THE COWBOY SALOON OF STILWELL AND STWART
True West|October 2020
Oklahoma historian reveals the real story of the ownership of the famous Charleston, Arizona, watering hole.
TRUE WEST'S EDITORS AND ROY YOUNG

For many years, True West’s editors have published a much-debated 1889 photograph of Stwart’s Saloon from Charleston, Arizona Territory. The town supported local mining mills and local ranchers and quickly became a hotbed of an anti-Earp contingent of cowboys, outlaws and rustlers including Ike and Billy Clanton, Frank and Tom McLaury, Pete Spence, Frank Stilwell, John Ringo and Curly Bill Brocius. True West ran a photo in the May 2020 issue, after some detective work by the editor on the photo. Now, Western historian extraordinaire Roy Young has provided us the final word on the photo in question:

“There is an error on page 11 about which I’ve written to you twice before, once getting a published reply showing the correction. But, here it is again. As this is such a famous Arizona photograph, please note the following:

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM TRUE WESTView All

Idaho Trout

The Gem State's stream and lake waters are famous for the popular game fish.

2 mins read
True West
July - August 2022

Lee Martin

A born storyteller, the California ranch girl has worked hard at her craft to become a successful Western novelist and screenwriter.

4 mins read
True West
July - August 2022

If it Moves, If it Spins, You'll Find it Here

This truly was the "engine" for Albuquerque.

2 mins read
True West
July - August 2022

Riding for the Guidon

U.S. CAVALRY SCHOOL AT LITTLE BIGHORN BATTLEFIELD IS A REAL-LIFE HISTORY LESSON.

9 mins read
True West
July - August 2022

RIDIN' THE RAILS: HISTORIC TRAIN EXCURSIONS COAST TO COAST

From North Carolina to California, Montana to Texas, "ridin' the rails" is reminiscent of days gone by, when trains were the fastest mode of transportation. Passengers sat back, relaxed and marveled at the scenery or engaged in delightful conversation with fellow travelers. Those days are not gone, and now you can enjoy them, too.

10+ mins read
True West
July - August 2022

Magnet for Miners

A tour of Western Montana is rich in mining heritage, ghost towns and living history centers.

3 mins read
True West
July - August 2022

America's Sherlock Holmes

William J. Burns proved a worthy competitor to the Pinkertons...for a time.

2 mins read
True West
July - August 2022

Hickok's Twist of Fate

WILD BILL'S 1870 DRUNKEN BRAWL WITH CUSTER'S TROOPERS IS AS LEGENDARY AS THE MAN OF MANY NAMES HE KILLED.

10+ mins read
True West
July - August 2022

Crazy Horse's Final Vision

THE PROPHETIC LAKOTA LEADER'S FINAL DAYS STILL HAUNT US TODAY.

10+ mins read
True West
July - August 2022

A HERO'S JOURNEY FROM WAR TO PEACE

THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT'S BETRAYAL OF ARMY SCOUT CHATO IS STILL A STAIN ON AMERICAN HISTORY.

9 mins read
True West
July - August 2022
RELATED STORIES

TINY EPIC DUNGEONS

More Fun Faster!

2 mins read
Casual Game Insider
Spring 2022

SK .22 LONG RIFLE LOADS

LOCK, STOCK & BARREL

7 mins read
Rifle
March - April 2022

Heart and Soul

Seek renewal and inner peace at Sedona’s L’Apothecary Spa.

4 mins read
Global Traveler
November 2021

Came Through Drippin

Most of the world relies on flood irrigation to water crops. A more efficient alternative hasn’t been widely adopted because it’s so expensive. One Israeli soil physicist has the answer: a tiny plastic widget

10+ mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
September 27, 2021

The Site Pushing the Big Lie About Arizona's Election Audit

The Gateway Pundit, which has a history of advancing promoting the audit in Maricopa County

3 mins read
Newsweek
August 13, 2021

FAMILIES URGE USING NEW DNA TECH TO ID PEARL HARBOR UNKNOWNS

William Edward Mann enlisted in the Navy after graduating from high school in rural Washington state. A guitar player, he picked up the ukulele while stationed in Hawaii.

5 mins read
AppleMagazine
AppleMagazine #510

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - CHARLESTON

Charleston, South Carolina, attracts visitors with its sophistication, pleasant weather and aesthetic beauty.

3 mins read
Global Traveler
July 2021

Kyrsten Sinema – Shape Shifter

From Green Party rabble-rouser to Senate power broker, Kyrsten Sinema’s rise is a political fairy tale—and nightmare.

10+ mins read
Mother Jones
July/August 2021

GEOLOGY IN THE NATIONAL PARKS

The Science Behind the Scenery

10+ mins read
Rock&Gem Magazine
June 2021

A New View of Mineral Museums

This year of 2021 certainly started out to be disappointing for many mineral collectors. We were all looking forward to a host of mineral-related activities. Instead, few mineral shows and mineral activities on the calendar remain, so the first months of this year were devoid of organized mineral activity.

6 mins read
Rock&Gem Magazine
June 2021