'Til death do us part … with your capital!
Finweek English|5 November 2020
Reallocating your retirement savings may end up benefitting the taxman and not your retirement.
Marc Lindley

Regulation 28 of the Pension Funds Act of 1956 – designed to protect retirement savings from imprudent exposure to riskier assets, including offshore assets – has frustrated some local investors of late. Local returns have lagged offshore returns, and some have argued that a discretionary investment fully offshore would be preferable to a retirement vehicle, limited as it is by regulation 28.

However, a previous article, penned by Ninety One deputy managing director Sangeeth Sewnath, discussed the impact of regulation 28 on portfolio returns and concluded otherwise. He argued that the tax benefits associated with a retirement fund potentially compensate an investor for any outperformance that might be enjoyed by increasing your offshore exposure beyond what is allowed by regulation 28, in a discretionary investment. He investigated a 30-year investment and drawdown cycle, consisting of a 15-year phase of contributions to a retirement annuity and then a 15-year spending phase, converting the consequent savings into a living annuity, so creating an income.

His calculations demonstrated that an unrestricted discretionary portfolio would need to outperform a regulation 28-compliant retirement fund portfolio by approximately 2.5 percentage points over the full 30-year period to leave an investor better off. Generating an extra 2.5 percentage points consistently over an extended period is exceedingly difficult to do.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM FINWEEK ENGLISHView All

SO, WHAT NOW?

AS WE PUT 2020 BEHIND US, 2021 ISN’T EXPECTED TO LOOK MUCH BETTER (THOUGH A LITTLE).

8 mins read
Finweek English
17 December 2020

The outlook for SA's four popular investment instruments

As 2020 draws to its bitter close, some respite may lay ahead for local stocks and bonds. The drive to list a diversified basket of offshore-focused exchange-traded funds will likely continue unabated. And the rand? Lest we burn our fingers in ever predicting our volatile currency.

6 mins read
Finweek English
17 December 2020

MAKING BAD (INVESTMENT) DECISIONS IN A PANDEMIC

Many investors fell into the trap of either selling stocks at depressed prices during the March market rout, or cashing in their pensions.

6 mins read
Finweek English
17 December 2020

Goodbye 2020 ... Hello 2021

Schalk Louw shares his outlook for the largest asset classes available to local investors.

3 mins read
Finweek English
17 December 2020

How Has The Covid-19 Pandemic Affected The Inflation Outlook?

Due to deglobalisation and higher commodity prices, inflationary risks are increasing worldwide.

2 mins read
Finweek English
17 December 2020

How Technology Influences Politics

Advances in how we communicate will continue to create opportunities for those who want to sow division.

4 mins read
Finweek English
17 December 2020

On margin

The curious case of the US elections

1 min read
Finweek English
26 November 2020

Introducing Refined Ruggedness

The Ford Ranger Thunder exhibits double-duty dexterity off- and on-road.

5 mins read
Finweek English
26 November 2020

Medical Schemes' Healthy Reserves Underpin Lower Premium Increases

The medical aid scheme industry is faced by stagnant membership as South Africans suffer from economic headwinds. Nevertheless, schemes are well positioned to buffer the effect of Covid-19.

7 mins read
Finweek English
26 November 2020

Emerging Markets … And Trends

As developing nations navigate their way through the worldwide pandemic, there just might be some investment opportunities starting to emerge, writes Jaco Visser.

10+ mins read
Finweek English
26 November 2020