The Ocean of Rumi
Spirituality & Health|May/June 2020
SCHOLAR OF ISLAM AND RUMI LOVER POURIA MONTAZERI TALKS ABOUT THE CONTEXT THAT’S GETTING LOST IN TRANSLATION.
POURIA MONTAZERI

CERTAIN THINGS IN LIFE are so precious, so divinely perfect and sacred, that they don’t need any alterations. They arise from the compassionate and boundless Existence, touch our hearts, and return to that placeless place where nothing ever repeats, leaving us in awe and wonder. Such perennial pearls of wisdom invite us to wholeness. For me, Rumi’s teachings and poetry are some of those precious gifts in life.

There is something definite, deep, and full about the unadulterated, pure teachings of the masters. They resonate with our hearts and, as a result, make us nod in agreement like bobbleheads.

When, through love and dedication, they are applied, embodied, and manifested within one’s heart and daily life, they are as relevant and applicable today as they have been for centuries.

Sadly, Rumi’s is one of the countless sacred teachings that take a whole new shape and meaning when crossed over the invisible yet tangible boundary into the West.

Several issues contribute to the tendency to alter teachings. One is the practice of cultural appropriation, where, in this context, scholars and translators get to render teachings through their fixed lenses and understandings without necessarily having any experiential knowledge of the subject, including the language itself.

Much of Eastern religion goes through the Judeo-Christian lens and filter before it is deciphered. I see this as a shadow of real interfaith and inter-spiritual dialogues and practices. To understand anything fully, the thing needs to be isolated and examined as it is without any interference. This requires commitment, dedication, and the kind of single-minded focus and attention yogis, Sufis, saints, mystics, and scientists used and continue to use. But instead, convenient, buffet-style spirituality often results in spiritual constipation.

The other includes spiritual objectification. Teachings exist as perennial wisdom, and understanding those teachings can be difficult. But when the teachings are interpreted by people who are most interested in gaining money or followers, they are inevitably changed to suit the fleeting culture of the moment.

As one small example, the Farsi pronoun ou may mean he as well as she. The proper meaning is contextually determined. God is never referred to as He, yet He is used in almost all translations. This is a very crucial point, for the additional filter in itself veils one from truly understanding the original work.

I have to admit how grateful I am for all that Coleman Barks has done in familiarizing the Westerner with Rumi’s poetry. This gratitude is accompanied by my core belief that individuals like Barks are mere instruments. At the end of a song at a concert, we clap for the musicians and not for the instruments.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM SPIRITUALITY & HEALTHView All

TOO MUCH STUFF? FLOW AND F.L.O.W.

Inspired by Benedictine simplicity, BECKY GARRISON looks for ways to keep her space less cluttered.

6 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

RIGHT NOW, WE'RE ALL DYSREGULATED

Yoga teacher and somatic counselor HALA KHOURI shares ideas for moving toward self-regulation.

5 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

The REST Story

Despite a high-pressure job producing films, Tracee Stanley had everything under control. Prioritizing her own wellbeing made her more effective and efficient at work—which gave her time and space to prioritize her own wellbeing.

9 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

PEERING INTO THE FUTURE OF RETREATS

Retreat centers are ready to invite guests back onto their properties, but what that means may be vastly different in 2021 and beyond, even after the pandemic is under control.

4 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

6 SECRETS FOR PLANNING A RETREAT FOR A GROUP OF FRIENDS

You’ve envisioned it for ages—escaping for a retreat with a group of dear friends. You’re laughing together in terry-cloth robes and mud masks. Or maybe your gang is at a wilderness retreat, journaling around a fire pit. Perhaps your group is together deepening a faith practice, experiencing a festival, or traveling in an exotic locale. But getting your squad off on a retreat can easily become a logistical challenge (ever heard the term herding cats?). Here are six secrets for turning a “maybe someday” dream into a concrete, and pleasurable, reality.

2 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

WOUNDS AND THE WOMB

JULIE PETERS explores how to heal a relationship with the sacred womb, a place of death, life, and possibilities.

8 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

BE SQUIRRELY

Giant squirrels, giant lessons? Animal chaplain SARAH BOWEN explores what squirrels can show us about mindfulness.

4 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

5 PREDICTIONS FOR THE FUTURE OF RETREATS

The rustic, historic property once offered hot mineral soaks in private rooms with big clawfoot tubs and one of the best and largest wood-burning saunas in the States. Days frolicking between the steaming hot mineral baths, a cold creek, and the sauna—and nights spent without phone or wifi in a simple cabin in the woods. Hot tea, a warm fire, and a cool stack of magazines: My kind of bliss.

3 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Mar/Apr 2021

Visioning a Re-new-able Year

FLASHBACK: It’s December 31, 1999. Flushed from dancing, I’m perched on the steps of the Hilton Addis Ababa in Ethiopia, filled with anxiety about Y2K and the chaotic world around me.

4 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Jan/Feb 2021

STAYING IN FOR A VIRTUAL RETREAT?

HERE’S WHAT TO DO BEFOREHAND

3 mins read
Spirituality & Health
Jan/Feb 2021
RELATED STORIES

The Passion Of Trees

The snow no longer cloaks our mountains in white.

3 mins read
Lens Magazine
August 2020

The Four Eternal Truths

DR. SIMMI VALECHA shares her own journey of discovery, and how she found her purposes and joy in life. She also shares her four eternal truths, and how she has realized them in her life.

10+ mins read
Heartfulness eMagazine
August 2020

From Army Vet to Spice Queen

Kimberly Jung, a former Army engineer stationed in Afghanistan, found a smart and socially responsible way to bring saffron to the U.S.— and help Afghan farmers at the same time

3 mins read
Better Nutrition
June 2020

BEYONCE OPENS UP!

QUEEN BEY DISHES ON GIVING ZERO F**KS, EATING FUNYUNS AND SHOPPING AT TARGET!

2 mins read
Star
December 30, 2019

JAMMED JANUARY

As mercury dropped to a record low consistently, Kashmir faced the harshest winter in thirty years. With cascading effect on every sphere of life, Saima Bhat chronicles the hardships faced right from lack of mobility to management of frozen pipes

7 mins read
Kashmir Life
February 07, 2021

TURN BACK TIME

From colonial nostalgia to legendary tiger trails, 10 itineraries that bring back the past.

5 mins read
Condé Nast Traveller India
December 2020 - January 2021

Beyoncé's BABY JOY!

COULD THE SINGER BE SET TO WELCOME HER FOURTH CHILD?

1 min read
WHO
September 14, 2020

ALEJANDRÍA

Hace muchos años que visité durante unos días la egipcia Alejandría.

3 mins read
Viajar
Julio - Agosto 2020

Resplendent weaves

After a three-year break from designing, couturier JJ Valaya returns with Tabriz, a collection of furnishing fabrics

1 min read
Brides Today
February 2020

ON TOP OF THE GAME

From being the ‘baby’ in Arrambam to being a rocket scientist in Mission Mangal and turning a shooter for her latest Saand Ki Aankh, Taapsee Pannu has a quality about her that is very convincing. The pretty lass, who is arguably one of the busiest actors currently, also happens to have a matter-of-fact personality that makes her very convincing in person too. We felt for her in Pink, rooted for her in Mulk, had a squirmy time seeing her in Game Over and felt inspired by her in Saand Ki Aankh. We got an opportunity to chat with her recently and here's how well we got along with the brilliant Tapsee Pannu.

7 mins read
RITZ
January 2020