Frankenlaw
Fairlady|January 2020
Babies conceived after their parents’ death, toddlers inheriting embryos, women giving birth to IVF twins that aren’t theirs, or related to each other… Significant advances in technology have opened up a whole new world of ethical and legal dilemmas. Fact truly is stranger than fiction in some of these real-life cases.
LIESL ROBERTSON

Conception through IVF has become so ubiquitous that it’s hard to believe the procedure is still relatively new. The world’s first test-tube baby was born in 1978 (Louise Joy Brown is 41 now), and the first birth from a frozen embryo only took place in 1984 when Zoe Leyland, now 35, was born in Australia. It seemed like science fiction at the time; nowadays it is hardly worth mentioning.

Advances relating to IVF have opened up a world of possibilities, some of which have become increasingly commonplace. Kim and Kanye selected the gender of each of their four kids. (Gender selection is legal in the US, unlike other parts of the world.) Sofia Vergara has been locked in a custody battle for her frozen embryos with her ex-fiancé since 2015. And just two months ago, FAIRLADY ran a story on another development gaining popularity, namely snowflake babies: ‘leftover’ IVF embryos given up for adoption.

But now that we’ve taken conception into our own hands, human error is bound to sneak in, and with every medical advancement, new ethical dilemmas arise. Here are just a few of the stories that have made headlines around the world.

The ol’ switcheroo

It was all fun and games when Jason Bateman hijacked Jen Aniston’s sperm donor sample in 2010’s The Switch. (Not really – it’s a reprehensible thing to do, despite the frothy romcom spin.) But with an estimated one million embryos on ice (that’s just in the US), there are bound to be mix-ups.

After spending months unsuccessfully trying to get pregnant via IVF, Armenian-American couple Anni and Ashot Manukyan received an urgent message from their LA-based clinic. They were to come in for ‘routine quality control’ testing. That turned out to be a ruse; there’d been a major mishap: the clinic had mixed up their embryos, and their son had been born to two total strangers on the other side of the country.

There was also a second baby in the mix – his twin, who was related to neither the New York couple nor Anni and Ashot; he is the genetic child of a third couple.

Both Anni and the unnamed New York woman, known only as A.P., had had embryo transfers at CHA Fertility Center for IVF on the same day in 2018. Anni’s failed and A.P. became pregnant with twins. If it hadn’t been for the fact that the New York couple was Asian, and the babies didn’t appear to be, the switch might have gone unnoticed. DNA tests confirmed that neither of the babies was genetically theirs; A.P. had been nothing more than an involuntary surrogate.

‘All of a sudden my brain went to: I didn’t get to bond with my baby. I wasn’t able to carry him. I wasn’t able to hold him… feel him inside of me,’ said Anni, in a video. The Manukyans, understandably, wanted their son back. But spare a thought for the New York couple: they had undergone IVF at great expense, had spent months preparing for the birth of their twins, and A.P. had carried them to term and given birth – only to have them both taken away after a few weeks.

A judge ruled in favour of the Manukyans. Anni held her son for the first time in a New York hotel. The third couple were awarded custody of their son; A.P. and her husband were left empty-cribbed.

It’s not the first time something like this has happened. In 1998, Donna Fasano gave birth to twins: one was genetically related to her; the other wasn’t. The second embryo had come from a black couple, the Perry-Rogerses, who were patients at the same fertility clinic. Judges awarded custody to the genetic parents, and later denied visiting rights to the Fasanos.

Courts determine rights on a case by case basis. In 2004, a woman in California fell pregnant after a fertility clinic transferred the wrong embryo into her. But, as the embryo had been created for another couple using the husband’s sperm and an unrelated egg donor, a judge ruled that the father had to split custody with the gestational mother. Although neither she nor the wife of the genetic father was genetically related to the baby, she had carried the child and therefore had more of a legal claim.

‘There’s no definitive answer here as to who should have custody and visitation rights,’ says US family law professor, Naomi Cahn. If there is no obvious racial mismatch, some of these mix-ups may never be detected. ‘We have no idea how often this [kind of mistake] happens, and there’s no requirement that prevents it from happening,’ says Dov Fox, a law professor and the author of Birth Rights and Wrongs.

Anni, meanwhile, is haunted by what might have happened to her other embryos. ‘I’m just praying to God I don’t have another son or daughter out there,’ she says.

