Rajya Sabha Is A Relic Of The Past
Indian Economy & Market|August 2017

Probably the first time the loud mouthed Samajwadi Party leader and Member of Parliament Naresh Agarwal raised an important issue in the Rajya Sabha when he attacked cricketer Sachin Tendulkar and actor Rekha, asking them to resign if they are not interested in the Parliament.

Krishna Kumar Mishra
Rajya Sabha Is A Relic Of The Past

He questioned the Chair that why shouldn’t their membership be canceled from the House. Records show that while the national average attendance of an MP is 78%, Sachin Tendulkar’s average as an MP is 7% and Rekha’s average stands at 5%. It would be conducive to compare it to the average attendance of other ten nominations. Sambhaji Raje with 100%, tops the list, whereas Subramanian Swamy is close second with 92%. All other nominations have a record attendance above 60%.

Prior to Sachin Tendulkar and Rekha, several other nominated members have recorded poor attendance in Parliament sessions. Lata Mangeshkar was a Rajya Sabha MP from November 1999 to 2005, and she attended merely six out of over 170 meetings. She used her power as an MP only to express discontent towards the possibility of a flyover being built opposite her house on Peddar Road, Mumbai. When asked about her lack of interest in attending Parliament sittings, she claimed that she had in fact pleaded with those who urged her into the Rajya Sabha to let her off; but then why did she accept the offer.

Rajya Sabha has equal powers to the Lok Sabha except for money bills, where it has no jurisdiction. It is a 250-member body, 238 are elected by an electoral college made up of state legislators. As per the Constitution Of India’s Fourth Schedule Articles 4 (1) and 80 (2), the President nominates 12 achievers to be a part of the Rajya Sabha for a term of six years for their outstanding contribution to art, literature, science and social services. But the nominations have always attracted controversy; the criteria are too vague. What has been observed over the last 70 years is a simple one liner funda - that to qualify one has to be sympathetic towards the party in power, have to be in their good books.

But this is one aspect only to start the arguments against the very usefulness of Rajya Sabha.

This story is from the August 2017 edition of Indian Economy & Market.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the August 2017 edition of Indian Economy & Market.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM INDIAN ECONOMY & MARKETView All
Do You Know? Now Google Search Results Are Dictated By A Political Doctrine
Indian Economy & Market

Do You Know? Now Google Search Results Are Dictated By A Political Doctrine

Google has become the tip of the spear in the management of the public mind. Google search results are dictated by a political doctrine that you are supposed to hold. The algorithms overwhelmingly favor approved talking points, even if false, with a vast and hugely influential machine now serving one political interest and dictated by one agenda. Search is no longer reliably informative of what's actually out there. "I'll Google that," once meant to get a wide range of wants you to believe. Jeffrey A. Tucker says those wonderful days are long gone outlooks on a topic. Now it means mostly to find out what the opinion cartel my & Market

time-read
6 mins  |
April 2024
In the Backdrop of World War III
Indian Economy & Market

In the Backdrop of World War III

When Iran's Supreme Leader Khamenei thundered a day back, \"We will make the ZIONISTS regret this crime of attacking the Iranian consulate in Syria and other crimes like this, by God's power and strength,\" now the stage is almost set for the World War III.

time-read
6 mins  |
April 2024
BE AGGRESSIVE ON DEFENSIVE
Indian Economy & Market

BE AGGRESSIVE ON DEFENSIVE

In an uncertain and volatile market, FMCG sector with strong return ratios, higher dividend yield ensures long-term capital preservation.

time-read
5 mins  |
April 2024
RBI MPC Meeting Key Takeaways
Indian Economy & Market

RBI MPC Meeting Key Takeaways

Reserve Bank of India's Monetary Policy Committee has decided to keep the repo rate steady at 6.5 per cent for the seventh consecutive time. Governor Shaktikanta Das highlighted the committee's majority decision of 5:1 to maintain the current stance, focusing on liquidity management to curb inflation.

time-read
2 mins  |
April 2024
India AI MISSION Well-positioned to Pave the Way for a Transformative Future
Indian Economy & Market

India AI MISSION Well-positioned to Pave the Way for a Transformative Future

The government has allocated Rs 10,300 crore for the IndiaAl Mission over the next five years. By nurturing an environment conducive to innovation, promoting knowledge sharing, and empowering stakeholders, the IndiaAl Mission is well-positioned to pave the way for a transformative future where AI acts as a catalyst for progress and prosperity for everyone.

time-read
5 mins  |
April 2024
SOME ETERNAL SUTRAS FOR INVESTORS
Indian Economy & Market

SOME ETERNAL SUTRAS FOR INVESTORS

Indian Economy & M What's the best way to survive a financial crisis with your wealth intact?

time-read
7 mins  |
April 2024
Gold: An Excellent Diversification
Indian Economy & Market

Gold: An Excellent Diversification

Gold is priced in dollars. Inflation means the dollar is worth less in terms of purchasing power. That means it takes more dollars to buy gold, so the dollar price of gold goes up. What you may lose in the rest of your portfolio in terms of dollar purchasing power is made up in part or all from the profits you make on the higher dollar price of gold. James Rickards says owning gold will protect you from the ravages of inflation. You’ll have your inflation protection in place 24/7 and won’t be caught off-guard.

time-read
5 mins  |
March 2024
Balaji Telefilms Ltd. Reports Robust Earnings for Q3FY24, To release "Love, Sex aur Dhokha 2"
Indian Economy & Market

Balaji Telefilms Ltd. Reports Robust Earnings for Q3FY24, To release "Love, Sex aur Dhokha 2"

Balaji Motion Pictures’, a division of Balaji Telefilms Ltd.’s highly anticipated Love, Sex aur Dhokha 2 has been in the headlines ever since its announcement.

time-read
2 mins  |
March 2024
PHARMA STOCK: AT PINK OF THEIR HEALTH
Indian Economy & Market

PHARMA STOCK: AT PINK OF THEIR HEALTH

Pharma stocks are once again showing sign of strength as they have outperformed key equity indices.

time-read
10+ mins  |
March 2024
Sarveshwar Foods Ltd. Board Approves Fund Raise of up to ₹99 Crores
Indian Economy & Market

Sarveshwar Foods Ltd. Board Approves Fund Raise of up to ₹99 Crores

Sarveshwar Foods Limited, a leader in the business of manufacturing, trading, processing, and marketing of branded and un-branded basmati and nonbasmati rice, has announced that the board approved a fund-raise of up to Rs. 98.94 Crores by the way of issue of Up to 10,20,00,000 Fully Convertible Warrants convertible into equal number of Equity Shares of face value of Re. 1/- each, to persons belonging to non-promoter group persons at an issue price Rs. 9.70 per warrant, subject to approval of shareholders and other regulatory authorities, as may be applicable.

time-read
2 mins  |
March 2024