Lessons For Congress From Uttarakhand
Open|April 11, 2016

Lessons For Congress From Uttarakhand.

PR Ramesh

When Shakespeare wrote ‘Beware the ides of March’, he was not referring to Harish Rawat, Uttarakhand’s former Chief Minister, who isn’t much of a Caesar anyway. Yet, the Congress leadership apparently took the warning seriously in the hill state of Uttarakhand back in December 2012, when it inexplicably chose to elevate Vijay Bahuguna to the post of Chief Minister in Dehradun. In doing so, it rode roughshod over the legitimate claims of Harish Rawat to the chair. Rawat, through perseverance and strong-arm methods, managed to turn things in his favour in 2014, forcing the hand of the party high command. With just about a year left to go for the state’s assembly polls , the back story and ominous warning appear to have come back to bite the top leadership of the Congress and Rawat, after an emergency meeting of the Union Cabinet recommended that the state be placed under president’s rule.

In contention for power in Dehradun is the BJp. Since 2000, when Uttarakhand was first carved out as a state from Uttar Pradesh on a decision taken by the Vajpayee Government, the state has had seven chief ministers, mostly of the BJp. Only three were of the Congress: party stalwart ND Tiwari who assumed office in 2002; Vijay Bahuguna, son of another stalwart Hemwati Nandan Bahuguna and brother of Up party chief Rita Bahuguna, in 2012; and Harish Singh Rawat in 2014. In the same period, Up has had only five chief ministers. Up, a larger state, has experienced greater political stability and effective governance—one of the arguments for the tiny hill state’s formation in the first place.

The current bout of trouble began with a rebellion on the Congress benches. Led by nine MLAs, including former Chief Minister Bahuguna and Harak Singh Rawat, it put the passage of the state’s appropriation Bill in danger during its budget session. The imposition of Central rule caught many off-guard, not least Rawat himself, especially since it came just one day ahead of the 28 March deadline set by Governor kk pal for the Chief Minister to prove his support on the assembly floor.

Alarmed, Congress president Sonia Gandhi and Vice-president Rahul Gandhi rushed advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi to contest the Centre’s move in the Nainital high Court. The single-judge bench had made no comment on president’s rule, but set a fresh deadline of 31 March for Abhishek Manu Singhvi to contest the Centre’s move in the Nainital high Court. The single-judge bench had made no comment on president’s rule, but set a fresh deadline of 31 March for Rawat to prove his house strength—a move later ‘stayed’ by a two-judge bench until 7 april—even while ‘staying’ the disqualification of the rebel Congressmen who will now be allowed to vote on the confidence motion in secret, under the supervision of a court representative.

Irrespective of the outcome of the test of strength, if and when it is held, the BJp contends that president’s rule cannot be undone in the interim by any court. The party is ready to approach the Supreme Court on this, if necessary. The Speaker had acted in a partisan manner by resorting to a voice vote without a division on the appropriation Bill, BJp holds, particularly since the rebels had informed the Governor of their opposition to the Bill.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM OPENView All

Sunny Leone's New Erotic Page!

The leading lady of Indian male fantasy turns a new erotic page.

8 mins read
Open
May 2, 2016

Mother's Day- Jayalalithaa Is Invincible In Spite Of A Diminished Aura

Jayalalithaa remains unbeatable in the face of a regrouping of smaller parties and the blunted challenge of DMK .

10+ mins read
Open
May 2, 2016

Shah Rukh Khan's Big Confession About Closed Chapters Of His Life

Shah Rukh Khan dissects fame and success and confesses that many chapters of his life remain closed to all.

10+ mins read
Open
May 2, 2016

A Ban Is Not The Answer

A ban is not the answer. Let tradition live with strict rule of law.

3 mins read
Open
April 25, 2016

What, Me Worry?

Mamata Banerjee is unfazed by the advantage the CPM-Congress combine has in terms of electoral math.

10+ mins read
Open
April 25, 2016

Shakespeare, The World's Greatest Storyteller

He understands the personal better than a shrink and the political better than a pundit. He explains it all better than a sage. An Open celebration of the world’s greatest storyteller.

2 mins read
Open
April 25, 2016

Make Way For Madam President

In spite of the trust deficit, it's time for Clinton dynasty's tryst with the White House.

9 mins read
Open
April 11, 2016

Lessons For Congress From Uttarakhand

Lessons For Congress From Uttarakhand.

8 mins read
Open
April 11, 2016

Ghosting, The New Break-Up Trend!

 In which you swipe left to erase a relationship.

8 mins read
Open
April 11, 2016

No More Dalit Vote Bank!

Dalits across the states are refusing to be anybody’s vote bank, writes Kumar Anshuman.

6 mins read
Open
April 4, 2016
RELATED STORIES

Go Big or Go Home

Joe Biden tackled Covid and an economic crisis in his first 100 days. It won’t get easier from here

10+ mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
April 26 - May 03, 2021 (Double Issue)

Seeing Red

Does Congressman Andy Harris represent the future or end of the Maryland GOP?

9 mins read
Baltimore magazine
April 2021

Fear of a Digital Dollar

Central bankers are looking at virtual currencies that could work without banks

5 mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
March 29 - April 05, 2021

CONGRESS TO PRESS BIG TECH CEOS OVER SPEECH, MISINFORMATION

The CEOs of social media giants Facebook, Twitter and Google face a new grilling by Congress Thursday, one focused on their efforts to prevent their platforms from spreading falsehoods and inciting violence.

4 mins read
Techlife News
Techlife News #491

JOSH HAWLEY'S TOXIC POPULISM

IS THE SENATOR’S AUTHORITARIAN GRANDSTANDING THE DARK FUTURE OF THE GOP?

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
April 2021

BRINGING EARMARKS BACK WON'T FIX CONGRESS

ELIMINATING EARMARKS DIDN’T MAKE THE GOVERNMENT SMALLER. BUT REINSTATING THEM WOULD FACILITATE LEGISLATIVE CORRUPTION.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
April 2021

Why We (Still) Shouldn't Censor Misinformation

Trump’s loss in 2020, a majority of his supporters believed the election had been rigged. Some adopted wild conspiracy theories involving Chinese supercomputers, Hugo Chavez, and state-level Republican officials. These beliefs culminated in an attack on the U.S. Capitol that left five people dead. To make sense of these events, many officials have argued that platforms such as Facebook and Twitter allowed conspiracy theories to spread unimpeded, leading to erroneous beliefs and deadly behaviors. In other words, they blame misinformation for the violence.

6 mins read
Reason magazine
April 2021

Federal Debt: A Heavy Load

The debt continues to grow, but record-low interest rates could ease the long-term damage.

3 mins read
Kiplinger's Personal Finance
February 2021

HOW FREDERICK DOUGLASS DESTROYED JOHN C.CALHOUN WITH THE POWER OF JOHN LOCKE

ARMED WITH THE CONSTITUTION, THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE, AND THE FAR- REACHING GUARANTEES OF LIBERTY AND EQUALITY THAT THEY CONTAINED, DOUGLASS TOOK THE FIGHT DIRECTLY TO THE SLAVEHOLDERS.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
December 2020

Pack the Supreme Court, Or Strip Its Powers?

A proposal to restrict the court’s authority over certain laws stirs interest on the left

4 mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
October 12 - 19, 2020