WILD BILL AND THE ART OF THE POSSIBLE
Handloader|December - January 2020
IN RANGE
Terry Wieland

James Butler “Wild Bill” Hickok is generally acknowledged to be the foremost gunfighter of the American West – the “Prince of Pistoleers,” as one admirer referred to him. Any such judgement is, of course, subjective. After all, how can it be measured? Bodies left in the dust? John Wesley Hardin killed four or five times as many as Hickok. Does that make him the best?

There is no shortage of other claimants, some famous and some not so much – Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, Doc Holliday, Billy the Kid. All have their supporters for one reason or another. Where Hickok unquestionably has it over all the others is the number of magazine articles, movies and television series about him – from documentaries that purport to tell the truth (as far as it can be known) to those that are pure fiction, trading on a famous name.

Being a “wild west historian” must be the most frustrating task imaginable. Outright fiction can be disregarded, but even journalistic accounts are highly suspect. There is an old Russian proverb: “He lies like an eye witness.” That seems to apply even in the most well-known and widely witnessed events of Hickok’s life.

Probably the best-known, most accurately documented, and the one in which there are the fewest contradictions is a gunfight that took place in Springfield, Missouri, on July 21, 1865. Hickok and Davis Tutt were erstwhile friends who had fallen out over a gambling debt. They met across the town square in Springfield, drew their guns and began shooting at about 80 yards. The most credible account is that Tutt fired five shots. All missed, at which point Hickok calmly raised his Colt Navy and shot Tutt through the heart.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

RELATED STORIES

COLTON COMES OUT

SAYING HE’S THE “HAPPIEST AND HEALTHIEST” HE’S EVER BEEN, THE FORMER BACHELOR CLARIFIES HIS ORIENTATION.

2 mins read
Star
May 03, 2021

Another Front in the COVID Fight

The commander of a National Guard task force says they’re filling gaps in the health care system.

3 mins read
Kiplinger's Personal Finance
May 2021

Bat Masterson: Armed and Dangerous

Bat Masterson lived long enough to enjoy the fame associated with his legendary time on the Kansas frontier as a lawman in Dodge City, and he never shied from promoting it, as he did when he notched a pawnshop pistol he sold as “his” frontier Colt to an overeager collector. – TRUE WEST ARCHIVES –

3 mins read
True West
February - March 2021

The last playoff win

Perhaps for some Dolphins fans it seems like just yesterday. For others, it might seem like an entire generation ago.

6 mins read
Dolphin Digest
January 2021

Flat Top Follow Up

PRODUCT REVIEWS

4 mins read
The Black Powder Cartridge News
Winter 2020

PIPER COLT

A REAL CONTENDER

6 mins read
Flying
November 2020

CASSIE & COLTON: RESTRAINING ORDER DRAMA!

DISTURBING ALLEGATIONS ARE REVEALED AS BACHELOR COLTON UNDERWOOD IS BARRED FROM SEEING EX CASSIE RANDOLPH.

1 min read
Star
October 05, 2020

Guns of Mexico's Freedom Fighters

During Mexico’s 1910 Revolution, rebel forces fought with muzzle-loaders, lever-action and bolt-action repeaters—even machine guns.

5 mins read
True West
November 2020

Cap & Ball Six-Guns A Smoke -Filled Adventure

Firearms fans are finding old-timey black powder revolver replicas offer a "time travel"shooting experience.

10+ mins read
True West
November 2020

ELVIS DIDN'T HAVE TO DIE!

Autopsy PROVES surgery could've save the King!

3 mins read
Globe
September 07, 2020