The Puzzling Pendennis Club Cocktail
Saveur|November 2015
Investigative bartender Toby Cecchini on an exquisite pink gin drink and the club in Louisville, Kentucky, that forgot how to make it.
Toby Cecchini

A long while back I had two regulars in my bar who enjoyed tasking me with interpreting classic cocktails. One night, these fellows ordered their all-time favorite, the Pendennis Club Cocktail. I blushed over my inability to conjure it: I had heard of it but had never encountered one nor seen a recipe. They walked me through it—gin, apricot brandy, lime juice, and Peychaud’s, the revered, anise-inflected New Orleans bitters. Taking a sip, I experienced one of those zoomfreeze moments. Intriguingly opaque, slightly frothy,and salmon-hued, the Pendennis Club Cocktail has a mesmerizing balance of flavors: sweet, tart, and packed with spice and strength all at the same time. It has remained one of my favorite drinks for some two decades, during which time I have tinkered with its parts and attempted to trace its perplexing history.

The actual Pendennis Club is a dining and social institution in Louisville, Kentucky, some 130 years old and deeply garlanded with its city’s history. It has long billed itself as the birthplace of the old-fashioned, a debate that has raged long and loud but one for which I’d prefer to stay on the sidelines. Instead, what I’ve wanted to know for many years is, who cooked up the actual Pendennis Club Cocktail, and why, in the middle of the bourbon belt, would this namesake house drink be composed with gin? 

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM SAVEURView All

Raising a Better Bird

Blue Apron founder Matt Wadiak has moved onto greener pastures, where happy chickens roam free.

2 mins read
Saveur
Fall 2020

One Good Bottle

Tamara Irish is a natural winemaker. Way natural.

2 mins read
Saveur
Fall 2020

My Not-So-Secret Garden

Good (vegetable-laden) fences make good neighbors in one tiny town.

4 mins read
Saveur
Fall 2020

Pralines: How They Cook 'Em in New Orleans

Pralines: How They Cook ’Em in New Orleans

4 mins read
Saveur
Winter 2019-20

My Father's French Onion Soup

Postwar Paris had a lifelong influence on James Edisto Mitchell—both as an artist and a cook BY Shane Mitchell

7 mins read
Saveur
Winter 2019-20

Our All-Time Best Recipes

If anyone should know if a recipe’s a keeper, it’s the person tasked with making sense of the original instructions—from the far reaches of Sri Lanka, say, or a famous chef who measures nothing. This might explain why many test kitchen staffers named favorites that their predecessors had tested and recommended. (Though a couple put forth recipes they developed themselves.) And while Saveur never shies away from the oddball authentic ingredient, the fare on the following pages is the stuff we cook at home, over and over again. Consider it global comfort food.

10+ mins read
Saveur
Winter 2019-20

Genever Is the Original Juniper Spirit

Don’t call it a comeback. Or gin

5 mins read
Saveur
Winter 2019-20

Gold Nothing

A sleepy city on the South China Sea ruled by the Portuguese until 1999, Macau has become a glitzy playground for China’s ultra wealthy. But in pockets between the casino resorts fueled by mainland money, traces of its culinary history remain.

10+ mins read
Saveur
Fall 2019

Mexico's Party Food

Fortified with hominy, chiles, and often myriad pig parts, pozole is a celebratory dish in Mexico and beyond.

4 mins read
Saveur
Fall 2019

The Middlemen

Tanzanian cocoa growers have long been at the mercy of itinerant buyers paying low prices despite the steep costs of growing. But a well-meaning company has created a supply chain that’s better for the farmers—and makes for better chocolate.

6 mins read
Saveur
Fall 2019
RELATED STORIES

GAINING PERSPECTIVE

With a new outlook on DAYS and family expansion on the horizon, Billy Flynn has found his groove.

8 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
April 04, 2022

Brandon Stanton's Empire of Empathy

Since launching humans of New York 12 years ago, the street photographer has pivoted his blog into a one-man philanthropy that raises millions of dollars for random people.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
February 28-March 13, 2022

Ginger & Spice

An Irishwoman, a kung-fu black belt and a confectioner walk into a bar… Plot twist! They’re all the same person. Rebecca Timkoe, founder of Gqeberha’s now legendary Ginger Pops, talks sweets with Khanya Mzongwana

8 mins read
Woolworths TASTE
March/April 2022

Food for Thought: There Will Be Blood

Lab-grown meat still requires slaughterhouse products.

3 mins read
Mother Jones
March/April 2022

We're With Her: Gina Rodriguez

"Golden Globe winner, former street racer and Hollywood powerhouse Gina Rodriguez goes from uptight to alright in Amazon rom-com / Want You Back."

3 mins read
Men's Journal
February - March 2022

Counter Movement

"Kitchens designed to celebrate cooking, rather than hide it away, are becoming real estate selling points."

3 mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
February 14, 2022

GINNY'S OFFER: TAKE MY HUSBAND, PLEASE!

GENEROUS Ginnifer Goodwin has offered to put her hot husband, Josh Dallas, out to stud — so her best friend can have a baby!

1 min read
National Enquirer
February 07, 2022

Native History Celebrated Large

Only months old, the First Americans Museum in Oklahoma City is dedicated to truth-telling.

3 mins read
True West
February - March 2022

US, EU AGREE TO FURTHER TRADE AND TECHNOLOGY TALKS

The United States and the European Union agreed Wednesday to carry on the work of 10 expert-level panels to explore and recommend solutions to a variety of trade disputes and challenges.

3 mins read
Techlife News
Techlife News #518

Leverage: Redemption

FRIDAY, OCT. 8

1 min read
TV Guide Magazine
September 27 - October 27, 2021