The piece had been instigated after I witnessed the England pack concede a scrum penalty try to South Africa in Bloemfontein as they lost the second Test of their 2018 summer tour – and with it the series – after being blasted back over their own line.
It was such a rare occurrence during three decades of watching England scrums that it stood out like a warning beacon. The England props were Kyle Sinckler and Mako Vunipola, and their South African counterparts (fresh off the bench) were Thomas du Toit, now with Bath, and Steven Kitshoff.
The article also drew on the encyclopaedic scrummaging knowledge of Phil Keith-Roach, the scrum coach of the 2003 England World Cup-winning squad. With his customary laser-like focus, Keith-Roach said he found the lack of attention paid to the England scrum’s shortcomings against the Springboks alarming.
He commented: “It has a huge physical and mental effect on the game, whether it is now or at the World Cup, and it is frequently the difference between winning and losing. That is why the scrum is not a minor issue.”
His concern was magnified because what we had witnessed was a complete contradiction of the regularly repeated claims by Eddie Jones that he would restore England’s traditional scrum dominance.
We do not have to detail here the England scrum collapse in the first half of the 2019 World Cup final which led to their comprehensive defeat by South Africa. However, we should examine with utmost scrutiny why four years later England’s same scrum shortcomings were brutally exposed again by South Africa in their 2023 World Cup semi-final loss.
This story is from the December 17, 2023 edition of The Rugby Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 17, 2023 edition of The Rugby Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
YOUNG GUNS
SEANKERR HARLEQUINS & ENGLAND U20 CENTRE
PGP deal is nothing but a waste of time
I CAN’T help thinking that the new Professional Game Partnership (PGP) is nothing but a waste of time as I can’t see how it is going to make any difference to how the game operates or how it will actually help clubs keep players and reduce the financial strain they are under.
Tries galore as Jake leads the Crusaders title party
WITH Dings stalwarts Charlie Taylor and Jake Holcombe reaching the milestones of 250 and 200 appearances respectively, the massive win over Camborne was a fitting end to the season.
It's title delight for the Titans!
ROTHERHAM Titans are the champions!
Lions survive as Patrick heroics seal late glory
THE final throws of the 2023-24 season saw Sale take on Leicester Lions at Heywood Road, with the visitors looking for a victory to ensure their survival.
35 years on and Tim's charity still full of hope
IF YOU believe rugby is the ultimate team sport – which I still do – it is tempting to superimpose all its many fine qualities into other team environments.
'Ireland in blue' will provide stiffest test
PHIL Dowson and Leo Cullen first crossed paths in European action 10 seasons ago when Northampton did something they had never done before nor since: beating Leinster in Dublin.
Cardiff left in a mess by lively Edinburgh
CARDIFF’S last appearance at the Arms Park this season ended miserably as Edinburgh picked up a valuable four points in their quest for an end of season playoff spot.
RED ROSES
MADDIE FEAUNATI EXETER CHIEFS BACK ROW
Sharks look to have edge in Diamond derby
SALE boss Alex Sanderson has thanked Steve Diamond, his opposite number at Newcastle, for giving him extra motivation to win what has been dubbed ‘the Diamond derby’.