THE HAUNT HOPPER
Charlotte Magazine|October 2020
Mooresville historian and history teacher Chris Stonestreet shares three of his spookiest local legends
TAYLOR BOWLER

O.C. “CHRIS” STONESTREET IV, 52, is a lifelong Mooresville resident who teaches history at Mooresville High School. In 2016, he published Curse of the Wampus, and Other Short Spooky Stories of Piedmont North Carolina, a collection of 10 local legends he’s investigated over the years. His family has lived in the area for more than a century, so his fascination with history and folklore spans generations. His father, O.C. “Chip” Stonestreet III, is a longtime writer for the Statesville Record & Landmark, where he writes a weekly column on Iredell County history (see sidebar).

Chris often takes his students through some of the spookiest sites in and around Mooresville. “When you’re teaching, you’re an entertainer,” he says, “and I’ve always been into folklore. It’s like the classic fish story. ‘Did you really catch a fish that big?’ What’s there and what’s not? But with every legend, there’s a kernel of truth.” Here are his stories from three local haunts. His words have been edited for clarity and space.

The Shinnville Witch

JUST OUTSIDE THE WALL of the 200-year-old Mills Family Cemetery near St. James Episcopal Church on Shinnville Road, there’s a small headstone without a name. The legend is, it’s a witch that was killed and buried outside the wall, and her soul still lurks there. It may have been a bogeyman story, or a case of parents trying to keep their children in at night or away from the cemetery.

SEVEN YEARS AGO, I was part of a team from the church to investigate the possibilities of lost or unmarked graves. The church had started burying people there without realizing there were already bodies there. Within weeks, we identified a number of unmarked graves outside of the original walls. Turns out, in the 19th century, people who had committed suicide, murder, or were deemed evil couldn’t be buried in consecrated grounds.

BUT THE MILLS CEMETERY was also established before the Civil War, and burials were segregated. So there is a stone there now that says something like, ‘To the beloved servants, you’re not forgotten.” The church came out and blessed the area, so once they found out, they tried to right that wrong. A legend led to us doing really good research and giving peace to those forgotten for 150 years.

The Girl at the Underpass

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM CHARLOTTE MAGAZINEView All

‘This Is How We're Going to Make Your Child Better'

Pediatric neurosurgery is technically and emotionally complex—and traditionally dominated by men. As Novant’s first female pediatric neurosurgeon, Dr. Erin Kiehna Richardson has had to learn the intricacies of a demanding field and battle sexism along the way

10+ mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

The Dumbledore of CMC

A surgery resident wrote a series of children’s books and created a special kind of medical magic

7 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

LGBTQ HB2+5

Five years after the furor of House Bill 2, the LGBTQ community—in Charlotte, in North Carolina, and across much of the nation—fights attacks on new fronts

6 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

Oh, Snap!

New ‘selfie museum’ in Concord celebrates the 1990s

5 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

ALLISON LATOS

The WSOC anchor on her hard trek from one episode of loss and grief to another—and the meaning of resilience

7 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

GOOD HEALTH

For years, Charlotte has been one of the largest American cities that lacked a four-year medical school. The health care professionals who finally made it happen overcame a series of setbacks, false starts, and failures, and they plan to use their clean slate to create a new kind of community asset

10+ mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

Summer Partee

From woodwork to retail, the kindergarten teacher-turned-designer has learned how to do it herself

3 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

Uptown or Downtown?

Archives illuminate how long we’ve argued over the perennial question

3 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

NOW OPEN NOVEL ITALIAN

Paul Verica brings a simpler version of the city’s hottest food trend to NoDa

3 mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021

TOP DOCTORS 2021

The annual list you can't without

10+ mins read
Charlotte Magazine
July 2021
RELATED STORIES

EXOTICURIOUS

A History Lesson and Lady's Perspective on Strip Clubs Across the Country

8 mins read
Recoil
May - June 2022

GH PREVIEW: SELINA RETURNS!

Selina returns to Port Charles and wastes no time trying to expand her influence, dropping in on Curtis to pitch a business arrangement to him.

2 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
March 21, 2022

CHARLTON HESTON A True AMERICAN HERO

THE OSCAR-WINNING ACTOR BELIEVED IN SERVING HIS COUNTRY AND FIGHTING FOR WHAT'S RIGHT

3 mins read
Closer US
March 07, 2022

thumbs up! and down!

Best Of Show Or Worse For Wear? Digest Decides.

2 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
January 24, 2022

SPOTTING PETER DO

The YOUNG DESIGNER and his friends-cum-partners BORROWED AND SCRAPED to create a label—and Fashion Week’s most anticipated NEW RUNWAY SHOW.

10 mins read
New York magazine
August 30 - September 12, 2021

Prodigal Daughter

Lydia Chang, daughter of the famed chef Peter Chang, makes a name for herself with Canton’s NiHao.

9 mins read
Baltimore magazine
March 2021

YES, WE'RE (REALLY) OPEN!

Despite the pandemic, a slew of new restaurants open in Baltimore.

10+ mins read
Baltimore magazine
November 2020

Lydia Hearst – If Looks Could Kill

Lydia Hearst combines horror and high fashion into one of the most interesting careers in Hollywood

4 mins read
Maxim
September - October 2020

Rest Assured

Area Assisted Living Residents Shelter Safely With Friends

5 mins read
The Best of Times
June 2020

DIAA's “ART matters 5” features photography as art

DEER ISLE—The Deer Isle Artists Association brings three local photographers to speak at the February 2 “ART matters 5” program, Captured Images. Lydia Osgood Cassatt, Julie Cleveland and Woodley Osborne will discuss their work at 1:30 p.m. at the DIAA Gallery in the village.

1 min read
Island Ad-Vantages
1/30/2020