India At A Crossroads
Reason magazine|January 2019

India is known as the land of contradictions, and recent events do little to undermine that reputation.

Shikha Dalmia

On the one hand, its Supreme Court is rapidly extending more rights to more groups. On the other, its ruling Hindu nationalist government is busy assaulting the longstanding rights even of incumbent groups. How things play out in this country of 1.35 billion people will have immense consequences for the entire region.

In September, India’s Supreme Court scrapped a colonial-era law that, for two centuries, had held that gay sex was “against the order of nature.” Thousands of people every year had been imprisoned under the law, and many more faced intimidation, harassment, and blackmail at the hands of corrupt law enforcement.

This doesn’t mean that same-sex marriage is now legal in India. But for a place where arranged marriages are still the norm, decriminalizing homosexual acts is nothing short of revolutionary. The court even declared that gays and lesbians deserve the same rights and protections as everyone else and apologized for how the country had treated them.

In a great leap forward for gender equality, the judiciary recently rolled back a cuckoldry law, another gift of the Victorian-era British, giving a husband— but not a wife—the right to prosecute his spouse’s lover and have him imprisoned for up to five years. The Supreme Court ruled that such a law reduced a wife to the status of “chattel,” the property of her husband. This offended “constitutional morality,” it said. It apparently did not offend the Hindu morality of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, whose Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) strongly supported the law, even though it was enacted by “foreign invaders” against whom the BJP otherwise constantly froths.

Last year, the court also deemed sex by husbands with underage wives to be rape and overturned a sharia rule that allowed a Muslim man to divorce his wife by simply chanting “divorce” three times to her face, without having to pay adequate alimony. The Indian Constitution allows religions some flexibility to manage their civil affairs in accordance with their own strictures, but feminists and Muslim women had long—and rightly—railed against this practice and demanded an end to it.

NONE OF THIS means that India is on a straightforward march toward ever-greater personal liberty and equal rights, unfortunately. The court can mint any rights it wants, but they’re meaningless if authorities aren’t willing to enforce them. And the current administration has made a mockery even of existing freedoms, to say nothing of new ones.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM REASON MAGAZINEView All

Scott Wiener Is California's ‘YIMBY' State Senator

IN NOVEMBER, VOTERS in San Francisco reelected California Sen. Scott Wiener, a Democrat, over his opponent, democratic socialist Jackie Fielder.

3 mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

BEYOND COVID

MORE USES FOR NEW MRNA TECHNOLOGY

3 mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

A Declassified Case Against Torture

The Black Banners (Declassified): How Torture Derailed the War on Terror After 9/11, by Ali Soufan, W.W. Norton & Co., 640 pages, $17.95

7 mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

The LAST PANDEMIC

TECHNOLOGICAL BREAKTHROUGHS AND POLICY PROGRESS MEAN HUMANITY MAY NEVER AGAIN HAVE TO ENDURE A DISASTER LIKE COVID-19.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

COMING OUT OF THE CHEMICAL CLOSET

Neuropsychopharmacologist Carl Hart says most of what the public knows about drugs is both scary and wrong.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

GOV. ANDREW CUOMO CLINGS TO HIS PEDESTAL

A YEAR AGO, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo was a pandemic hero.

5 mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

THE DREAM OF THE '90s DIED IN PORTLAND

ONCE AN UP-AND-COMING CITY, PORTLAND WAS DESTROYED FROM WITHIN BY RADICAL ACTIVISM AND POLITICAL INEPTITUDE.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION ISN'T GOING AWAY

WHILE OVERTURNING ROE V. WADE WOULD LEAD TO NEW RESTRICTIONS IN MANY STATES, LEGAL ACCESS TO ABORTION WOULD BE UNAFFECTED IN MOST OF THE COUNTRY.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

The Myth of Antonio Salazar

The integralist right’s foolish crush on the man who once ruled Portugal

7 mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021

Wartime Rationing Changed How America Ate for a Century. The Pandemic Will Do the Same.

THE GOVERNMENT TRIED TO STABILIZE THE NATION’S FOOD SUPPLY 80 YEARS AGO. ITS EFFORTS BACKFIRED.

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
May 2021