There is seemingly no end to miracle additives on the market, all offering gardeners the appealing promise that they will make your plants bigger or healthier - or possibly even both. Often there is little, if any, way of knowing whether or not they work the claims made by these products may simply not have been adequately tested, and sometimes it's hard to tell what's in them.
There are at least three that should make you pause for thought before parting with your hard-earned cash: rockdust, biochar and mycorrhizal fungi.
Rockdust
Apparently there's almost nothing this finely ground volcanic rock can't do, including producing bigger yields, healthier crops, better flavour and improved resistance to pests, disease and drought. Fortunately, there have been two big, well-designed scientific studies of the effects of rockdust, one in Scotland and the other in Sweden, and both found exactly the same: nothing. No effect on yield, plant nutrient content or soil chemistry.
These studies also show why they found nothing. As the Scottish analysis puts it, a high degree of rock weathering was required to release small quantities of trace elements from rockdust samples. In short, it's not easy to get anything out of rockdust, and even when you do it's mostly sodium, with small amounts of calcium and even smaller amounts of other constituents. So the most rockdust might sometimes do is raise soil pH a little, although in the Scottish study it didn't.
This story is from the June 2023 edition of Gardens Illustrated.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the June 2023 edition of Gardens Illustrated.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
LAZY DAYS
Alice Vincent has had a hectic 2023, but for next year she's come up with a cunning plan to give herself more time and reduce her carbon footprint
SCULPTING THE LANDSCAPE
Charlotte Rowe's elegant design for a country garden in Hampshire fuses modern and traditional styles and captures the Zeitgeist for naturalism with a contemporary edge
Flavour of the seasons
Smallholder and former chef Julius Roberts suggests three easy, warming recipes for a winter feast with seasonal produce
JOINT ENTERPRISE
In southwest Germany, a couple have combined structural grasses and perennials with good seedheads in their garden to great effect, especially when touched by winter frost
COUNT YOUR BLESSINGS
There is a biodiversity loss crisis, but research into the wildlife found in gardens has made it clear just how important these spaces are as habitat. Discover how much you can learn, and gain, by identifying and documenting what you find beyond your back door
MATTHEW BIGGS
Horticulture's nicest practitioner on his journey from sweeping playgrounds to Gardeners' Question Time via offering gardening advice to insomniacs
YOUNG AT HEART
The garden of the late, great landscape architect Jacques Wirtz, which is more than 50 years old, is now being renewed by his children
PITTOSPORUM
These evergreen shrubs come in a multitude of sizes and shapes with shiny, often variegated or colourful leaves and small scented flowers
Festive flourishes
Entertain in style this Christmas with ideas for natural decorations from Swallows & Damsons
LUKE SENIOR
A former Ruth Borun scholar at Great Dixter, Luke is now one of the garden's full time gardeners