Which Will Emerge As The Ultimate Smartwatch?
HWM Singapore|March 2019

Activity trackers are getting more powerful, and smartwatches are getting healthier. With the convergence of features, what is the best wearable that will fit all your needs?

Zachary Chan With Kenny Yeo And Alvin Soon ​

APPLE WATCH SERIES 4

The Apple Watch Series 4 might look the same as last year’s model but it has numerous improvements.

The two case sizes available now are 44mm and 40mm - 2mm larger than their predecessors. But case thickness has actually been reduced from 11.4mm to 10.7mm. On the wrist, the difference is surprisingly pronounced, with better comfort and proportions.

The display is over 30% larger too. Apple even designed two exclusive Series 4 watch faces (Infograph and Infograph Modular) that can show up to eight complications to track of more stuff.

Also new are a haptic Digital Crown and louder speakers. Haptic feedback provides a more intuitive experience scrolling through long lists, while the louder speakers comes in extremely useful for the Walkie-Talkie feature in watchOS 5.

The Series 4 watches are powered by Apple’s 64-bit S4 processor. A new W3 wireless chip supports Bluetooth 5.0 for quicker wireless transfers and improves power consumption.

Series 4 also comes with improved sensors. The accelerometers and gyroscope are now more sensitive and can detect double the dynamic range. This allows it to detect if the wearer has a serious fall, and automatically notifying emergency services with your location, a nifty feature for the elderly.

Talking about sensors, the last big improvement comes in the form of new electrical heart rate sensors capable of taking an electrocardiogram using the ECG app. Note that this feature requires regulatory approval from relevant health authorities to work, and may not be available in your location.

I’m not a particularly heavy user, and I find myself left with about 50% to 60% battery at the end of the day. Using cellular data, however, will put a huge drain on battery life so use judiciously. In short, Series 4 will still require nightly charging to get the best out of it.

AT A GLANCE

CPU S4 64-bit dual core, W3 wireless chip

SOFTWARE Watch OS 5

DISPLAY LTPO OLED Retina Display

BATTERY Up to 18 hours

HIGHLIGHTS Electrical heart sensor, 2nd gen optical heart sensor, fall detection

PRICE From $599 (GPS), $749 (GPS+Cellular)

CASIO PROTREK WSD F30

Casio’s third attempt at a smartwatch, the WSD-F30 is one handsome beast, with a standout color and strealimed design that successfully hides how huge it is. It’s nearly 54mm wide, and yet the 46mm Samsung Galaxy Watch looks larger at a glance. I’ve gotten more compliments wearing the F30 than any other watch in this shootout.

Under the ProTrek name, the F30 is built as an outdoor adventure watch and comes with a set of ten “Featured Apps” you can install from hiking to horse riding. Bear in mind that these apps are available to all Wear OS devices too. However, Casio claims to have partnered with the developers to optimize them for the F30.

However, the F30 is the only watch in this shootout that does not feature a heart rate sensor, making it less useful as a daily activity tracker. For a smartwatch released in 2019, this is a rather unfortunate omission. It also doesn’t have NFC, so you can’t use Google Pay either.

Its standout feature is a dual layer display combining a 1.2-inch color OLED with a monochrome LCD. This means the F30 can work in either full smartwatch or timekeeping mode, which turns it into a standard digital ProTrek watch. It can run for up to a month in this mode before the battery goes completely flat.

In smartwatch mode, battery performance was a mixed bag. In normal conditions, it lasted above two days days, higher than advertised. However, the moment any active tracking is used, such as a workout, and you’ve got yourself a dead watch in a few hours. Very disappointing given that the F30 doesn’t even have a heart rate sensor.

For Casio fans, the F30 is a step up from a regular ProTrek, and it carries the rugged look best. However, you can’t help but notice the lack of basic features expected from a smartwatch in 2019 when put against the competition. It doesn’t help that the F30 costs $749, the second most expensive smartwatch in this shootout.

AT A GLANCE

CPU Snapdragon Wear 2100

SOFTWARE Google Wear OS

DISPLAY 1.2-inch dual layer , OLED (390x390 pixels) , Monochrome LCD

BATTERY 1.5 days average (Smartwatch mode), 1 month (Multi Timepiece mode)

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM HWM SINGAPOREView All

CLOSING THE GENDER GAP IN TODAY'S TECH INDUSTRY

Although gender discrimination is illegal today, the gender gap still persists, ranging from subtle to obvious in every industry. The tech industry is no exception.

