The hijab case of Karnataka has moved, almost inevitably, into a higher orbit of national reckoning. The raft of issues raised by the case—arising out of an Udupi college’s refusal to allow girls to wear the Islamic headscarf on campus—will now be subject to the Supreme Court’s judicial wisdom. A bunch of appeals have landed before it, and more may be on the way. What they are challenging is the Karnataka High Court’s March 15 verdict that upheld what is fated to be known, in common understanding, as ‘the hijab ban’.
The three-judge HC bench, while framing the issue, had chosen to accord centrality to the question of whether the hijab was essential to the practice of Islam. This scaled up a practical question—one that could have been framed tightly, and tackled, at the level of a conflict between college rules and individual rights—to a more fundamental, risky realm. In the end, the court ruled that Islamic tenets didn’t mandate the hijab.
The verdict also privileged the idea of the uniform, saying schools and preuniversity colleges (PUCs, the equivalent of Plus 2) are “qualified public spaces” where the idea of discipline is paramount and must prevail upon individual choice. The relevant 1983 Act of Karnataka prescribed no uniform, and only a Government Order (G.O.) of February 5, 2022, had brought in, even as the controversy raged, an executive cover for uniforms prescribed by individual colleges. The court finally validated that G.O. too, saying it was not violative of the principle of equality, nor discriminatory in nature.
This story is from the March 28, 2022 edition of India Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the March 28, 2022 edition of India Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Falling Back On Ram
It’s not new from the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), led by ‘Ram bhakt’ Arvind Kejriwal, but worth noting because god is in the details. It was Ram Navami on April 17.
Congress 'EQ' Vs BJP ‘IQ'
Team Modi Is Riding On Its Assembly Poll Momentum, But The Congress's Clever Candidate Mix May Prevent A Washout
The Macallan M 2023 debuts in India
Standing as a pinnacle of exclusivity, The Macallan M 2023 graces the shores of India with limited 10 handpicked bottles for whisky aficionados
Give it up for the science bros
They've got brains, brawn and billions in the bank. A new breed of wellness guru is doing for men what Gwyneth Paltrow did for women.
LIVING BY THE RULES
Chetan Bhagat returns to non-fiction with his new book-11 Rules for Life
The Mysterious City
Anuradha Kumar's The Kidnapping of Mark Twain paints an intriguing portrait of Bombay around the time of the American writer's visit
GOWDA KNOWS
Hot Stage, the third book in Anita Nair's Inspector Gowda mystery series, is here
WITH OUR OWN DESI SLEUTHS
Indian detective fiction gets its due in this massive, two-volume compilation from Hachette
PRIVATE PARADISE
Your home may well be your haven, but here are easy ways to make it your very own spa-dom.
Subversive IN SUBURBIA
A MONTH-LONG SHOW AT ART AND CHARLIE, MUMBAI, SHOWCASING THE WORKS OF POONAM JAIN AND YOGESH BARVE POSES SEVERAL QUESTIONS TO THE VIEWER