It is a debate that has been going on for years and right now is raging. Is menopause a female hormone deficiency with accompanying health risks? Or is it a natural process we are at risk of over-medicalising? Recently, an editorial in the British Medical Journal provoked a strong reaction. Penned by Martha Hickey, a professor of obstetrics and gynaecology at the University of Melbourne, and her colleagues, it argued that the medicalisation of menopause emphasises its negative aspects, increasing women’s anxiety about this life stage. The paper suggested we should change the narrative and normalise menopause by emphasising its positive or more neutral aspects. The position the authors took was that menopause is experienced in different ways and while women with severe symptoms, such as hot flushes, will often benefit from hormone replacement therapy (HRT), most will manage the process without medical intervention.
The backlash was immediate. In a response, also published in the BMJ, the high-profile British menopause specialist Louise Newson called the article “medical gaslighting”, saying she was appalled and saddened to read it.
“There has been a very strong kickback from the UK,” confirms Hickey. “People who are pushing for more HRT to be used are annoyed at what we’ve done and see it as being retrograde. It evoked a lot of vitriol that we said there could be some good things associated with menopause.”
This story is from the July 23 - 29, 2022 edition of New Zealand Listener.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the July 23 - 29, 2022 edition of New Zealand Listener.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Morning songs
On a recent early and glorious Saturday morning - it was 4°C outside I let the complaining chickens out. Chickens never stop complaining.
Upwardly mobile
Climate-friendly e-scooters are proliferating but there are stumbling blocks for users and non-users.
A potent brew
There's a correlation between moderate coffee drinking and reduced risk of colorectal cancer - but evidence of a causal link is still percolating.
Food saviours
A little bit of silliness lightens the mood on the serious topic of food waste.
Ode to old masters
The Polynesian sound and Auckland's ska-punk scene are remembered in new releases.
Weaving Welsh with waiata
Te reo meets Cymraeg in a musical project partly spearheaded by Kawiti Waetford, an opera singer with connections to Wales.
Culture warrior
Activist and scholar Ngahuia te Awek6otuku achieved several firsts in society but had to fight many battles to get there.
An age-old problem
Is our lifespan fixed, or might we be able to slow down or even abolish ageing? And what would we do if we could?
When Jim becomes James
'What would white people do to a slave who had learned to read?' This impressive reimagining of Huckleberry Finn seeks to find out.
Manhattan transfer
A Kiwi movie star led the charge for an Anzac garden atop New York's Rockefeller Centre that's still in use today.