THE GUPKAR GAMBLE?
Kashmir Life|November 21, 2020
More important than the Gupkar group’s performance in the DDC polls will be what the alliance will do with its potential victories, asks Riyaz Wani
Riyaz Wani

Jammu and Kashmir is gearing up for its first District Development Council (DDC) elections to elect the third tier of its Panchayati Raj system. The erstwhile state had a three-tier system prior to the abrogation of Article 370 and 35A but it never moved beyond the basic Panchayat grouping and the top-tier was completely different.

The DDC polls were announced after Modi government gave its approval to amendments in Jammu and Kashmir’s Panchayati Raj Act, 1989. This has ushered in a three-tier grassroots system of governance like the rest of India.

A DIFFERENT MODEL

The DDCs will be constituted in Jammu and Kashmir‘s all 20 districts. There will be 14 territorial constituencies in each district of the former state. People will elect their representatives to DDCs directly through elections. The twenty districts will make for 280 constituencies.

The issue with the Jammu and Kashmir DDCs is the direct election of its members. In the rest of India, the DDCs are not directly elected but are constituted by the members of the Block Development Councils (BDCs) which are directly elected. Directly elected DDCs thus override the gram panchayats and the BDCs and dilute their powers.

This has triggered the debate about the need for the elected DDCs when the government could have followed the model adopted elsewhere in the country that is more representative of grassroots democracy.

The DDC members will have complete jurisdiction over the district. Though the members of the Legislative Assembly and the chairperson of all the BDCs of the district will also be the DDC members, they will wield no power. The Additional District Development Commissioner shall be the chief executive officer of the DDC.

Also as per the amendments, seats for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and women have been reserved which will be filled by direct election to the District Development Councils.

“This system is no grassroots democracy. It is something else. You are only killing the powers of gram panchayats and the BDCs,” said Shafiq Mir, the president of J&K Panchayat Conference who himself is a Block Development Council Chairman. “The issue is when you directly elect members of the DDC and give them exclusive control of the development activities in the district where does this leave the elected members of gram panchayats and the BDCs?”

Mir, who finally merged his party into Apni Party, said that after coming into being of the DDCs, the Panchayat and the BDC members in the rural areas of the district will have to jockey for power with its members. “In every territorial constituency in a district, there will be a sarpanch and maybe one or two BDC members besides a DDC member. How will there be a consensus over what development work should be prioritized in the area?” Mir asked. “Similarly, in a DDC while an MLA and a BDC chairperson will be members, they will be subservient to elected members. So, how will their opinion matter?”

GUPKAR GROUP

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM KASHMIR LIFEView All

TWENTIETH CENTURY KASHMIR

In his fourth books, Khalid Bashir Ahmad accesses rare documents to rediscover many people between Allama Iqbal and Sheikh Abdullah to various events from Roti Agitation to the making of National Conference

9 mins read
Kashmir Life
January 03 - 09, 2020

‘I HAVE RISEN FROM THE GROUND IN THESE ELECTIONS, NOBODY CAN TERM ME A PARACHUTE'

Trained lawyer and wife of former Deputy Chief Minister, Muzaffar Hussain Beigh, Safeena Beigh, who won her DDC election from Wagoora after defeating the PAGD and Apni Party candidate told Yawar Hussain

7 mins read
Kashmir Life
January 03 - 09, 2020

AMSHIPORA REDUX?

Days after the sleuths completed investigations in the July 2020 fake encounter involving the killing of three Rajouri labourers, the killing of a teenage trio in a gun battle in city outskirts, has run into controversy with their families claiming they were innocent students, reports

9 mins read
Kashmir Life
January 03 - 09, 2020

A READING ROOM

A woman in Jammu sets up a library on her property to encourage students to read and gradually it is emerging a model for societies where families lack enough of space or the situation for the students to study, reports Umar Mukhtar

3 mins read
Kashmir Life
January 03 - 09, 2020

Pandemic's Emotional Toll

In Kashmir, Covid-19 hasn’t infected and killed people alone. It has broken families or pushed them into crises that are unlikely to settle. Saima Bhat reports the emotional toll of a pandemic involving alienation of husbands from wives, in-laws from daughters-inlaw and engagements that families terminated fearing the irreversible damage by the infection will mar the lives of their wards

10+ mins read
Kashmir Life
January 03 - 09, 2020

‘GIVE US SAME RIGHTS AS MIGRANT KASHMIRI PANDITS'

