THE exclusive breeding rights to the late record-breaking dressage star Totilas are held by Paul Schockemöhle, a Dutch court has ruled in a dispute over the dead stallion's semen.
The case involves Totilas's past owner Kees Visser and Mr Schockemöhle, and has been rumbling through German and Dutch courts for years.
H&H reported on an interim decision by a German court to prevent Mr Visser from selling Totilas's frozen semen (news, 11 April 2021), which was upheld later that year following an appeal.
Once the interim injunction proceedings were concluding, main proceedings had to be initiated to conclude the dispute by a final decision. Mr Schockemöhle did so at the Oldenburg Regional Court, and these proceedings are ongoing.
At the same time, Mr Visser initiated main proceedings in the Netherlands, which have recently concluded, where he sought the declaration that he is entitled to sell Totilas's semen. He also sought damages of up to €18m (£15.93 million) against Mr Schockemöhle.
The Court of Gelderland in Arnhem, the Netherlands, dismissed Mr Visser's claim on 15 February 2023.
VERBAL AGREEMENT
THE court document was anonymised, referring to Mr Visser as the plaintiff and Mr Schockemöhle the defendant.
The case hinged on whether buying Totilas in 2010 for €9.5m, in a verbal agreement, included exclusive breeding rights. It also focused on whether a box of 301 semen straws with a value of at least several hundred thousand euros" delivered to the new owner were a gift or not.
Mr Visser, who had frozen semen from when he owned Totilas, argued that Mr Schockemöhle bought only the horse, not exclusive breeding rights. After Totilas's death in 2020, his former owner listed the frozen semen for sale online via a third party, which prompted the dispute and legal wrangling.
This story is from the March 16, 2023 edition of Horse & Hound.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the March 16, 2023 edition of Horse & Hound.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
New competition and classification to mean dressage will be for all
The new partnerships with British Dressage will provide opportunities for riders with intellectual disabilities
Pressure grows on the FEI to tackle concerns in dressage
A leading judge has made some recommendations he believes will help support the sport's future
Aidan Coleman
Just a week after he announced his enforced retirement with a career-ending injury, Aidan Coleman talks through his raw emotions with Kate Johnson as he ponders life outside the weighing room
Badminton groundsman
Phil Cole on flawless going for cross-country, perfecting his craft on polo pitches and being at the mercy of the weather
Pulling power
Carriage-driving horses have a very specific job, and with that can come specific injury risks. Rosie Mould MRCVS explains
'Plenty to get your teeth into'
This year's Badminton track is testing, but fair, says Nicola Wilson, the 2021 European champion who finished in the top 10 at this five-star four times
Townend leads British domination
The world number one spearheads a British clean sweep of the podium as he contests his 100th five-star
Birch is back in the big time
A former Olympic reserve rider scores her first international win in four years, while Kelsall specialists make their mark again
Comeback queens reign
Rehab work pays off for Anna Ross as she makes a winning return, while a pair of young riders' birthday wishes come true
Pender keeps it in the family
Ireland's Mikey Pender begins a remarkable grand prix winning double and it all comes together in the ring for a \"special character\"