A welcome addition to the debate on India’s options in dealing with Pakistan and cross-border terror.
Ahead of the 2014 general elections, Narendra Modi successfully projected the image of a tough leader who would transform the terms on which India dealt with terrorism emanating from Pakistan. During his initial months in office, Prime Minister Modi seemed to make good on this promise. Since then, however, the Indian government has struggled to evolve a coherent and consistent policy towards Pakistan. Faced with terrorist attacks, New Delhi has resorted to the old playbook of calling off talks and urging Pakistan to bring the perpetrators to justice.
To be sure, the government hasn’t had to deal with a major attack on the scale of 26/11. In consequence, the question of how the Modi government will respond to a major terror attack remains open. In particular, the old debates on whether, and how, India can use force to coerce Pakistan remain unsettled.
George Perkovich and Toby Dalton’s book is an excellent contribution to these debates. India, they argue, will inevitably have to do more than strengthen its homeland security. Coercion or the use of force to move Pakistan’s behaviour in the desired direction remains an indispensable option. Following Tom Schelling, they consider coercion both as deterrence—the threat of force to prevent an adversary from doing something—and compellence, or the threat of force to get an adversary to do some thing. Compellence is clearly more difficult than deterrence. This is especially tough when the adversary is not a unitary actor but a combination of state and its client terrorist groups. Put simply, the question is whether India can use the threat of force to convince Pakistan to clamp down on the terrorist outfits that it has patronised for so long.
This story is from the September 26, 2016 edition of India Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the September 26, 2016 edition of India Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
FUELLING AMBITIONS
Puri's return signals a welcome continuity. Oil production and green fuels remain a challenge
Acceptance Certificates
The Ayush ministry must push for rigorous treatment protocol based on science and ensure new and high-quality products
THE HEALTH MAKEOVER
Providing adequate and quality healthcare to a large population is a challenge. The immediate task is to provide affordable treatment and tackle the burden of spiraling non-communicable diseases
THE GREEN TIGHTROPE
If the government is to realise its grand promises of a green revival, it needs to show unwavering commitment. Pollution and depleting forest cover remain major worries
REALISING THE TRUE POTENTIAL
Conserving and promoting India's rich heritage can generate jobs and spur other sectors too
MAKING YOUTH EMPLOYABLE
To cash in on its demographic advantage, India must revamp its skilling infrastructure with aid from the industry
CRACK THE REFORM CODE
Educational reform is unfinished business. More resources and full adoption of NEP are a must to end disparities, fill vacancies and train teachers
FISHING FOR SUCCESS
Empowering the fisheries sector and the national livestock census will be top priority
POWER-PACKED AGENDA
Reforms in the power sector are key to meeting the exponential growth in demand for electricity
BREAKING THE GRID LOCK
Joshi's big challenge, apart from synergies with the power ministry, will be to popularise the green fuels of the future