Was Charlotte Dod the Greatest Athlete Ever?
The Atlantic|October 2020
The remarkable career of a Victorian athletic phenom—and the legacy that wasn’t
Helen Lewis

Charlotte Dod was only 16 when she challenged a man to single combat—three men, in fact. It was the summer of 1888, and the British prodigy had already won two Wimbledon titles, earning her the nickname “Little Wonder.” But Dod was always eager for another victory, and three singles matches, each against a top-ranked male tennis player, would attract plenty of publicity. Two of the men knew her already, having partnered with her in mixed doubles. One of them, Ernest Renshaw, even had prior experience in taking on a woman—Dod’s great rival, Blanche Bingley. (On a dare, he had worn cumbersome women’s clothing to do so; he won the match.)

The men allowed Dod to start at 30–0, and she could request replays of up to three points in each set. But the advantages did not all run one way: Dod wore a long, high-necked dress; a corset; thick stockings; and heavy leather shoes. And, like most women at the time, she habitually served underhand. Renshaw lost the first set, and upped his game. One commentator remarked that once he realized “he had no ordinary lady opponent … every stroke was keenly contested.” He recovered to win the match narrowly (2–6, 7–5, 7–5), but the other two men were beaten by a girl. Eighty-five years before Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs fought the “battle of the sexes,” a Victorian teenager showed what women could do.

Dod’s story is all the more extraordinary because, after winning three more Wimbledon victories, she abandoned tennis in the mid-1890s, feeling that she had nothing left to prove. She went on to represent England in field hockey, win an Olympic silver medal in archery, and become an accomplished mountaineer, expert horseback rider, skilled ice-skater, champion golfer, and daredevil tobogganist.

A sensation in England at the end of the 19th century, a time of feminist ferment, Dod was all but forgotten when she died in 1960—“a Victorian relic in a nuclear age,” as the journalist Sasha Abramsky wistfully puts it. In Little Wonder: The Fabulous Story of Lottie Dod, the World’s First Female Sports Superstar, he sets out to write her back into the historical record. In doing so, he joins a well-established feminist project— the rediscovery of lost pioneers of all kinds. Researchers have not yet settled on the athletic equivalent of the playwright Aphra Behn or the mathematician Ada Lovelace. Could Lottie Dod be that figure?

Working out where Dod fits in the pantheon of sporting, and female, greatness is its own sort of feat. After all, she played against a limited pool of amateur opponents, drawn from the upper and middle classes, while wearing clothes chosen for modesty rather than performance. Taking stock of her remarkable versatility is tricky, too. Her omnicompetence now seems like dilettantism, but it might also reflect changing models of success. The current formula for athletic stardom is the “Tiger path,” mimicking Tiger Woods’s early and unwavering hyper-focus, but in his book Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World, David Epstein instead endorses the more eclectic “Roger path”—following Roger Federer, who loved skateboarding, skiing, and wrestling as a child, and settled on tennis only as a teenager.

On the tennis court, Dod wore a long, high-necked dress; a corset; thick stockings; and heavy leather shoes.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM THE ATLANTICView All
RELATED STORIES

BANKRUPTCY RACKET!

Brazen Boris Becker gets 2.5 years for covering his assets

1 min read
Globe
May 23, 2022

Kaley: WHY I'LL NEVER MARRY AGAIN

Kaley Cuoco is taking a vow – and it's not the wedding kind!

1 min read
Life & Style US
May 09, 2022

EMERGENCY ILLUMINATION

DIVERSIFYING YOUR LIGHTING OPTIONS

5 mins read
American Outdoor Guide
April 2022

FIGHTING to be HEARD

Black women are nearly three times more likely to die after childbirth than white women. Serena Williams was almost one of them. Here, in her own words, she tells her story.

9 mins read
ELLE
April 2022

Crush it at crushing (No, really)

Left on read and pining from afar? Gain the confidence to take control of your romance story—your way—before the school year’s done.

4 mins read
Girls' Life magazine
April/May 2022

TAKE FIVE:Chandler Massey (Will, DAYS)

SOUTH PARK - Guilty pleasure TV show

1 min read
Soap Opera Digest
March 28, 2022

Pickleball

Unlike Waylon Jennings and Willie Nelson, I’ve found the athletic answer to the musical question “where has a slow-movin,’ once quick-draw outlaw got to go?” Pickleball.

2 mins read
Cigar Aficionado
March - April 2022

Grand Slam

Follow the pro tennis tour around the world.

2 mins read
Global Traveler
March 2022

Secretly Seeking Springtime

Spring is just around the corner; we can almost taste it. Gather your loved ones and take a trip to a colorful wonderland.

3 mins read
Cottages and Bungalows
April - May 2022

72 minutes with… Connor Pardoe

Pickleball, once a game for the 50-plus crowd, exploded during the pandemic. This sports commissioner wants to turn it into a national pastime.

6 mins read
New York magazine
January 17 - 30, 2022