Sense and Sensitivity
The Walrus|July/August 2020
Publishers increasingly lean on outside experts to vet books for cultural insensitivity. Is it working?
TAJJA ISEN
Sense and Sensitivity

American dirt was supposed to be a major book of the year. Jeanine Cummins’s novel, which follows a Mexican bookseller and her son as they dodge cartel violence and attempt to cross the border into the United States, had all the makings of a blockbuster. Cummins’s publisher, Flatiron Books, had reportedly paid out a seven-figure advance and was sparing no expense on marketing; the book was blurbed by heavyweights Stephen King and John Grisham; and, sealing the deal, it was chosen for Oprah’s Book Club. More than a mere bestseller, though, American Dirt was positioned as the next Great American Novel. (Crime author Don Winslow called it “a Grapes of Wrath for our times.”) The book was meant to illuminate the politics of the present, when migrants of all ages are being detained en masse along the US border. Then, a few weeks before its January release date, the backlash began.

In one viral review, author Myriam Gurba tore into the book’s stereotypical characters and simplistic moral dichotomy, which positions America as a beacon of hope and goodness and Mexico as all criminality and death. Another review, in the New York Times, called American Dirt “ determined ly apolitical” —  surprising, given its themes — and noted the author’s odd fascination with “gradients of brown skin.” It emerged that, though Cummins has a Puerto Rican grandmother, she had identified as white up until at least 2015, when she’d penned an op-ed claiming that race was something she “really [didn’t] want to write about” (emphasis hers). It was only last year, during early promotion for American Dirt, that she began publicly identifying as Latinx.

This story is from the July/August 2020 edition of The Walrus.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the July/August 2020 edition of The Walrus.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM THE WALRUSView All
Invisible Lives
The Walrus

Invisible Lives

Without immigration status, Canada's undocumented youth stay in the shadows

time-read
3 mins  |
JanFeb 2024
My Guilty Pleasure
The Walrus

My Guilty Pleasure

"The late nights are mine alone, and I'll spend them however I damn well please"

time-read
3 mins  |
JanFeb 2024
Vaclav Smil Is Fed Up
The Walrus

Vaclav Smil Is Fed Up

The acclaimed environmental scientist is criticizing climate activists, shunning media, and stepping back just when we need him most

time-read
10+ mins  |
JanFeb 2024
It's Time for a Birth Control Revolution
The Walrus

It's Time for a Birth Control Revolution

What the pill teaches us about the failure - and future - of women's health care

time-read
10+ mins  |
JanFeb 2024
Would You Watch a Play about Hydro Electricity?
The Walrus

Would You Watch a Play about Hydro Electricity?

How documentary theatre struck a chord in Quebec

time-read
10+ mins  |
JanFeb 2024
Still Spinning
The Walrus

Still Spinning

One record chain has bet big on a new appetite for physical media

time-read
8 mins  |
JanFeb 2024
Just So You Know, I Love My Mother
The Walrus

Just So You Know, I Love My Mother

In many ways, multi-generational living makes sense. But that doesn't make it easy

time-read
10+ mins  |
JanFeb 2024
Art of the Steal
The Walrus

Art of the Steal

Why are plundered African artifacts still in Western museums?

time-read
10+ mins  |
JanFeb 2024
Canada in the Middle
The Walrus

Canada in the Middle

What role can we play in easing the war in Gaza?

time-read
6 mins  |
JanFeb 2024
The Walrus

Canadian Multiculturalism: A Work in Progress

As we mark fifty years since the adoption of Canada’s federal multiculturalism policy, human rights advocate AMIRA ELGHAWABY celebrates its merits and reflects on the work that is yet to be done when it comes to inclusion, acceptance, and fighting systemic racism in our country.

time-read
7 mins  |
January/February 2022