Best and brightest?
BBC History Magazine|July 2021
PETER MANDLER considers a sweeping analysis of meritocracy’s role in shaping the western world and debates the effectiveness of attempts to usher in equality
PETER MANDLER
Best and brightest?

In this readable and wide-ranging book, Adrian Wooldridge – sitting tenant of the “Bagehot” column in The Economist – brings a historical perspective to the current “crisis of the meritocracy”, in which meritocratic values and institutions (especially educational ones) are assailed from both the left and populist right as mystified bastions of privilege. Against this attack, Wooldridge maintains that meritocracy is revolutionary and egalitarian. He makes life easier for himself by foraying backwards, as far as Plato, focusing especially on the long haul from the Enlightenment to the brink of the present, when hereditary privilege was challenged by new meritocratic ideals of ability and hard work. There are few defenders of feudalism nowadays to argue otherwise.

Wooldridge has many tales to tell of doughty crusaders for truth and justice fighting against entrenched and unearned privileges. The story is a familiar one of “the rise of the west”. Our old friends the Renaissance, the Protestant work ethic, the Enlightenment, the American and French Revolutions, the industrial revolution with its cohort of self-made men, and the dawn of competitive examinations in the 19th century all play their appointed roles. Indeed, Wooldridge has a habit of name-checking conventional claims for the rise of the west – about its embrace of rationality, economic growth, liberty and democracy – and telling us these are really about meritocracy. Thus meritocracy plays the starring role that in some other accounts might have been assigned to Magna Carta, Protestantism or the Enlightenment.

The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World by Adrian Wooldridge Allen Lane, 496 pages, £25

This story is from the July 2021 edition of BBC History Magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the July 2021 edition of BBC History Magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM BBC HISTORY MAGAZINEView All
The Aztecs at war
BBC History UK

The Aztecs at war

RHIANNON DAVIES discovers why war was so important to the Mesoamerican people - and why they believed a badly cooked meal could prevent a soldier from shooting straight

time-read
1 min  |
March 2024
Towering achievement
BBC History UK

Towering achievement

NATHEN AMIN explores a 13th-century stronghold that was built to subdue independent-minded Welsh people, yet has since become a symbol of courage in the face of overwhelming odds

time-read
2 mins  |
March 2024
Eighteenth-century mushroom ketchup
BBC History UK

Eighteenth-century mushroom ketchup

ELEANOR BARNETT shares her instructions for making a flavourful sauce with roots in south-east Asia

time-read
3 mins  |
March 2024
Goodbye to the gilded age
BBC History UK

Goodbye to the gilded age

JOHN JACOB WOOLF is won over by an exploration of the Edwardian era, which looks beyond the golden-era cliché to find a nation beset by a sense of unease

time-read
2 mins  |
March 2024
The power of the few
BBC History UK

The power of the few

Subhadra Das's first book catches two particular waves in current publishing.

time-read
2 mins  |
March 2024
The 'badass' icon
BBC History UK

The 'badass' icon

One of the problems with biography, if an author is not careful, is that it can quickly become hagiography.

time-read
1 min  |
March 2024
Ghosts of Germany's past
BBC History UK

Ghosts of Germany's past

KATJA HOYER is impressed by a study of a nation's attempts to grapple with the crimes it perpetrated during the Second World War

time-read
2 mins  |
March 2024
A window onto England's soul
BBC History UK

A window onto England's soul

SARAH FOOT has high praise for a book that traces the evolution of English Christianity over the course of 1400 years, through the lives of its greatest thinkers

time-read
4 mins  |
March 2024
"Indigenous children were forcibly separated from their families"
BBC History UK

"Indigenous children were forcibly separated from their families"

HIDDEN HISTORIES... KAVITA PURI on the legacy of Canada's residential schools

time-read
3 mins  |
March 2024
ANNIVERSARIES
BBC History UK

ANNIVERSARIES

DANNY BIRD highlights events that took place in March in history

time-read
5 mins  |
March 2024