100 Women. One Trial.
New York magazine|January 6–19, 2020
After a flood of allegations that launched a movement, Harvey Weinstein will finally face rape and sexual-assault charges. But nothing in the case has been simple.
By Irin Carmon. Portfolio by Amanda Demme

It is true but incomplete to say that the word of one woman was not enough to bring down the law on Harvey Weinstein. The full truth is uglier. In the spring of 2015, Weinstein’s own admissions of groping a woman without her consent, first overheard by officers and then caught on tape, weren’t enough for prosecutors to bring charges.

Ambra Battilana Gutierrez was 22 when she reported to the NYPD that, earlier that day at a business meeting, the superstar Hollywood producer had grabbed her breasts and put his hands up her skirt. As she sat with Special Victims detectives, Weinstein called her and police heard him acknowledge touching her breasts. Gutierrez was distraught, but she agreed to wear a wire to meet Weinstein the next day in the lobby of the Tribeca Grand, where he asked her to come to his hotel room while he took a shower. Gutierrez repeatedly said she wanted to leave, then demanded to know why he had groped her breasts. Weinstein replied, “Oh please, I’m sorry, just come on in … I’m used to that.”

He was also used to what happened to him after he was hauled in for questioning, which was nothing. The producer assembled a team of well- connected advocates, from Rudy Giuliani to the former chief of the Manhattan district attorney’s Sex Crimes Unit, Linda Fairstein. Tabloids battered Gutierrez’s reputation. “Page Six” referred to Weinstein as a “married dad of five” and quoted an anonymous source dismissing the case as extortion. Detectives later said prosecutors in Manhattan DA Cyrus Vance’s office had grilled Gutierrez about whether she was a sex worker. Days later, they announced they would bring no charges.

With no other recourse, Gutierrez decided that accepting payment from Weinstein ($1 million, she has said) in exchange for her silence was the least-worst option. She couldn’t have known at the time how many other women had faced the same decision. Two years later, in 2017, Gutierrez chose to break her NDA, playing the Weinstein recording for The New Yorker’s Ronan Farrow. “I hope the other girls get justice,” she told him.

Her account to Farrow, along with dozens of others in The New Yorker, the New York Times, and elsewhere, was enough to finally shame law enforcement into action. As of this writing, at least 100 women have come forward with allegations of sexual assault or harassment against Weinstein; over a dozen made formal complaints to the NYPD. This month, the same Manhattan DA who declined to pursue Gutierrez’s allegations will finally put Weinstein on trial. He has been charged with five counts of rape and sexual assault of two women—former production assistant Mimi Haleyi and an unnamed woman who says he raped her in a midtown-Manhattan hotel room in 2013.

Several other women are expected to testify to Weinstein’s predation. The hope of prosecutors is that the cumulative effect of the accusers’ testimony will establish a pattern harder to dismiss than any one woman’s account. In that way, then, the trial will be yet another test of the strength of the larger Me Too reckoning. “This sort of testimony is really powerful,” said attorney Douglas Wigdor, whose anonymous client plans to testify at trial that Weinstein sexually assaulted her in 2005. “It just takes the wind out of the sails of the defense team.”

It’s the same strategy that worked in the case against Bill Cosby. When he was tried in June 2017 for assaulting Andrea Constand, only one other accuser was allowed to testify; the proceedings ended in a mistrial. A year later, five women testified. This time, Cosby was convicted. By then too, the public better understood why, for example, a sexual-assault survivor might not immediately report her attack or why she might stay in friendly contact with her abuser. An appeals court upheld the conviction in December, saying prosecutors had established Cosby’s “unique sexual-assault playbook.”

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM NEW YORK MAGAZINEView All

A Normie's Guide to Becoming a Crypto Person

How to (cautiously and skeptically) fall down the rabbit hole.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

You Don't Cancel Me. I Cancel You.

On the precipice of sports-gambling riches— and facing sexual-misconduct allegations—Barstool Sports’ Dave Portnoy doubles down on the culture war.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

The Money Game: Jen Wieczner

Revolt of the Goldman Juniors Wall Street’s youngest want more cash and better conditions. But mostly cash.

6 mins read
New York magazine
November 8 - 21, 2021

Climate Reparations

A trillion tons of carbon hang in the air, put there by the world’s rich— an existential threat to its poor. Can we remove it?

10+ mins read
New York magazine
November 8 - 21, 2021

Lindsey Buckingham Thinks He Did Something Right

IT HAS LONG BEEN Theorized that it takes two guitarists to equal one Lindsey Buckingham, which was proved back in 2018 when the fingerpicking deity was unceremoniously fired from Fleetwood Mac and had to be replaced with a duo of rock elders for the band’s following tour.

5 mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

Biden in Free Fall

Progressive donors to the left of him, cynical centrists to the right— a unified theory of why his popular agenda is so unpopular.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

Kathy Hochul's Got Seven Months

To govern. To campaign. And to tell New Yorkers what, if anything, she believes in.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

Bad Bunny Off Cycle

Benito Antonio Martínez Ocasio turned 27 this year. It’s been a time for introspection.

10+ mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

Pivot: Scott Galloway

Super-Apps Are Inevitable Get ready for the first $10 trillion tech company.

6 mins read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021

The Group Portrait: Hello, Old Friend

The 3rd Rock From the Sun cast tearily reunites for the first time in 20 years.

1 min read
New York magazine
November 22 - December 5, 2021