5 mins read
HWM Singapore
May 2021

Artistic And Multi-Faceted Gameplay

Fantasian is an all-new fantasy role-playing game developed for the Apple Arcade and published by independent Japanese studio Mistwalker. If that doesn’t ring a bell, the studio is led by one Hironobu Sakaguchi, or as many gamers know him, the creator of Final Fantasy.

4 mins read
HWM Singapore
May 2021

Leading The Charge For 2021 Gaming Notebooks

ASUS ROG Strix Scar 15 (G533)

4 mins read
HWM Singapore
May 2021

A Relaxing Thrill Ride

Monster Hunter: Rise

3 mins read
HWM Singapore
May 2021

A Piece Of Charging Art

Belkin Boost Charge Pro 3-in-1 Wireless Charger with MagSafe

3 mins read
HWM Singapore
May 2021

An Ode To LG Mobile

In April 2016, the cover story for the month’s issue of HWM was Samsung vs LG. It was an in-depth look at the two Korean electronics giants. Samsung had just launched the Galaxy S7 and LG, the modular G5. In just a few months after that story was published, Samsung’s follow up Note 7 devices would suffer battery failures and meltdowns. The entire line had to be recalled. It was undoubtedly a PR disaster and Samsung’s reputation took a major hit that many thought would take years to rebuild.

5 mins read
HWM Singapore
May 2021

This Monitor Does (Almost) Everything LG UltraGear 27GN950

LG’s UltraGear 27GN950 is a 4K gaming monitor that has pulled out all the stops to deliver a premium screen for gaming, content creation, and media consumption. And it has pretty much succeeded.

4 mins read
HWM Singapore
April 2021

Truly Lightweight And Powerful

Dyson Digital Slim

4 mins read
HWM Singapore
April 2021

Breaking The Glass Ceiling

How women in tech succeed in a male-dominated industry

4 mins read
HWM Singapore
April 2021

Thinking Of Joining Clubhouse? The Membership Fee Could Be Your Privacy

With leading media and business influencers such as Oprah Winfrey, Kanye West, Drake and Elon Musk enthusing about Clubhouse, the invitation-only ‘drop-in audio’ app has created massive awareness and interest globally, even though it’s still in beta mode. It claims to have 10 million users, up from 2 million in January 2021, and its US$1 billion valuation makes it a tech unicorn ranking alongside the likes of Uber and AirBnb.

4 mins read
HWM Singapore
April 2021
RELATED STORIES

Apple Watch Series 6 Review

Still a rhapsody, now in blue yet the best, even with caveats.

8 mins read
Macworld
December 2020

Fitbit Versa 2: Packed With Features And Looks

The Fitbit Versa remains one of the most functional and friendly Android-compatible smartwatches we’ve seen.

7 mins read
PC Magazine
October 2019

9 Top Trends At CES 2016

Teen pregnancy usually gets the spotlight, but women in their 20s have much greater numbers of unwanted pregnancies. And for Latinas, that raises the stakes.

5 mins read
PC Magazine
February 2016

Get The Basics Right

Is the Mi Watch Lite a good watch for beginner smartwatch users?

2 mins read
NXT
April 2021

Activity Tracker For Kids Fitbit Ace 3

THE FITBIT ACE 3 is the brand’s next-generation activity and sleep tracker that makes it fun and easy for kids ages 6 and older to get active and build healthy habits with the whole family. It introduces more animated clock faces and new accessories to motivate kids and show off their personal style. With up to 8 days of battery life in a swim-proof design, Ace 3 can also keep up all week long.

1 min read
Gadgets
April 2021

Montblanc Summit Lite

The smartwatch’s lightweight 43mm case is crafted from recycled aluminium and stainless steel giving it an active, high-performance appearance, while the eye-catching form is modern and sleek.

1 min read
NXT
March 2021

Xiaomi Mi Watch Lite

Mi Watch Lite is equipped with a built-in GPS and air pressure and altitude function, allowing users to track information about their workouts when running, riding, swimming and even hiking.

1 min read
NXT
February 2021

The New Generation Of The Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch

The new generation of the OMEGA Speedmaster Moonwatch

2 mins read
PORTFOLIO Magazine
February 2021

New Gen Smart Watches

With refined and minimalist designs, the latest smartwatches are made for the fashion-conscious, with stylish good looks plus customizable faces and straps to match your outfit.

1 min read
Her World Singapore
July 2020

Be Connected

The latest from TAG Heuer looks like a watch, but works more like your phone

1 min read
L'OFFICIEL Singapore
May 2020