What Makes The Best All-Rounder?
Shooting Times & Country|April 21, 2021
There is no one breed ideally suited to all shooting disciplines, so it is crucial to concentrate on temperament and ability, says Ellena Swift
Ellena Swift

The all-rounder is a common concept in the shooting world and a hotly debated topic by anyone involved in gundogs. But what does it mean?

To me, it applies to the dog that is as much at home sitting on a peg as it is flushing game for its handler when rough shooting. One that will happily retrieve a pigeon back to a hide, a partridge out of thick cover and a Canada goose offwater.

It is also the dog that can genuinely and happily turn its paw to each task the handler requires. It is a tall ask, certainly, but is possible and there are many examples. I see a few most seasons.

Breed is the first thing we take into consideration. You cannot write offany gundog breed because there will always be one example that surprises you and performs in every area. However, if the all-round gundog is required, there are some breeds I would avoid.

Cocker spaniels are renowned as good shooting companions for flushing and hunting dense cover. Their size means they can get into almost anything with relative ease and most can learn to quarter with great effect. This makes them ideal for beating and rough shooting alike.

Many cockers are used in picking up teams and possess plenty of drive and ability to hunt and find wounded game. Fewer cockers are used on peg; something many of these little dogs can lack is a bit of patience. So sitting for the vast majority of the day and waiting for one or two retrieves is not normally one of their strengths. Though a fantastic little all-rounder, due to its size, the cocker can struggle on bigger game and the vast majority genuinely cannot pick a goose.

Their size can also limit their strength in water and a lot of them do not fare as well in cold weather. So, sitting in the cold, shallow water for flighting is not for a lot of cockers.

Their size can often be a benefit for those wishing to have a companion and working dog. Cocker spaniels have mastered the art of being an excellent working dog and a lap-sized pet. Many can work one day, but then make perfect tractor companions the next.

The labrador or golden retriever often seems a sensible choice. They are much more at home wildfowling, as the cold is kept at bay by a double coat, and any good labrador or goldie should make short work of tough swimming and retrieving geese.

Sensible

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM SHOOTING TIMES & COUNTRYView All

A bit of hide and sleek

Do we pay enough attention to our sense of touch? It is as vital in pigeon shooting as camo clothing and elaborate hides, believes Gough Thomas

5 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

Coming home to roost

When a fox finds its way into a chicken pen with the inevitable result, a plan is hatched to exact revenge and protect the survivors

6 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

Keeping it scruffy

Cutting back on mowing and adopting a ‘rough around the edges’ approach would be a major boost for wildlife

5 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

A great way to beef up a shoot

The sustainable future of our sport depends on rebuilding the old connections between farming and fieldsports, says Patrick Laurie

7 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

What you cannot learn on the peg

Many of the best Shots started young and had a rural upbringing, but there are other ways to become a good all-rounder, says Tom Payne

7 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

The day of the jackal — and pine marten

As long-absent predators return to our countryside, we can learn from how other nations deal with the conflicts that arise, says Matt Cross

6 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

A jewel, complete with a crown

A ‘malform’ spotted in the trail camera would make a perfect specimen to fill a hamper for Will Pocklington

6 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

Cold comfort on game crop

Bad weather is a major headache at this time of year, but all is not lost, advises Liam Bell

4 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

Standing the test of time

The vast array of fieldsports offers something for all ages, as sporting preferences evolve with advancing years, Barry Stoffell discovers

6 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021

With Guns in the pink

Britain’s colonial territories opened up a host of opportunities for the sportsman; Diggory Hadoke looks back at the days of the Empire

6 mins read
Shooting Times & Country
June 09, 2021