The Rise Of Bordeaux Cru Bourgeois
Sommelier India|January/February/March 2018

The 1855 Classification of Bordeaux is a 19th century ranking of wines that are much sought after. The upside is that today’s discerning customer can also get superb value from lower classed crus. Ashika Mathews explains

Ashika Mathews

The Left Bank of Bordeaux is to many classicists the Holy Grail of wine. The names here are a roll call of aspirational wine drinking and collecting. But it has also found itself the subject of criticism: that the pricing is absurd, the style out-of-date, the complexities too subtle to comprehend. And yet for any producer of Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot based blends, Left Bank wines remain the benchmark.

The Bordeaux Classification of 1855, a ranking system of these wines which was put in place by Napoleon III was based on the prevailing prices, which it was believed logically reflected their quality. The top wines were divided into five classes from 1st Growths to 5th Growths – the Crus Classées. And despite changes of ownership, vineyard holdings and winemaking these have remained written in stone, with one exception, that of Mouton Rothschild which was elevated from 2nd to 1st Growth in 1973 when its label declared: “Premier je suis, second je fus, Mouton ne change”. (First I am, second I was, I Mouton do not change).

However, beyond these classified growths there lay a huge number of petits châteaux that also showed considerable variation in style and quality and required further classification for an increasingly interested market. The first came in 1932 when 444 properties were designated Cru Bourgeois. Since then, the Cru Bourgeois classification system has been on something of a rollercoaster ride.

Following the latest decree in 2009, properties are selected on the basis of an annual blind tasting two years after the harvest, when estates can be downgraded as well as upgraded. Recently, 271 châteaux have been qualified with their 2015s. While not as controversial as the 2006 St Emilion demotion that has seen various lawsuits and daggers drawn reactions from participants and jury members, the Cru Bourgeois is not without its own drama.

The Alliance des Crus Bourgeois du Médoc have introduced a(nother) new system, though it probably won’t come into effect until at least 2020. Rather than being completely new however, it reverts to an old system of a three-tier classification which will be reviewed every five years rather than annually. As many as 78% of their members voted for this change and it seems a sensible choice.

At the recent trade tasting of 190 of the 2015 Cru Bourgeois wines it was clear that there was an extensive range of quality, style and price which makes a single status rather confusing for consumers. In the revised new-old system there will be Cru Bourgeois, Cru Bourgeois Supérieur and Cru Bourgeois Exceptionelle. This is a clear and useful guide to a vast swathe of properties that cannot possibly be expected to all fit into one category.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM SOMMELIER INDIAView All

Vineyards At Your Doorstep

To withstand the march of concrete, many cities are embracing the concept of urban vineyards. Carol Wright reports on this exciting development 

7 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

The Rise Of Bordeaux Cru Bourgeois

The 1855 Classification of Bordeaux is a 19th century ranking of wines that are much sought after. The upside is that today’s discerning customer can also get superb value from lower classed crus. Ashika Mathews explains

6 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

The Birth Of Brandy And The Craft Of Cognac

On a recent visit to India, Baptiste Loiseau, Cellar Master of the House of Rémy Martin met Karina Aggarwal. What follows is a fascinating glimpse into the origins of brandy and the emergence of Cognac as the best example of it

4 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

My Strategy Was To Bring In Pocket-friendly Wines Of Reasonable Quality

Q&A with an Industry Insider

3 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

Kanya Asia's Top Single Malt Whisky

Shortly after Kanya won the award for Asia’s top single malt, Ruma Singh bumped into a thrilled Paul John at Bengaluru airport and extracted a promise for an interview. Excerpts from the interview follow

6 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

Beating The Heat In Akluj

Five cool-climate grapes are growing well at Akluj in southern Maharashtra in the vineyards of Fratelli Wines and their wines are making exciting, unusual blends. Brinda Gill reports

6 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

Castello Banfi

Putting Brunello di Montalcino on the global map

4 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

Wine In The City Of A Hundred Spires

Brinda Gill visits Veltlin – an iconic wine bar in Prague that offers a variety of “authentic” wines sourced from producers in the erstwhile Austro-Hungarian Empire

3 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

All That Glitters Is Not Gold True Or False

False! Michael Fridjhon recently returned to Marques de Riscal in Rioja after 25 years and came away hugely impressed by the quality of the wines despite the increase in volumes 

5 mins read
Sommelier India
January/February/March 2018

Watering The Wine

Stories of French producers watering the wine may not be a crime but a way of improving the ageing of wine.

2 mins read
Sommelier India
September/October 2017
RELATED STORIES

Legendary Land

Explore the historic châteaux and fine wines of Bordeaux.

6 mins read
Global Traveler
March 2021

How To Buy A Vineyard

From acquiring the perfect estate to bottling world-class wine

5 mins read
Maxim
January - February 2020

Ringing Success

Bordeaux might be one of the most traditional winemaking regions, but the estates are constantly innovating, including St Emilion superstar Chateau Angelus.

3 mins read
The PEAK Singapore
May 2021

Maybe clubs are reason England failed, not Eddie

The European Champions Cup has reached the quarter-final stage last weekend with a mixed bag of teams from the three leagues involved.

4 mins read
The Rugby Paper
April 18, 2021

Island Wine Time

Vineyards are returning to the pleasure island of Mallorca in a serious way, thanks to new players like Bodega Son Mayol where technical director Marie Barbé oversees a modern Bordeaux-styled estate.

6 mins read
Epicure Magazine
April - May 2021

Heritage Haven

A beautiful renovation has transformed this grand old manor into a contemporary family home full of cool character with hints of moroccan and nordic influences

7 mins read
Home Beautiful
April 2021

The Secret Of Bordeaux Lies In The Soil

SGC Wines discovers hidden gems through a study of earth.

4 mins read
Robb Report Singapore
March 2021

They Make Skincare At This Vineyard

Château d’Yquem is where Dior creates L’Or de Vie, its skincare collection that harnesses the antioxidant benefits of Yquem sap to achieve youthful-looking skin.

4 mins read
A Magazine Singapore
January - February 2021

Winning Look

Nascent winery Bodega Son Mayol is making world-class wines in the Balearic Islands.

3 mins read
The PEAK Singapore
January 2021

DASSAULT AVIATION'S HIGHLY ANTICIPATED ROLL-OUT

In a first virtual socially distance rollout, the 6X, said to have the largest cabin cross section of any purpose-built business jet had its debut

7 mins read
SP’s Aviation
December 2020