CLASSIC JET OR 21ST CENTURY TURBOPROP?
Pilot|September 2020
Gnat, Hawk or PC-21? Three generations of military trainer compared. Although we have a clear winner in 2020, all of them are fun to fly
Dave Unwin
CLASSIC JET OR 21ST CENTURY TURBOPROP?

What Pilot reader hasn’t dreamt of going shopping after a big lottery win? A Spitfire or Mustang would be cool, but perhaps a more modern turbine-powered ex-military trainer would be more to sir’s (or madam’s) liking? In many respects, such machines are easier to handle than a ‘big piston’ fighter. Now, this may seem counterintuitive, but it is a fact that as aircraft have evolved they have become simpler to fly but harder to operate. So, in much the same way as our well received ‘65-Horse Race’, we thought this month it’d be fun to look at three great turbine trainers from three distinct eras; the Folland Gnat, BAe Hawk and Pilatus PC-21.

I’ve been lucky enough to fly all three, but in the interests of honesty must point out I haven’t soloed any of them (although do believe that with one more hour of circuits I could’ve flown both the Hawk and the PC-21 solo−but not the Gnat!) Consequently, the following article should not be construed as full flight tests of any of the types but instead read as a general overview of their suitability−and practicality−for the private pilot.

The Gnat

This story is from the September 2020 edition of Pilot.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the September 2020 edition of Pilot.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM PILOTView All
Hybrid-Electric ‘Hawaii Bird' Makes First Flight
Pilot

Hybrid-Electric ‘Hawaii Bird' Makes First Flight

Electric aviation company Ampaire flew its second technology demonstrator on 10 September. The aircraft is a refined version of its Cessna 337 ‘Electric EEL’ hybrid-electric power conversion.

time-read
3 mins  |
November 2020
Rare Rearwin
Pilot

Rare Rearwin

Made in tiny numbers by Piper and Aeronca standards, the beautifully-engineered Rearwin Skyranger proves to be a delight waiting to be discovered

time-read
10+ mins  |
November 2020
Dr Hill's new helicopter
Pilot

Dr Hill's new helicopter

You’ve seen pictures of concept helicopters before, and most of them never rose from the paper… but this one has a better chance than most of flying in the real world. It’s the Hill HX50, and the designer describes it as a ‘disruptive’ entry into the small helicopter market, offering a step-change for the better in safety, performance, comfort and elegance.

time-read
2 mins  |
November 2020
Make mine a turbine!
Pilot

Make mine a turbine!

To say aviation and turbines is a happy marriage is true−albeit mainly in the airline, business aircraft and helicopter world. Light aviation, especially the ultralight segment, remains essentially a turbine free field−apart from noble exceptions, in the form of single-engine jets and ‘experimentals’.

time-read
10+ mins  |
November 2020
Industry experts say...
Pilot

Industry experts say...

Representatives from a selection of Approved Training Organisations look forward to the future of Commercial Air Travel and prospects for professional pilots after the pandemic

time-read
10 mins  |
November 2020
Flight training
Pilot

Flight training

News from the clubs, schools & ATOs

time-read
3 mins  |
November 2020
First airline job
Pilot

First airline job

... won and lost after just eighteen months in the right-hand seat. Reflections on the rewards of the hardest work in a lifetime

time-read
9 mins  |
November 2020
Safety Matters
Pilot

Safety Matters

Safety Matters and Safety Briefs are based on the AAIB Bulletin and UK Airprox Board reports, with additional material from the US National Transportation Safety Board.

time-read
10+ mins  |
November 2020
Donegal wins ‘most beautiful airport' - again!
Pilot

Donegal wins ‘most beautiful airport' - again!

Donegal in Ireland has been named as the ‘world’s most beautiful airport 2020’ – for the third successive year – in a major vote by more than six thousand ‘flying fans’. The award is given as part of the annual Scenic Airports poll conducted by private jet booking service PrivateFly.

time-read
1 min  |
November 2020
Come to Sweden!
Pilot

Come to Sweden!

A French pilot retires to Sweden, where he enjoys great weather, blissful flights and barbecues – and invites British flyers visit this GA-friendly country

time-read
10+ mins  |
November 2020