Petticoat TERROR OF THE PLAINS
Oklahoma Today|July/August 2020
WHETHER SINNER OR SAINT, MONSTER OR MADONNA, BELLE STARR IS ONE OF THE MOST ENIGMATIC AND MISUNDERSTOOD FIGURES IN OKLAHOMA HISTORY.
KARLIE YBARRA
THERE WAS A time within the memory of men now living when this dread name struck terror to the hearts of the timid and caused brave men to buckle an extra holster about their loins,” wrote Captain Kit Dalton in his 1914 book Under the Black Flag.

By the time that book was published, the woman Dalton was referring to, Myra Maybelle Shirley—better known as Belle Starr—had been dead for a quarter century. Her life was long over, but her legend still was gaining momentum. Borrowing her cachet for his own overblown biographical account, Dalton went on about the “Fearless Indian Outlaw.”

A more accomplished musician never coaxed dumb ivory into melody; a more daring bandit never hit the train nor cut a throat for the love of vengeful lust. A more winning smile never illuminated the face of a Madonna; a more cruel human never walked the deck of a pirate ship. She dispensed charities with lavish hand of true philanthropy and robbed with the strong arm of a Captain Kidd. No human ever risked life and liberty in more perilous ways for friendship’s sake than did this phenomenally beautiful half savage, nor was the gate to a city of refuge ever opened wider for the distressed than were of the doors of her humble mountain home . . .

Almost every word was fiction, but Dalton was by no means alone in this sin. Just months after Starr departed her earthly vessel, New York writer Richard K. Fox published Bella Starr: The Bandit Queen or the Female Jesse James and sold thousands of copies. Considering Starr’s name was misspelled in the title, it’s no surprise that the book is full of errors. Leagues of articles, books, and movies followed, many of which used Bella as a primary source.

Starr is among the most recognized female figures in Western lore, but she might also be the least understood. So if she wasn’t a hellcat on a horse galloping across the plains while firing two sixshooters at trailing U.S. Marshals, who was she? Perhaps the one thing Dalton and the others got right was that Starr was a fascinating set of contradictions.

“I’ve never seen so much rubbish written about someone in my life,” says Michael Wallis, a Tulsa author whose Belle Starr biography is slated for release in summer 2021. “When I talk about the West, I say, ‘Forget about the movies and the pulp books and all of that. Just know this: There were some white hats, and there were some black hats, but the majority were gray. Myra Belle Shirley’s hat was gray—and a lighter gray than many other romanticized figures from the West.’”

MYRA MAYBELLE SHIRLEY was born near Carthage, Missouri, on February 5, 1848, to Eliza—née Elizabeth Hatfield of the famously feuding Hatfields—and John. While John made a comfortable living as the proprietor of the Carthage Hotel, Eliza took care of the couple’s five children. Myra and her siblings grew up with many advantages. She performed piano recitals to adoring audiences in the hotel lobby. John’s extensive library offered the curious young woman a chance to explore philosophy and history. And at the Carthage Female Academy, Myra excelled in Latin, Greek, and Hebrew, among other subjects.

Though generally well-liked, Myra was no wilting flower. Contrary to what was considered proper for females at the time, she yearned for more than the domestic arts.

“Two interests obsessed her: horses and the outdoors,” wrote historian Glenn Shirley in his 1952 book Belle Starr And Her Times. “A competent horse-woman, she spent much of her time roaming the hills with her brother Bud.”

Bud, a.k.a. John Allison M., was six years Myra’s senior, but he treated her more like a friend than a little sister. He even taught her how to shoot a pistol and a rifle.

Idyllic as her childhood seemed, it was marred by bloodshed and the specter of war. When Myra was six, Congress passed the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854. This allowed states to decide whether to permit slavery within their own borders. Pro-slavery Americans—particularly those from neighboring Missouri— flocked to Kansas to vote, steal, and otherwise illegally influence the election.

