IT’S BEEN seven or eight years since a wave of illiberal norms around the discussion of race and gender began to hit an expanding array of progressive institutions. The name for this phenomenon kept changing, from political correctness to call-out culture to cancel culture to wokeness, because every time a new label came along, Republicans would slap it on literally anything that wasn’t right wing. (Mitt Romney recently blamed President Biden’s economic policies on his “woke advisers.”) What remained of the liberal left would have to clarify that, no, what they were critiquing was stuff that was really far out there: impenetrable jargon, irrational mobs, struggle sessions, creepy forced apologies, absurd firings.
In certain quarters, a deep fatalism set in about the survival of liberal values, articulated by critics including Andrew Sullivan and Wesley Yang, who has described the left’s new thinking as “successor ideology”—a term that presumes it is destined to displace the old liberal ideology. Michael Lind, a co-founder of New America, claimed that, within the center left, “debate has been replaced by compulsory assent and ideas have been replaced by slogans that can be recited but not questioned: Black Lives Matter, Green Transition, Trans Women Are Women, 1619, Defund the Police.”
But I don’t take the success of the illiberal left for granted. I think it can be halted. In fact, I suspect that the floodwaters are already receding.
The way the illiberal left has been dealing with race and gender is of a piece with the way it has approached a range of debates in the social-media era. Activists reduce nearly every issue to a moralistic binary and cast any dissent as a personal failing. Disagree with the policy activism of the Sunrise Movement? You’re a boomer happy to let the planet fry after you enjoy your remaining time on it. Not sure single-payer health care is the best strategy? You must want people to die on the street.
It is on identity-related issues that this style of thinking has made the most headway. Academia has produced left-wing philosophical challenges to liberalism that treat speech as tantamount to violence and regard political disputes as a zero-sum conflict between oppressor and oppressed. And while these illiberal norms often originated on campus, they have expanded into progressive communities like primary schools (mostly private ones), media, publishing, and political- and social-activist organizations.
Continue reading your story on the app
Continue reading your story in the magazine
Abortion Funds Are a Lifeline. And a Target.
The right's attacks on grassroots groups have already begun.
128 Minutes With... Olúfemi Táíwò
The Georgetown philosopher's new book, Elite Capture, comes at a moment of change for identity politics.
What Would You Like to Know?
An afternoon of pleasant negotiation with actor, stealth musician, and Taylor Swift muse Joe Alwyn.
This Pasta Granny Relishes the Spotlight
THE UNDERGROUND GOURMET
THE WOMAN WHO KILLED ROE
Marjorie Dannenfelser's single-minded pursuit of an end to abortion.
The Original The Famous
A pieman with a past, a business deal gone sour: New York's next great pizza feud ignites in Astoria.
The Group Portrait: Champions of the Office
Ten New York bosses urging workers back to their desks.
Mort & Me in Bed-Stuy
The artist Simone Bodmer-Turner lives in this apartment of her own devising with her rescue dog, Mort.
Send in the Clowns
Mike Myers returns as … well, a lot of different people.
How the proudly personally privileged NELL DIAMOND convinced so many women to wear PAJAMAS in public.
WAKING UP FROM THE NAP DRESS