The control freaks will stifle rugby fans' interest
The Rugby Paper|November 29, 2020
“Borthwick also appeared to have a problem answering questions from the media”
NICK CAIN

IT seems that one of the requirements to be a top level coach is also to be a fully-fledged control freak, and this week Eddie Jones and Steve Borthwick both made power grabs that emphasised the trait. That they should do so in the same week is probably not an accident, given that Jones and Borthwick worked hand-in-glove together for seven years, with Fast Eddie installing the former Bath/England lock as forwards coach with Japan, and then with the Red Rose men, before he joined Leicester.

Jones wants a change to having to announce his match squad 48 hours before an international, which he called an “archaic” rule. Instead, he wants to name his starting fifteen on the day of the match.

Jones offered this rationale on BBC 5 Live: “The rules of naming a starting 15 and a finishing eight is quite archaic, and we should just be allowed to name the squad of 23 and then pick on the day who starts and who finishes.”

Flexing his muscle as one of Rugby Union’s new breed of football-style ‘supercoaches’, he added: “It would add a bit more drama to the game. It would be really good (if) two hours before kickoff the name sheets are provided and you know who you’re playing against.”

A strong counterpoint to the Jones argument is that while it might cause a minor jolt of surprise on the bus to the game – mainly to the opposition coach – the talking point would barely impact the fans in the stadium, or the TV audience, because it will be swallowed up by the live action.

The point about announcing line-ups 48 hours before matches is because it keeps the interest in the match alive for at least a week ahead of it.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM THE RUGBY PAPERView All

‘Yoga-trance' saw Tim smash kicking records

Brendan Gallagher delves into some of rugby’s most enduring images, their story and why they are still so impactful

4 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Jonny finds some more hills to climb

ENGLAND and Exeter lock Jonny Hill insists he is not in the business of reflecting on past glories as he resets his sights after a stellar end to 2020 for both club and country.

4 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Itoje's excellence shows why locks are top earners

AT first glance reports that second rows are now the most valuable players in the European club game based on a recent survey of wages across Premiership, the Top 14, and the PRO14, was a bit of a surprise.

5 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Harry has to be a key influencer every week

HARRY Randall played really well last weekend, picking up the man-of-the-match award in Bristol’s win over Exeter.

6 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Women thrived in wartime

Brendan Gallagher begins a new series charting the history of the women’s game

6 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Connolly and Foley ruined my Bath team

KEVIN MAGGS THE FORMER IRELAND, BRISTOL, BATH AND ULSTER CENTRE AND FORMER COACH OF MOSELEY

6 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Highs and lows of Will's rollercoaster

Steffan Thomas talks to former Wasp Will Taylor about life after quitting rugby age 25

4 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Backs are turning into grunts now

HEARTFELT apologies in advance to forwards everywhere for this treacherous item because I know how incredibly hard you all work and heavens knows the bloody backs already get more than enough glory, headlines and sponsorships.

3 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

Bristol boy Joe's done with clapping Exeter

LIONHEART lock Joe Joyce believes Bristol Bears’ multi-million-pound training ground investment has left the squad with nowhere to hide in their quest for domestic and European domination.

4 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021

All Blacks deal casts doubt over CVC cash

Well, who would have thought it? Rugby seems to be the new darling of the investment industry and those who have taken the first offer now appear to be somewhat inept.

2 mins read
The Rugby Paper
January 17, 2021
RELATED STORIES

X's and O's: Cowboys

Leonard Williams sacks Cowboys quar terback Andy Dalton.

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
February 2021

Mr. Jones and Joe

Whether you agree or not, Daniel Jones is the Giants QB in ‘21

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
February 2021

Burst of Activity

TOOL’S ADAM JONES — AND GIBSON’S CESAR GUEIKIAN — DISCUSS THE FINER POINTS OF GIBSON’S NEW ADAM JONES 1979 LES PAUL CUSTOM

4 mins read
Guitar World
February 2021

No Frank Sinatra in Joe Judge

Coach says he had no regrets starting Daniel Jones. But was it the right move?

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
January 04, 2021

NEWS & NOTES

TOUGH LUCK The Giants Hope to Have the Injured Daniel Jones Back for The Cardinal's Game

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
December 21, 2020

Daunting December

The Giants provided November thrills and took the division lead into December.

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
December 21, 2020

Leadership, prep, and even “gut” over analytics

The Giants are not far from breaking through as an organization. They have the right coach, by most accounts, and they have the right quarterback, by fewer accounts.

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
December 7, 2020

THE ALL BLACKS

UNLOCKING THE SECRETS TO SUCCESS

3 mins read
Faces - The Magazine of People, Places and Cultures for Kids
November/December 2020

Learning how to win

Judge is not used to losing

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
November 2, 2020

Judgement Day in the City of Brotherly Love

WEEK 7: GIANTS AT EAGLES

4 mins read
The Giant Insider
November 2, 2020