The Tykes were kicked out of the competition on Wednesday after fielding forward Aiden Marsh in the teams' first-round replay - a game the League One side won 3-0.
Marsh had been on loan at York City when the original tie at Oakwell, a 3-3 draw, took place on November 3 before being recalled by Neill Collins' side three days later.
The Football Association investigated and Barnsley accepted the decision against them, deciding not to appeal, meaning Horsham will travel to League Two's basement side Sutton United this Saturday - only the second time in their history they have reached the second round.
Di Paola had been planning for a Pitching In Premier Division fixture at Hastings that day before discovering his team had received the incredible news this week, with one win now meaning they could draw a Premier League team next.
"It's quite crazy, quite unprecedented," he said.
This story is from the November 26, 2023 edition of The Non-League Football Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the November 26, 2023 edition of The Non-League Football Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
LOTTERY'S NO FUN FOR LEE!
Eagles can soar but Bircham jokes he won't enjoy it
BIRD EYES A WAY BACK IN
Tanners boss keeps perspective
VICTORY IS FOR OUR HERO GEE!
CHICHESTER CITY dedicated their five-star play-off victory to late assistant manager Graeme Gee after this one-sided encounter sent them up in style.
JAMES' HEROES TAKE A BOW
BOWERS & Pitsea bounced straight back to Step 3 foot ball after a tense penalty shootout victory over Essex rivals Brentwood Town, who in turn lost a second final shootout in three years.
STEVE'S SUITED AND LIVING DREAM
STEVE GARDENER thought he was just going for a pint with his dad and brother when he attended a meeting at the local ice rink to discuss restarting Romford Football Club.
AUSTIN'S BOYS ARE MOTORING
HARBOROUGH Town boss Mitch Austin said his side bagged the win and promotion they deserved after goals at either end of the game saw off promotion rivals Anstey Nomads.
WE'RE HEAD OVER HEELS!
Anchors seal a derby thriller
CABLES FINALLY CAN BELIEVE. JT!
PRESCOT Cables supporters have waited for more than a decade to celebrate promotion but knew this contest was over in little more than an hour.
WHITES TAKE A HARD LINE
SALISBURY boss Brian Dutton says his team won’t be bullied out of a place in the National League by big-spending AFC Totton.
THE BUCKS HAVE GOT FIZZ BACK
KEVIN WILKIN has urged his AFC Telford United promotion-chasers to take the club’s first major step back to redemption.