If you're looking for what's successful, follow box-office rankings. 12th Fail (2023) was a rare movie that was loved by critics and made money too.
Kenneth Turan, film critic for the LA Times, didn't enjoy Titanic when the film was released in 1997. AO Scott of The New York Times dismissed the 2012 blockbuster The Avengers as "grinding, hectic emptiness". Both films have thrilled audiences around the world and made hundreds of millions. Meanwhile, restaurant reviews are often out of sync with a user rating on a delivery app. In the book-publishing world, readers and reviews are routinely at loggerheads. Even critical reviews of runway shows can make or break a popular designer.
So, does it help to listen to the critics? Or do the crowds really know more than a handful of experts? It's tricky territory. But here are some general guidelines.
Watch out for exaggeration.
"With new restaurants, "catchphrases such as 'Must Try' and 'Hidden Gem' used without justification are worrying signs", says Nikhil Merchant, blogger and writer. Other suspicious terms: "Offbeat", "Instagram-worthy". For books, steer clear of "This book that will change your life". Wellread folks rarely use it.
Run an authenticity check.
This story is from the May 11, 2024 edition of Brunch.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the May 11, 2024 edition of Brunch.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Encore competence
Some actors did so well in arole, it's déja vu with every new character they play. Can these 10 talents break free?
School of rock
From cassettes to CDs, from iPods to streaming, some Indian bands have stayed put as the world, and music changed. See how four bands recall the time that was, and what it takes to rock on today
Animal crossings
If you ever feel out of place, think about these 10 species that are thriving far from home
Silk road tripping
Camels, caravans, Chevrolets. Driving down the same road in Uzbekistan 30 years later brings back memories and gives one hope for the future
Guess who's coming to dinner
Some guests take their welcome much too seriously, don't think twice about being disrespectful, and are wholly unbearable. Here's how to identify them
I of the needle
Century-old fabrics, designs sourced from museums, inspiration from old photos, creative hacks to turn back time. Check out how Indian costume designers are making every period detail shine
Another caper around Capri
The legendary resort town is relatively unspoiled and glamorous. The food is better than it used to be, if you know how to skip the tourist traps
Unscrambling the data
Free-range, natural, organic, cage-free. How good can eggs get, anyway? And why are restaurants obsessed about it?
Let's talk about me again
Insta Reels are out to paint everyone as narcissists. Here's how to tell regular confidence from dangerous disorder
The magic of meet-cutes
Boy meets girl. It's awkward but adorable. First contact can make or break arom-com. Is there a formula for getting it right?