Coin authentication can be both an art and a science, but the science part is better. When I started working for the American Numismatic Association Certification Service (ANACS) in November of 1978, with the ultimate goal of starting an additional grading service for ANA, I was first trained as an authenticator. After all, there is no point in grading a coin if it is counterfeit, altered, or otherwise not an original numismatic item.
Back then, the process of authentication—the determination of whether or not a numismatic item is both genuine and original—required the ability to look at an item with a good eye for detail and a good memory of what you had seen before. Eventually, I trained several authenticators myself, and I can assure you that some people have a better eye for detail than others. I suspect now that people who like to do jigsaw puzzles make the best authenticators, but that is just a guess.
Of course, some memory aids and records are important. The first generation of ANACS authenticators (the service opened in 1972) made drawings on index cards showing die characteristics of both genuine coins and counterfeits. A classic example of a genuine coin characteristic would be the diagonal die scratch inside the incused T of LIBERTY on an 1893-S Morgan dollar. Only one obverse die was used to strike the entire press run of this issue, so if an 1893-S dollar does not have this die characteristic, subject to damage or excessive wear in this generally well-protected area, the coin is not genuine.
This story is from the June - July 2021 edition of COINage Magazine.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the June - July 2021 edition of COINage Magazine.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Is AI Smarter than a Numismatist?
One of the hottest digital topics today is artificial intelligence (AI) and it hasn’t skipped the numismatic and investing worlds
The Coinage of MARCUS AURELIUS
The first half of the Second Century A.D. marked a period of prosperity within the Roman Empire. Wars had been fought and won by Augustus, and borders were established. These borders of the Empire had been successfully consolidated and secured later after the brilliant reigns of Trajan and Hadrian
LIKIN' IKE DOLLARS
The Eisenhower dollar, issued from 1971 through 1978, was a coin of firsts and lasts. It became the first United States dollar coin to be produced in a copper-nickel clad composition and the largest such produced
AMERICA'S Early Gold Coins
MUSEUM-LIKE TREASURES OFTEN SELL FOR RECORD PRICES
UNVEILING A COIN THIEF
HOW NGC AND INVESTIGATORS EXPOSED A MOTHER-SON DUO
MEET JOEL ISKOWITZ: MASTER COIN DESIGNER
You might not know his name, but you very likely do know his classic coin designs
COINS As an INVESTMENT
A Complete Guide to Coins to Collect That Should Endure
A GUIDE to the Tetradrachm
THE STANDARD COIN OF ANTIQUITY
Inherit a COIN COLLECTION?
ADVICE FOR HEIRS TO DETERMINE NEXT STEPS
Collecting Vintage U.S. Silver Commemorative Coins 101
RARE U.S. COINS FOR ANY BUDGET