It's early on a Friday night in Williamsburg, and one person is dancing at Union Pool. A version of the late-'70s power-pop anthem "Starry Eyes," performed by the Japanese quartet the Tweezers, plays on the speakers. "Classy as hell cover!" the set's DJ, Brooks Headley, tells me. "No one in the room is going to care about the music we're playing, which is what we want. We're just trying to have fun for ourselves and the seven of our friends that actually show up."
Headley, in loose-fitting work pants and a baggy sweatshirt, is here mostly because he likes to keep busy. "If I'm not working, I go insane," he says. "For me, not having a 16-hour-a-day kind of job made me go a little batty." Headley has been filling his hours waiting for Superiority Burger to reopen. The original incarnation of his vegetarian counter spot, a 240-square-foot white-tiled hole-in-the-wall on 9th Street near Tompkins Square Park, closed for good in November 2021, a few months after Headley announced he was moving the restaurant to a far larger location a block and a half away.
The first Superiority Burger opened in 2015 and came together in 11 weeks. To make it happen, Headley and his partners used whatever equipment was available, like a half-size oven that either baked focaccia perfectly or completely crapped out halfway through. A few school desks were used as tables, and if Headley had to work the ice-cream machine, he did so right next to the counter. "We outgrew the space on the first day," he says.
This story is from the February 13 - 26, 2023 edition of New York magazine.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the February 13 - 26, 2023 edition of New York magazine.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Our Campus.Our Crisis.
Inside the encampments and crackdowns that shook American politics.
Middle Management
A 40-something woman undergoes asexual awakening in Miranda July’s thrilling new work.
Return to Guantánamo
Serial dusts off American terror's old machinery.
Chekhov, Misfiring
An Uncle Vanya that’s all talk.
The Art World's Pot Stirrer Returns
Maurizio Cattelan’s first solo gallery show in more than 20 years is a provocative commentary on America’s ills.
On Normani's Time
Five years into her solo career, the pop star's debut album is finally imminent. She's not sorry for the wait.
French Quarter Seafood in Fort Greene
Lots of oysters and fillets of fish inspired by Nobu at Strange Delight.
Where Does the Wine Bar End and the Restaurant Begin?
Pét-nats, pan roasts, and a lobster on the loose at Penny and Demo.
Trial-and-Error Arcadia
Kitty Hawks and Larry Lederman's Chappaqua gardens have been a three-decade-long journey.
The Trash and Treasures of Temu
How are these headphones 4.98? And everything else you've wondered about the chaotic new Everything Store.