Too Many Elk
Successful Hunter|March - April 2020
Second Opportunity Bull
Darron McDougal

There are times in life that seem too good to be true. It was the first morn-ing of my Colorado elk hunt, and the second my guide John-Michael Ferrier killed the engine on his Polaris General, we heard bugling in multiple directions. That was encouraging since it was late October. As we waited for shooting light to arrive, a dozen or more tan figures meandered through the inky predawn filter separating us.

Just a few minutes before legal shooting light my wife, Becca, Ferrier and I quietly slipped out of the UTV. I uncased my rifle as we quickly discussed a game plan. Once we’d grabbed all of our gear, I slid the magazine into the rifle and then we shadowed the herd, which had now disappeared into a mixture of aspen and oak brush.

We were following the bugles when a young bull popped out of the dense oak brush about 80 yards ahead. “Don’t move,” I coached, since I was in the lead. Evidently, it heard some brush rustling, spotted our movement and mistook us for elk. It bugled at us, then stood and stared. We knew the rest of the herd was steadily moving away, so we gently nudged the young bull as we continued pursuing the herd.

As an outdoor communicator, I’m occasionally invited by manufacturers to go on hunts and was invited to the White River Mountain Ranch near Craig, Colorado.

I was fortunate enough to bow-kill a 6x6 bull in Idaho late in September. After arriving home in Wisconsin and processing the meat, my Colorado hunt was already fast approaching. I made a couple of trips to the local firing range to sight in my .30-06. After a few clicks, I felt confident in the combination out to 400 yards, in ideal conditions, of course.

The weeks peeled by, and before we knew it, Becca and I were packed and driving west. After an all-day drive, we spent the night in Rapid City, South Dakota. We rose early and finished our trip to the White River Mountain Ranch after another big push.

On arrival, we met our hosts and the other hunters in camp. A few of them had already hunted that afternoon, and one even had a close call with a very nice bull. After hearing stories, we were served a terrific dinner of antelope burgers. Then I was paired with Ferrier, and we discussed plans for the following morning.

After nudging the young bull, we continued after the herd. We crested a small rise that dropped into a basin and rose back up to a flat maybe 500 yards away where elk were feeding in and out of aspens. Ferrier believed one bull to be fair, but we couldn’t confirm it due to fleeting glimpses.

We decided to loop around to another vantage point above the herd. While making the maneuver, we spotted a cow elk on the trail in front of us. We hunkered down and watched as it fed toward us and then dipped off the trail less than 30 yards away. Antler tines soon caught my attention. I quickly identified it was a young 5x5. We hung tight and waited for the small herd to move away.

We continued ahead and eventually made a hard left turn up a steep grade to our predetermined vantage point. When we reached it, we slowly peered over the edge and our eyes were met with dozens of elk feeding amidst an aspen stand 200 yards below us. Only one bull in the group was worth a second glance, and we studied it carefully before determining it was a young bull with solid genetics. Ferrier left the decision up to me, and I passed up the 200-yard shot. We continued watching in case another larger bull was with the herd, but to no avail.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

RELATED STORIES

American Ruins

This country's unmatched and unlimited industrial might helped define the 20th century. But that was then, and this is now.

10 mins read
Men's Journal
August - September 2022

A Matter of Perspective

Regular backpacking trips are the key to contentment.

4 mins read
Backpacker
Summer 2022

Into the Wild

Cooking along the 500-mile Colorado Trail taught Clean Eating editor Amanda M. Faison how to transform the campfire into a kitchen.

9 mins read
Clean Eating
Summer 2022 / July - September 2022

We Turned a Retro Camper Into Our Home for $10,000

How to UPGRADE 106 SQUARE FEET FOR YEAR-ROUND LIVING

10+ mins read
Popular Mechanics
May - June 2022

perennial nectar favorites

Attract more hummingbirds year after year with flowers that require less time, maintenance and money.

4 mins read
Birds & Blooms
June/July 2022

Jared Polis Wants To Leave You Alone

The Democratic Colorado governor on pandemics, parenting, and partisanship

10+ mins read
Reason magazine
July 2022

JONBENET DAD DEMANDS NEW MURDER PROBE!

Wants more tests on crime scene DNA evidence

2 mins read
Globe
May 23, 2022

SPRINGTIME WILD EDIBLES

TAKE THE MYSTERY OUT OF WILD FOODS BEFORE IT'S A MATTER OF SURVIVAL

6 mins read
American Outdoor Guide
April 2022

Zuckerberg Money Won't Be in Next Round of Aid for Elections

The nonprofit that distributed most of the $350 million in donations from Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg to election offices in 2020 said that it won’t disburse similar donations this year after backlash from conservatives suspicious that the contributions tilted the outcome of the presidential race toward Joe Biden.

3 mins read
Techlife News
April 16, 2022

A Bellwether for Democrats

The race for a newly created Colorado U.S. House seat may depend on Latino voters and offers some clues about the November midterms

6 mins read
Newsweek
March 18 - 25, 2022 (Double Issue)