Sanjay Tickoo is the leader of Kashmiri Pandit Sangharsh Samiti, the group of the members of the community that didn’t migrate from Kashmir in 1990. In this interview, Tickoo tells Umar Mukhtar that the Pandits who stayed back have been ignored by the government

4 mins read
Kashmir Life
December 27 2020 - January 02 2021

DIVISION DIVIDEND

At least a dozen seats were won by BJP, independents and Apni Party because of the infighting within PAGD and its failure to take its understanding with Congress seriously, reports

6 mins read
Kashmir Life
December 27 2020 - January 02 2021

DDC'S DOZEN QUESTIONS

In Kashmir, every solution triggers new problems. While the BJP government devised a new system within the democratic set-up to address the representation issues being talked about loudly, there were new questions that the exercise raised. Yawar Hussain picks some questions from Srinagar streets and attempts an answer

10+ mins read
Kashmir Life
December 27 2020 - January 02 2021

CAST IN STONE

A mosque constructed by the most celebrated Mughal Queen, Nur Jahan, in the heart of Srinagar fought a lot of negative narratives to survive as unique piece of Mughal architecture and a praying space for the faithful

7 mins read
Kashmir Life
December 27 2020 - January 02 2021

OBAMA ON INDIA

The former US President Barack Obama’s book ‘A Promised Land’ has made a special mention of his first India tour and in between he had made a series of observations about the leadership and the politics of a nation that owes a lot to the struggle of Mahatma Gandhi

9 mins read
Kashmir Life
December 20-26,2020
RELATED STORIES

What It Takes To Sell Indian Saffron!

The saffron of Kashmir has long been considered the world’s finest, but drought is threatening the livelihood and traditions of its farming families.

4 mins read
Saveur
Summer 2019

The BJP wants to cage me again

AFTER HER release from detention last October, Mehbooba Mufti, former chief minister and Peoples Democratic Party president, has been relentless in her attack on the BJP. She has also been active as vice president of the People’s Alliance for Gupkar Declaration. Excerpts from an exclusive interview with THE WEEK:

5 mins read
THE WEEK
January 24, 2021

NO SILVER BULLETS FOR DEFENCE

THE CONVERGENCE OF CHALLENGES IN THE YEAR OF THE PANDEMIC MEANS NEW DELHI WILL NEED TO REASSESS ITS MILITARY MODERNISATION, REFOCUS BUDGETS AND ACCELERATE DEFENCE REFORMS THAT HAVE BEEN STUCK FOR OVER TWO DECADES

7 mins read
India Today
January 18, 2021

Forced exit

A militant group’s claim of killing a non-Kashmiri businessman for obtaining a domicile certificate has posed a new challenge for government and security forces

4 mins read
THE WEEK
January 17, 2021

Fungal attack in apple orchards across the valley

WIDESPREAD FUNGAL infection is set to hit apple production in Kashmir this season.

1 min read
Down To Earth
December 16, 2020

जम्मू-कश्मीर में डीडीसी चुनावों ने दिखाया देश में लोकतंत्र कितना मजबूत: मोदी

प्रधानमंत्री नरेन्द्र मोदी ने जम्मू-कश्मीर में जिला विकास परिषद (डीडीसी) के चुनावों के शांतिपूर्ण व पारदर्शी ढंग से संपन्न होने और लोगों की बड़ी भागीदारी को शनिवार को भारत के लिए ‘गौरव' का क्षण बताया और कहा कि इन चुनावों ने एक नया अध्याय लिखा है और दिखाया कि देश में लोकतंत्र कितना मजबूत है।

1 min read
Samagya
December 27, 2020

Bittersweet mandate

The successful DDC polls could help fill the political vacuum in Jammu and Kashmir, but the results have revealed the dangerous levels of communal polarisation in the Union territory

4 mins read
THE WEEK
January 03, 2021

Bitter cold persists in north India, light snowfall likely in Kashmir

Minimum temperatures hovered well below the normal limits at several places

3 mins read
Millennium Post Delhi
25 December 2020

North India reels under cold wave

KEYLONG CONTINUES TO BE COLDEST REGION IN STATE AT -11 DEGREES CELSIUS

3 mins read
Millennium Post Delhi
New Delhi 21December2020

Govt invites farmers for next round of talks, asks them to choose date

Farmers to observe hunger strike today

3 mins read
Millennium Post Delhi
New Delhi 21December2020