One of the fiercest historical controversies in recent years exploded last summer, sparked by an essay entitled ‘Is History History?’. Written by James H Sweet, then president of the influential American Historical Association, it was printed in that organisation’s magazine in August 2022. The global social media backlash was overwhelming. Angry readers branded his article “crap”, “smug condescension”, even “white supremacist”. Scholars around the world weighed in, along with media commentators. An opinion piece in The New
York Times called it “one of the confusing messes that pop up from time to time in the highest reaches of academia”, while The Washington Post mocked “academia’s most recent pratfall”.
In his piece, Sweet, professor of African history at the University of Wisconsin at Madison, criticised a shift toward ‘presentism’ – the study of the past through the lens of the present – in historical writing. He warned that more and more historians let current concerns dictate the focus of their scholarship, giving in to the “allure of political relevance” or even, in more extreme cases, using history as a “grab bag” to advance political goals such as identity politics in their work. Moreover, he advised interpreting “elements of the past not through the optics of the present but within the worlds of our historical actors”. If we “read the past through the prism of contemporary social justice issues”, he declared, we risk producing history that “ignores the values and mores of people in their own times, as well as change over time, neutralizing the expertise that separates historians from those in other disciplines”.
This story is from the June 2023 edition of BBC History UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the June 2023 edition of BBC History UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
The Aztecs at war
RHIANNON DAVIES discovers why war was so important to the Mesoamerican people - and why they believed a badly cooked meal could prevent a soldier from shooting straight
Towering achievement
NATHEN AMIN explores a 13th-century stronghold that was built to subdue independent-minded Welsh people, yet has since become a symbol of courage in the face of overwhelming odds
Eighteenth-century mushroom ketchup
ELEANOR BARNETT shares her instructions for making a flavourful sauce with roots in south-east Asia
Goodbye to the gilded age
JOHN JACOB WOOLF is won over by an exploration of the Edwardian era, which looks beyond the golden-era cliché to find a nation beset by a sense of unease
The power of the few
Subhadra Das's first book catches two particular waves in current publishing.
The 'badass' icon
One of the problems with biography, if an author is not careful, is that it can quickly become hagiography.
Ghosts of Germany's past
KATJA HOYER is impressed by a study of a nation's attempts to grapple with the crimes it perpetrated during the Second World War
A window onto England's soul
SARAH FOOT has high praise for a book that traces the evolution of English Christianity over the course of 1400 years, through the lives of its greatest thinkers
"There was a general perception that Queen Victoria's mourning was neither normal nor acceptable”
JUDITH FLANDERS talks to Rebecca Franks about her new book, which delves into the customs surrounding dying, death and mourning in Victorian Britain
"Indigenous children were forcibly separated from their families"
HIDDEN HISTORIES... KAVITA PURI on the legacy of Canada's residential schools