25-YEAR COLD CASE We're making Paula proud
New Zealand Woman's Weekly|May 17, 2021
LOSING A LOVED ONE SO TRAGICALLY HAS INSPIRED THE FAMILY TO HELP OTHERS
Fleur Guthrie

On the back of Norma Brown’s bedroom door hangs a beautiful maroon velvet jacket, adorned with diamanté buttons. As she tenderly gathers it in her hands and strokes the fabric, the retired widow can’t believe it’s been 25 years this month since her beloved daughter Paula last wore it, while on a girls’ night out in Sydney, Australia.

The jacket came home that night, but Paula didn’t. The young hairdresser disappeared from the city’s bustling Oxford Street on May 4, 1996, after becoming separated from her friends.

Paula’s battered body was found eight days later. She was killed with two blows to the head and dumped in bushland south of the central city, in a murder that has remained unsolved.

“The hardest thing for us is not having that closure or sense of justice being served,” says Norma, 75, sitting alongside her son and Paula’s younger brother Daryl, 52.

“It feels like unfinished business,” he agrees. “Somebody out there knows what really happened to her.”

Revisiting those first nightmarish days – after getting the call in Auckland telling them that 30-year-old Paula was missing – the duo have their theories over what occurred that fateful night when her drink was proven to have been spiked.

“Paula ran her own hair salon and one of her staff was leaving to have a baby, so after work on the Friday, they all went out to celebrate at a restaurant,” tells Norma. “They loved dancing, so they went to a nightclub up on the main road. Paula had taken her velvet coat off and hung it on her chair, then went downstairs to the ladies’ toilets. Unbeknown to her friends, there was a door from the toilet that went into another bar, which Paula had gone through.

“I think she had every intention to go back upstairs as she wouldn’t have left her jacket behind. Her friends went down to the toilets, couldn’t see her anywhere and assumed she had gone to catch the last ferry home to Manly, where she lived with her fiancé David. Her friend picked up her jacket and took it home.

“The next morning, David rang her friends, asking, “Did Paula end up staying at your place?” They said, “No, we thought she got the last boat home.” But David had waited at the ferry terminal until after the last boat. Paula wasn’t on it. That’s when he rang the police and called us in New Zealand.”

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM NEW ZEALAND WOMAN'S WEEKLYView All

Write stuff TESSA DUDER

The author who inspired Kiwi girls to follow their dreams has achieved some very big goals of her own

6 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

KIWIS PAYING IT FORWARD - We're doing it for love

It’s Volunteer Week and to celebrate these unsung heroes, Rebekah Hebenton finds out what ignites their passion

2 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Royally delighted THE QUEEN BOUNCES BACK

It’s like a weight has been lifted from the Monarch’s shoulders

3 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

SHE'S A REAL PEARL

A publican is fishing for answers when her oyster supplier is found dead

1 min read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Keisha's Shorty confession - I'M SO EMBARRASED'

The talented soap star tells why she can’t always hold her head up high!

4 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Kate's Biden her time!

The duchess and the First Lady got on famously

2 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Pippa's superpower - WHY I HAD TO STEP UP

The beloved TV presenter is all about giving those in need a fair go

6 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Five minutes with...HUGH VAN CUYLENBURG

The Aussie motivational speaker, 40, is thankful for so many things

1 min read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Julianne's gems ‘TURNING 60 IS A PRIVILEGE'

A hit on the big screen, she works just as hard at keeping her family happy

4 mins read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021

Back in the SADDLE

He may have been the charity race leader, but there was no chance Charles was going to finish first!

1 min read
New Zealand Woman's Weekly
June 28, 2021
RELATED STORIES

A Dementia That Can Be Cured

“I couldn’t even sign my name,” says an ex-teacher. It took years for doctors to spot the real cause.

8 mins read
Reader's Digest US
June 2021

My Pandemic Project

I have been an avid woodworker for years, working on one project or another in my spare time.

3 mins read
Popular Woodworking
June 2021

Khloe & Tristan: BETRAYED AGAIN!

KHLOÉ KARDASHIAN IS LIVID AFTER AN INSTA MODEL CLAIMS TRISTAN THOMPSON IS BACK TO HIS CHEATING WAYS.

3 mins read
Star
May 17, 2021

5 completely honest confessions from Ruth Righi

You know Ruth Righi best as Sydney Reynolds on Disney’s Sydney to the Max (back on Disney Channel for a third season starting March 19). And while the 15-year-old actually has a lot in common with her onscreen alter ego (to start, they're both biracial and amazing bass players), we decided it was time to dig even deeper. Below are five brutally honest, real-life confessions straight from Ruth herself.

2 mins read
Girls' Life magazine
April/May 2021

Off the Beaten Path

When a hiker falls 75 feet from a mountain cliff, a young stranger goes to extremes to save her

3 mins read
Reader's Digest US
April 2021

BIRTHDAY BUOY

GH’s Maurice Benard (Sonny) Marks His Birthday With A Special Gift For His Fans

6 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
March 08, 2021

Bills Digest BUZZ Box: Five hot topics Bills fans are talking about

Bills Digest editor Mark Ludwiczak and editor-at-large Chris Brown weigh in on a handful of the hottest subjects Bills fans have been sounding off about in e-mails to our offices, radio call-in shows and Internet message boards. Have an opinion? Feel free to send an email to Chris (AskChris@bills.nfl.net) or Mark (Mark@asmpublishing.com).

4 mins read
Bills Digest
March 29, 2021

1st & Ten with JOSH NORMAN

Nothing has gone according to plan for everyone this year, but that’s particularly true for Bills cornerback Josh Norman.

10+ mins read
Bills Digest
January 4, 2021

Paul Andrew Hutton

True West’s historian is a natural storyteller whose love of country and the West makes him one of best in his field.

5 mins read
True West
January 2021

Our 19th Annual Celebration of the Absolute Best of the West!

For many in 2020, great treks, trips and vacations to the American West were put on hold because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

2 mins read
True West
January 2021