Lessons For Congress From Uttarakhand
Open|April 11, 2016

Lessons For Congress From Uttarakhand.

PR Ramesh

When Shakespeare wrote ‘Beware the ides of March’, he was not referring to Harish Rawat, Uttarakhand’s former Chief Minister, who isn’t much of a Caesar anyway. Yet, the Congress leadership apparently took the warning seriously in the hill state of Uttarakhand back in December 2012, when it inexplicably chose to elevate Vijay Bahuguna to the post of Chief Minister in Dehradun. In doing so, it rode roughshod over the legitimate claims of Harish Rawat to the chair. Rawat, through perseverance and strong-arm methods, managed to turn things in his favour in 2014, forcing the hand of the party high command. With just about a year left to go for the state’s assembly polls , the back story and ominous warning appear to have come back to bite the top leadership of the Congress and Rawat, after an emergency meeting of the Union Cabinet recommended that the state be placed under president’s rule.

In contention for power in Dehradun is the BJp. Since 2000, when Uttarakhand was first carved out as a state from Uttar Pradesh on a decision taken by the Vajpayee Government, the state has had seven chief ministers, mostly of the BJp. Only three were of the Congress: party stalwart ND Tiwari who assumed office in 2002; Vijay Bahuguna, son of another stalwart Hemwati Nandan Bahuguna and brother of Up party chief Rita Bahuguna, in 2012; and Harish Singh Rawat in 2014. In the same period, Up has had only five chief ministers. Up, a larger state, has experienced greater political stability and effective governance—one of the arguments for the tiny hill state’s formation in the first place.

The current bout of trouble began with a rebellion on the Congress benches. Led by nine MLAs, including former Chief Minister Bahuguna and Harak Singh Rawat, it put the passage of the state’s appropriation Bill in danger during its budget session. The imposition of Central rule caught many off-guard, not least Rawat himself, especially since it came just one day ahead of the 28 March deadline set by Governor kk pal for the Chief Minister to prove his support on the assembly floor.

Alarmed, Congress president Sonia Gandhi and Vice-president Rahul Gandhi rushed advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi to contest the Centre’s move in the Nainital high Court. The single-judge bench had made no comment on president’s rule, but set a fresh deadline of 31 March for Abhishek Manu Singhvi to contest the Centre’s move in the Nainital high Court. The single-judge bench had made no comment on president’s rule, but set a fresh deadline of 31 March for Rawat to prove his house strength—a move later ‘stayed’ by a two-judge bench until 7 april—even while ‘staying’ the disqualification of the rebel Congressmen who will now be allowed to vote on the confidence motion in secret, under the supervision of a court representative.

Irrespective of the outcome of the test of strength, if and when it is held, the BJp contends that president’s rule cannot be undone in the interim by any court. The party is ready to approach the Supreme Court on this, if necessary. The Speaker had acted in a partisan manner by resorting to a voice vote without a division on the appropriation Bill, BJp holds, particularly since the rebels had informed the Governor of their opposition to the Bill.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM OPENView All

Can Therapy Break The Taboo Of Hypersexuality?

Can therapy break the taboo of hypersexuality?

10+ mins read
Open
December 28, 2015

Afghanistan: Waiting For A New Life

Ravaged by war, terror and bad politics, Afghanistan is waiting for a new life after the withdrawal of American troops.

8 mins read
Open
December 28, 2015

Grand Opening Of Dance Bars, Are The Girls Excited?

Following a Supreme Court order, Mumbais dance bars are preparing for a grand opening. Are the girls equally excited?

10 mins read
Open
December 21, 2015

Discovery Of Colonial India

Lord Hastings 1814 journey from Calcutta to Punjab with painter Sita Ram is a discovery of Colonial India through lives mundane and magical.

8 mins read
Open
December 21, 2015

Imtiaz Ali: Auteur In Love

Imtiaz Ali's new film too is a celebration of desire and longing. The filmmaker in conversation with Divya Unny.

