Friends and neighbors welcomed invitations to the intimate dinner parties and lavish annual New Year’s Eve bash thrown by Timothy Smith and Herb Swilley and set in the tropical decor of their home in Ocala, Fla. Yet even those closest to the pair—who were married in a purple-themed celebration in 2015—considered them to be something of an odd couple: Smith, 59, the executive director of a senior living center, was fun-loving and liked to entertain. “He was caring and quite flamboyant,” says Tammy Warner, a former colleague. On the other hand, Swilley, 55, a self-employed handyman, was sometimes boastful and aggressive. “He had to be the big man on campus,” says Warner, 56. “I always thought he was all talk.”
Not anymore. On March 25, Marion County Sheriff’s officers, performing a welfare check after Smith failed to show up for work, found his body inside an Ocala apartment that the couple reportedly maintained for sex dates with other people. Dressed in just a tank top and shoes, Smith had ligature marks on his neck and blunt trauma to his head and genitals, according to a probable-cause affidavit. Police say a toxicology test later determined that Smith had been dosed with 30 times the recommended amount of diphenhydramine, the active ingredient in Benadryl.
This story is from the December 25, 2023 edition of People US.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 25, 2023 edition of People US.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Meghan's New Moves
Meghan Markle is heading into spring and summer with a tasty new business venture.
LUCKY TO SURVIVE
YEARS AFTER TRAUMATIC ATTACKS, TWO WOMEN WHO GOT AWAY FORM A HEALING
JON BON JOVI - THE UN BREAKABLE
THE BELOVED ROCKER LOOKS BACK ON HIS BAND'S RUNAWAY SUCCESS AND REVEALS HOW HE'S RECOVERING FROM CAREERTHREATENING VOCAL ISSUES
heartbreak, fury &finding happiness
THE POP SUPERSTAR TELLS ALL ON HER DEEPLY PERSONAL NEW ALBUM THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT
A Field for Healing
Shortly into their two-hour drive to a San Diego soccer tournament, 12-year-old Tommy Mark turned to his mom, Nikki, and began peppering her with questions about the meaning of life.
TIFFANY HADDISH'S PATH TO PEACE
Every morning Tiffany Haddish wakes up and takes stock.
ETHAN HAWKE - PROUDEST DAD ALIVE
FOR HIS LATEST MOVIE, THE FATHER OF FOUR TOOK ON A NEW ROLE: DIRECTING HIS DAUGHTER MAYA
MELANIE LYNSKEY - Hitting Her Stride
Melanie Lynskey has her eyes on the prize-the Nobel Peace Prize.
JACK WAGNER - GETTING WISER & LETTING GO
Every time Jack Wagner steps onto the set of the Hallmark Channel drama When Calls the Heart, he's reminded of a simpler time before technology was so deeply ingrained in everyday life.
HEALING AFTER HER DAUGHTER'S SUICIDE- I'm So Thankful for the Time We Had❜
Simpkins understood the depths of her daughter's long struggle with depression.