Save his swimmers

Here’s another moral conundrum that has no set laws governing it: the retrieval of sperm, post-mortem. In some countries (France, Canada, and Germany, to name a few) the procedure is illegal, and in the UK, men need to provide written permission before their deaths.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM FAIRLADYView All

How to Survive the Feast-Or Famine Cycle

It’s empowering to have more than one income stream, but there is a downside: it’s easy to splurge when money is plentiful, but what about the lean months? Three self-starters share their tips for keeping an even keel through good and bad.

6 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

Kaley's Comet

Kaley Cuoco was so beguiling as Penny on The Big Bang Theory that she soon became one of the highest paid actors in television. With HBO’s comedic thriller series The Flight Attendant, she entered exciting, slightly sinister new territory – but it proved her range as an actress and cemented her broad-based appeal.

7 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

Let the Music Play

My dad died days before the global lockdown. While I was trapped within four walls, music and dancing gave me reason to smile again.

7 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

How to Make Your Own Luck

Luck isn’t easy to measure or study, but those who have managed to do it discovered it’s not the work of fate – it’s a skill you can cultivate and improve. So, how do you go about it?

8 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

Local Flavour

Stocking up your pantry? These artisanal foods are guaranteed to ignite the senses of home chefs everywhere. Meet the foodies behind two of South Africa’s tastiest brands.

7 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

The Comfort of Ritual

Rituals imbue our lives with depth and meaning. And in times of uncertainty, they are even more important because they create a sense of grounding.

8 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

Get Your Shine Back!

When the last of the summer heat is over, it’s important to take time to reverse any hair damage caused by sun and sea water.

5 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

The Rise of the Personal Shopper

It’s not a new concept, but the number of people who make a living from sourcing goods on behalf of clients is on the rise. We talked to three personal shoppers to find out what it takes.

7 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

Back to the Wild

Imagine camping in the Little Karoo… a billion stars above you, the ancient desert beneath, the insistent flapping of your canvas tent in the cold night air. Then banish all the rustic images this conjures up – because Dwyka Tented Lodge will confound all your expectations.

6 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022

A Good (Mo) Hair Day

"Beauty Mokgwamme had other dreams, but circumstances took her exactly where she was meant to be."

3 mins read
Fairlady
March/April 2022
RELATED STORIES

NIGHTMARE ON LAKE SUPERIOR

One by one, the three kayakers capsized in the cold, angry water. Then they became separated.

10 mins read
Reader's Digest US
June 2022

MAKE ROOM FOR USELESSNESS

Entrepreneurs want to make useful things. But what if that holds us back from truly inspired ideas?

4 mins read
Entrepreneur
June 2022

point that piece! an A to Z guide

All the tricks to maximizing your DIY skills and making old furniture look better than new.

9 mins read
HGTV Magazine
June 2022

Four Must-See Crime Dramas

ANNIKA | UNDER THE BANNER OF HEAVEN | SHINING GIRLS | SIGNORA VOLPE

1 min read
TV Guide Magazine
April 25 - May 08, 2022

MIKE SOLANA WANTS YOU TO COMMIT THOUGHT-CRIMES

The Hereticon organizer on deplatforming, tribalism, and why tech dudes and journalists are natural enemies

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
June 2022

Ex-norton Motorcycles Boss Stuart Garner Avoids Jail After Investing £11 Million of Pension Savings

Stuart Garner has received a suspended prison sentence after pleading guilty to using other people’s pension money to invest in his own business, Norton motorcycles.

3 mins read
Bike SA
May 2022

Four SCORE

Annika Noelle Reflects On How Her Life Has Changed Since Joining B&B In 2018.

6 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
May 02, 2022

Form Fixers

A “perfect” running style doesn't exist, but there *are* expert-approved ways to tweak your stride at any speed so each step is efficient, powerful, and injury-free. Time to lace up....

5 mins read
Women's Health
April 2022

Finally, well done

The medium-rare New York strip. The ice-cold martini. The tableside Caesar. For ages, THE STEAKHOUSE and its trappings signified success and a damn good time... even if the food and service could be hit-or-miss. But now, thanks to a handful of splashy, CHEF-DRIVEN RESTAURANTS from New York to Chicago to San Francisco, the party has reached a new golden age. Here are the fresh temples of beef worth traveling for.

7 mins read
Esquire
April - May 2022

More Heartache Titute for DIV

He lost his daughter to cancer in 2019. Now former Bok coach Pieter de Villiers is grieving again after his beloved wife drowned in a friend's pool

5 mins read
YOU South Africa
21 April 2022