8 mins read
Open
December 14, 2015

Athleisure, A Lifestyle Trend Of This Decade

As the defining lifestyle trend of this decade, athleisure has changed the way we dress, appear, move and feel.

9 mins read
Open
January 18, 2016

Hate Wave In Communal India

Provocative clerics, frenzied mobs and the widening fault lines of communal India.

10+ mins read
Open
January 25, 2016

Delhi Government: Getting Even With The Odd Chief Minister

A righteous Kejriwal makes the governance of Delhi all about one man’s whims and paranoia.

8 mins read
Open
January 25, 2016

India’s Cricket Prodigies: Who Will Stay Like Tendulkar?

India’s cricket prodigies today are luckier than their predecessors, but who will stay the distance like Tendulkar? 

7 mins read
Open
January 25, 2016

Dating Apps: A Sexual Revolution

As the dating app sets up office in India, its first ever outside the US, Lhendup G Bhutia signs on to see what the fuss is all about. He comes out unwanted.

9 mins read
Open
February 2, 2016
RELATED STORIES

BIDEN, DEMOCRATS BET ON LONG-TERM GOALS FOR SHORT-TERM BOOST

President Joe Biden’s legislative victories have aimed to position the U.S. to “win the economic competition of the 21st century,” but his investments to boost the nation’s technology, infrastructure and climate resilience over the next decade are set against a 90-odd-day clock until the midterms.

6 mins read
AppleMagazine
August 12, 2022

What Will the Amazon Slayer Do Next?

Chris Smalls became the new face of labor when he spearheaded a unionization drive at a packing facility in staten island. Now he is trying to replicate that success across the country.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
July 18 - 31, 2022

RULING COULD DAMPEN GOVERNMENT EFFORTS TO REIN IN BIG TECH

The Supreme Court’s latest climate change ruling could dampen efforts by federal agencies to rein in the tech industry, which went largely unregulated for decades as the government tried to catch up to changes wrought by the internet.

4 mins read
Techlife News
Techlife News #558

Why Sports Nearly Didn't Make It Into Title IX

The daughter of Representative Patsy Mink, Title IX’s legislative champion, recounts the personal drama behind the near-exclusion of athletics from the law

5 mins read
Newsweek
July 01 - 08, 2022 (Double Issue)

CONGRESS GETS SECRET WARNING ON UFO INVASION!

What Pentagon brass revealed at historic hush-hush hearing

2 mins read
National Enquirer
June 06, 2022

CRYPTO COMES TO WASHINGTON. WILL THE MILLIONS BUY INFLUENCE?

Erin Houchin braced for the worst when a mysterious, well-financed group started buying television ads last month in her highly competitive southern Indiana congressional race.

7 mins read
Techlife News
May 14, 2022

OUR ABORTION STORIES

With abortion rights under attack, ELLE brought together five members of Congress perhaps most qualified to discuss the issue— because they’ve been there themselves.

10 mins read
ELLE
May 2022

WHITE HOUSE SEEKS MORE POWER TO COUNTER USE OF DRONES IN US

The Biden administration is calling on Congress to expand authority for federal and local governments to take action to counter the nefarious use in the U.S. of drones, which are becoming a growing security concern and nuisance.

2 mins read
AppleMagazine
April 29, 2022

IN AMERICA, A FEW DAYS IN MARCH 2020 ECHO TWO YEARS LATER

The conversations went like this: It will be just a few days. It can be kept at bay. There will be some inconvenience, sure, but the world will merely be paused — just a short break, out of an abundance of caution, and certainly not any kind of major grinding to a halt. Certainly not for two years.

4 mins read
AppleMagazine
March 18, 2022

FED TO ACCELERATE WITHDRAWAL OF ECONOMIC AID AS PRICES SURGE

Under Chair Jerome Powell, the Federal Reserve is poised this week to execute a sharp turn toward tighter interest-rate policies with inflation accelerating and unemployment falling faster than expected.

4 mins read
Techlife News
Techlife News #529