The battle between active and passive
Finweek English|8 October 2021
Some considerations in the decade-old debate remain important.
Johan Fourie

The Index Card is a popular personal finance book, first published in 2017. Its thesis is simple: Buy an index fund – like the ALSI Top 40 – rather than paying the fees of asset managers, who in the long run rarely outperform the market. I asked Nico Katzke, head of portfolio solutions at Satrix, why we should not all follow The Index Card’s advice and go for passive rather than active investing.

“The debate has often been framed, wrongly in my opinion, as either active or passive. In reality, both have their place. Active managers have an important price discovery role to play and preserve the ability to outperform indexes. Index-tracking funds, often referred to as passive funds, provide investors with a low-cost alternative, while tracking indices that have proven to be very hard to outperform consistently.”

But even passive investing is not that simple. “In reference to index funds, passive is a bit of a misnomer. Our research shows that the tracking error between two widely tracked indices, the Capped SWIX and the ALSI Top 40, is in line with that of the median active manager to the Capped SWIX. This suggests that your choice of index to track is a very active decision, and not all indices are created equally.”

The main advantage of indices, though, is the fee structure. The “tyranny of fees”, as the The Index Card makes clear, can be devastating for future returns. Is that true in the South African context too?

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM FINWEEK ENGLISHView All

THE HEALTH OF SA'S MEDICAL SCHEMES

As the Covid-19 pandemic abates, finweek takes a look at the financial performance of some of the largest players.

7 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

The effect of Gilbertson's departure

With Ntsimbintle Holdings now the major shareholder of Jupiter Mines, it could change SA’s manganese industry.

3 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

Making money from music

Why investors are increasingly drawn to the music industry.

3 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

Conviction is key

Sandy Rheeder plays a critical role in Mukuru’s mission to open up financial services to the emerging consumer market in Africa through tailor-made technology solutions and platforms.

5 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

The post-pandemic toolkit

How CFOs can use technology to support growth.

4 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

Big city living exodus

Mini cities like Waterfall City and Steyn City are redefining city-style apartment living.

3 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

Big compact, big value

Handsome, with a hefty level of standard specification, the roomy Haval Jolion compact crossover is a great value proposition.

3 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

On barriers to entry

There are various ways in which a company or sector can achieve competitive dominance. They usually make for good investments.

2 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

Fear and greed in one index

To buck the trend, when markets are hot or cold, is a tough thing to do. However, it can deliver solid returns.

3 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021

Africa's largest data centre facility coming soon

Vantage Data Centers plans to invest over R15bn for its first African data centre facility in Attacq’s Waterfall City.

3 mins read
Finweek English
5 November 2021