DEADLINE DECISIONS
Niner Report|December 2020
Alexander trade a harbinger of tough choices looming for 49ers
Craig Massei

With the NFL trade deadline looming last year, the 49ers pulled the trigger on a major trade to bring in accomplished veteran wide receiver Emmanuel Sanders, providing San Francisco with a final piece for its offensive puzzle in a move that transformed a rising, undefeated team from ascending playoff contender into Super Bowl favorite in the NFC.

Flash forward to the league’s trade deadline this year, when San Francisco traded away veteran linebacker Kwon Alexander, another key piece both on and off the field that joined the 49ers in 2019 and helped transform them into a championship operation, instantly becoming instrumental in their quick climb back to elite status.

What a difference a deadline makes.

And, as is often true in the NFL, what a difference in outlook and perspective that a year can make for virtually any team. Particularly a team such as the 49ers, a well-built outfit that appeared to have it all last season as a rising powerhouse stocked with talent and star performers that provided plenty of evidence it was built for the long haul.

Until maybe it wasn’t.

Nobody could have foreseen the practically apocalyptic surge of injuries that have swept over the San Francisco roster this season, a battlefield rout that has seen the 49ers have an astounding 23 players go on the injured reserve list through the middle of November and several other key starters and vital performers also miss one or more games — often more — with injuries.

With a 4-4 record at the league’s Nov. 3 deadline this year, still fighting valiantly to remain in playoff contention in the ultra-tough NFC West despite taking a numbing assault of body blows from every direction, the 49ers found themselves facing an unexpected dilemma that had them teetering on both sides of the deadline fence.

Should they be buyers or sellers this time around?

To be sure, the 49ers still had a chance to both save and resurrect their season. To do that, certainly the logical approach with a decimated roster would be to bring in reinforcements rather than send away a player such as Alexander, a leader in the locker room and difference-maker on the field when he’s at the top of his game.

But at the same time, the 49ers also had to keep an eye on the future and keep it real about what direction the team really is headed in 2020.

So the 49ers sent Alexander, one of the early keys to their rapid development into a defensive juggernaut last season, packing to New Orleans in exchange for veteran linebacker Kiki Alonso and a conditional fifth-round draft pick, sending away a player with potential to be a defensive force to one of San Francisco’s top rivals for NFC supremacy.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM NINER REPORTView All

EIGHT IS ENOUGH

Set 49ers lineup still has several new starters

7 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

Calling all cornerbacks

Loss of Verrett exposes 49ers’ thin depth at CB

7 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

Always finding their way to run

49ers system accomplished at developing homegrown talent

9 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

ANOTHER COMEBACK?

Resilient veteran Verrett to miss rest of season

5 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

TOP 10 Rookie running backs

THE BACK LIST

3 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

STOCK UP STOCK DOWN

DEOMMODORE LENOIR | AMBRY THOMAS

4 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

Will Mostert run for 49ers again?

Raheem Mostert was primed this year to be the centerpiece of one of the NFL’s most dynamic offenses, featured as the lead performer in San Francisco’s grinding rushing attack while making his climb among the league’s top running backs.

5 mins read
Niner Report
October 2021

THE WONDER OF WARNER

49ers make All-Pro star highest-paid LB in NFL

9 mins read
Niner Report
August 31, 2021

Making the right choice at QB

In the weeks that follow after you read this — and perhaps sometime even sooner than that — Kyle Shanahan and the rest of the 49ers organization will make a titanic decision that will have present, future and perhaps even everlasting implications for the franchise. It will chart the course for the team’s pivotal 2021 season while determining whether San Francisco really does have the juice to return to powerhouse status and again be considered a legitimate contender to get back to the Super Bowl.

3 mins read
Niner Report
August 31, 2021

TOP 10 Linebacker seasons

Fred Warner vaulted to stardom with a spectacular 2020 season — and the 49ers rewarded him this summer with a $95.225 million deal that makes him the highest-paid inside linebacker in NFL history. By today’s standards, Warner’s performance last year was worth the money as he posted an Approximate Value of 19 — matching the highest score ever recorded by a San Francisco defender according to a Pro Football Reference formula that puts a single number on each player-season across all positions since 1960. Patrick Willis and NaVorro Bowman (twice) also had seasons with an AV of 19 as they dominate this list of the greatest individual seasons by a linebacker in 49ers history.

3 mins read
Niner Report
August 31, 2021
RELATED STORIES

2022 NFL Draft

Today's Sports Pick

1 min read
TV Guide Magazine
April 25 - May 08, 2022

LOVE TRIANGLE!

A source says Keith is "intimidated" by Alexander.

1 min read
Star
May 02, 2022

The Hardest Day on Set: The Northman

Dozens of extras, nonstop rain, and a village full of animals— what could go wrong?

5 mins read
New York magazine
April 25-May 8, 2022

Tom & Gisele: MARRIAGE IN CRISIS

AFTER AGREEING TO RETIRE TO SPEND MORE TIME WITH HIS FAMILY, FOOTBALL GREAT TOM BRADY BETRAYS HIS PROMISE TO WIFE GISELE BÜNDCHEN — AND SHE’S FURIOUS!

8 mins read
Star
April 04, 2022

George & Amal STRONGER THAN EVER

Happy wife, happy life! It’s been almost six years since George and Amal Clooney tied the knot in Italy, and they’re more in love than ever.

1 min read
Life & Style US
March 28, 2022

Tom Betrays Gisele!

Less than two months after announcing his retirement, Tom Brady is back, breaking his promise to his wife

2 mins read
inTouch
March 28, 2022

True North

Cruising Cape Breton Island’s captivating Cabot Trail in a Land Rover Defender

4 mins read
Maxim
March - April 2022

PORSCHE 911 GT3

DOMINATION IS IN ITS BLOOD

10 mins read
Motor Trend
April 2022

Get ready for the Super Bowl of gambling. There's a football game, too

A decade ago, one knowledgeable authority had deep reservations about the idea of the National Football League ever embracing legalized gambling. It would create a corrosive atmosphere in which every penalty or dropped pass—the normal ebbs and flows of games—“inevitably will fuel speculation, distrust, and accusations of point-shaving or game-fixing.” The moralist was none other than NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell, declaring the league’s opposition to expanding sports bookmaking outside of Nevada.

10+ mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
February 14, 2022

Family, Faith and Football

A new movie tells the story of NFL Hall of Famer Kurt Warner’s against-the odds rise to stardom

6 mins read
Newsweek
January 21, 2022