After Fort Sumter was taken by Confederates on April 12, 1861, U.S. Secretary of War Edwin McMasters Stanton ordered Missouri’s governor Claiborne Jackson to send troops for support. Instead, Jackson called for fifty thousand volunteers to defend the state, and minutemen militias in small towns like Carthage started drilling nightly. Rival governments formed. Later that year, more than two hundred soldiers were killed in a skirmish just north of Carthage.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM OKLAHOMA TODAYView All

Past Presents

The Owasso Historical Museum documents the hometown pride of its citizens.

3 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

Revving Up

This Oklahoma venue provides a space for those who have a need for speed.

1 min read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

ROAD Less traveled

OKLAHOMA’S DIRT ROADS AND BEATEN PATHS OFFER VIEWS, RIDES, AND ROAD T R I P S I N AC C E S S I B L E TO M O S T. B U T HOW TO GET STARTED OFF-ROADING? WHERE TO GO? HOW TO STAY SAFE? THIS GUIDE WILL HELP YOU HIT THE TRAILS.

10+ mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

Mutually Assured Deliciousness

Peruvian and Chinese cuisine live in wedded bliss at Tulsa’s Pachac.

3 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

THE High GROUND

As the world hunkered down, one Oklahoman prepared for the toughest athletic challenge of his life. But the hardest obstacle to overcome wasn’t legs, lungs, stamina, or Oklahoma’s deceptively hilly terrain—it was losing the person who inspired him the most.

7 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

Paradise Found

This downtown Tulsa tiki bar stuns the senses and excites the palate.

3 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

Bottoms Up

Foggy Bottom Kitchen’s down-home cuisine is giving Oklahomans yet another reason to get out and enjoy their state parks.

3 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

Radio Free Tulsa

Live from Cain’s brings Oklahoma music history to the airwaves.

2 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

Highway to History

Derrick Smith Jr. is sharing Oklahoma’s rich heritage from the back of a motorcycle.

2 mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021

ADVENTURE BLACK BOOK

How do you feel most alive? Whether your adrenaline rushes come from death-defying feats, unusual journeys, or one-of-a-kind meals, these fifty-one Oklahoma spots will have you living life to its fullest all year long.

10+ mins read
Oklahoma Today
March/April 2021
RELATED STORIES

DANIEL BOONE'S YELLOW STONE HUNT

FACT OR FICTION?

10+ mins read
True West
May 2022

Leavenworth, Kansas

The First City of the Sunflower State celebrates its Western heritage.

3 mins read
True West
April 2022

Law and Order on the Overland Trails

Each traveler was a marching ordnance department.

3 mins read
True West
April 2022

Rule the School: Boards of Control

Our long history of letting white Americans veto racial progress in education

7 mins read
Mother Jones
March/April 2022

GRIPPING RESEARCH

I said my first words in a bar—“orange sody.” I eventually outgrew my love of Whistle orange soda, but I have a lifelong interest in bars.

2 mins read
Mystery Scene
Summer #168 2021

Private Schools Are Indefensible

The Gulf between how rich kids and poor kids are educated in America is obscene.

10+ mins read
The Atlantic
April 2021

Overland Trails: Fur Trappers to Pony Express Riders

ENJOY THE ADVENTURE AND HISTORICAL SITES BETWEEN ST. LOUIS AND FORT LARAMIE.

9 mins read
True West
April 2021

CARRY YOUR KIT WITH CONFIDENCE

TUFF POSSUM GEAR LETS YOU FOCUS ON THE ADVENTURE.

9 mins read
American Survival Guide
March 2021

Finding St. Nicholas

To the undiscerning eye, the Turkish city of Demre is not much to look at, let alone stop for. Rows upon rows of greenhouses covered in clear plastic sheeting cover nearly every plot of land. The drab outpost in southwestern Anatolia lacks the luxuriant resorts and Turquoise Coast panache of such places as Bodrum, Marmaris, and Antalya, the latter a renowned haven for Russian vacationers.

7 mins read
Russian Life
January/February 2021

Ariana & Dalton: 2021 WEDDING!

After nearly a year of dating, the two plan to make it official.

1 min read
Star
January 11, 2021