Buy Right And Sit Tight How Right Is That?
Dalal Street Investment Journal|November 23, 2020
One thumb rule, promoted by most investment consultants, is the buy right and sit tight strategy. In the long term, this will help you create good wealth. However, there are various drawbacks of this strategy such as there is no consistent winner among various asset classes like equity, debt and gold. This article takes a close look at the fallacies of this strategy and suggests an alternative option

You may have heard from investment gurus and financial planners that investors need to be disciplined and should invest from a long-term perspective. In short, they suggest a ‘buy and hold’ strategy. And though disciplined investing is something that we too are in favour of, we have our doubts about the buy and hold strategy. Having said that, a genuine question pops up which is that when the future is unknown and uncertain, how one can state for sure whether to buy, hold or sell a particular stock, index or mutual fund?

Of course, we can just come out with a probable situation but cannot predict it. This is the question that led us to analyse and understand whether or not at all the ‘buy right and sit tight’ is a prudent investment strategy, in particular for mutual funds considering that they are promoted more as long-term investments than stocks. It is equally important then to know if there exists a viable alternative.

Buy Right and Sit Tight

To begin with, let us understand what is the buy right and sit tight strategy is all about. As the phrase itself suggests, it is a strategy wherein you identify a stock or a mutual fund, invest in it and then forget it. According to this strategy, a quality stock or a mutual fund would always provide you with better returns in the long term. Consider the illustration alongside to understand this better. As an example, let us assume that you invest Rs 1 lakh in S & P BSE Sensex in November 2000 and forget about it till October 2020.

The above graph shows how your investment would have grown if you had adopted a buy and hold strategy in S & P BSE Sensex for 20 years. Your investment of Rs 1 lakh would have become Rs 10.46 lakhs in 20 years i.e. it would have grown by more than 10 times. And the compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) would be 11.79 per cent. All you did was to have bought it and then held it till the end of its tenure.

The above graph shows the three-year rolling returns for the same period as has been considered for our case study. Here we can clearly see that the three-year returns have fallen quite a bit lately and have also turned negative. Although the average three-year rolling return is 15.53 per cent, the variation in returns is huge. There was a period when the returns were greater than 50 per cent, while during other instances they were negative 10 per cent. Nonetheless, deeper analysis shows that it is more due to a polarised performance of the Sensex constituents where a few stocks did exceptionally well while a majority of them performed poorly. For these reasons, the buy and hold strategy may not always work.

Debunking the Strategy

There are four things that make the buy right and sit tight strategy futile.

Asset Class

We all know the importance of diversification. You may have heard the maxim of never putting your eggs in one basket. Hence, asset allocation has its own advantages. So, let us move on to the basics and understand why we need to diversify and have a proper asset allocation in place. One particular asset class is never a consistent winner. Though equity as an asset class performs better in the long run, that does not deem it a winner all the time.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM DALAL STREET INVESTMENT JOURNALView All

The Art Of Asset Allocation

Mutual Fund Distributor

3 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

George Joseph CEO and CIO, ITI Mutual Fund

In this exclusive interview, George Joseph, CEO and CIO, ITI Mutual Fund, expresses his opinion about the status of the MF sector in the new scenario post the pandemic and how his fund house is strategizing future investments

5 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

LUX INDUSTRIES IN A ‘COMFORTABLE' POSITION

Some of the strengths of Lux Industries include rich sectoral experience, extensive distribution network, substantial cost leadership, proprietary manufacturing ability, vast product variety and sharp focus on the mid-price segment

5 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

Turnaround Companies Of 2020

The year 2020 was anything but dull for equity investors. Many made money in 2020 and on an average the risk-taking appetite was on the rise in 2020. The stock prices were no doubt volatile and several stocks more than doubled in 2020. The year clearly belonged to the defensives and penny stocks and to a great extent 2020 was also a year for turnaround stocks. Shreya Chaware highlights the turnaround stories that helped create wealth for investors in 2020 while also sharing key elements to watch out for in identifying turnaround stocks

6 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

Welcome 2021 With A Revisited Portfolio

Hemant Rustagi Chief Executive Officer, Wiseinvest Pvt Ltd.

3 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

Replace Fixed Deposits With Mutual Fund Schemes

The worst hit by the lower interest rates are investors who had relied on bank fixed deposits to earn interest. The option for such investors is to shift to debt mutual funds. The article explains why

4 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

Markets End 2020 On A Cheery Note

With positive news announcements about the vaccines and successful clinical trials, the healthcare industry remained in the limelight, gaining 2.10 per cent during the fortnight

4 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

ALKEM LABORATORIES ON A ‘PRESCRIBED' JOURNEY OF SUCCESS

Alkem Laboratories Limited is a pharmaceutical company engaged in the development, manufacture, and sale of pharmaceutical and nutraceutical products.

2 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

Jayesh Dadia Chartered Accountant

Tax Column

4 mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021

2021 Value Stocks

Market participants are focusing on 2021 and there is a huge level of enthusiasm and high expectation on the part of investors as far as the forthcoming year goes after an unbelievable 2020. It was not easy to pick pharmaceutical and IT as probable winners at the start of 2020 and similarly it will not be easy to pick the set of stocks that may dominate in 2021. Geyatee Deshpande puts forth a case for value stocks to do well in 2021 while Yogesh Supekar highlights how to identify value stocks

10+ mins read
Dalal Street Investment Journal
January 04, 2021
RELATED STORIES

AMERICANS CAN PAY THEIR CREDIT CARD BILLS, BUT FOR HOW LONG?

The coronavirus pandemic hasn’t stopped Americans from keeping up with their credit card payments, thanks in large part to government relief programs passed by Congress earlier this year.

3 mins read
AppleMagazine
AppleMagazine #476

Getting More from Less

Everyone has been forced to cut back in some way—but limitations can lead us to even greater growth. We asked six entrepreneurs: What unexpected benefits have you gotten from change?

2 mins read
Entrepreneur
December 2020

Are We Going Digital Forever?

The pandemic swiftly moved our world online. Once you discover the power of engaging your customers digitally, you won’t want to go back.

3 mins read
Entrepreneur
December 2020

Japan's Softbank Back in The Black As Investments Improve

Japanese technology company SoftBank Group Corp. said it bounced back to profitability in the last quarter as its investments improved in value.

2 mins read
AppleMagazine
November 13, 2020

Focus On Your Mission

Our worlds may feel shaken. But we’re actually much sturdier than we think.

3 mins read
Entrepreneur
Startups Fall - Winter 2020

My Mentor Taught Me Always Go Deeper

A branding expert weighs in on a promising business idea.

2 mins read
Inc.
October - November 2020

Give Your Portfolio Some Shine

With a weaker dollar and inflation stirring, it’s probably a good idea to diversify with a little gold.

5 mins read
Kiplinger's Personal Finance
November 2020

Death and Taxes

The Trump tax cut failed to deliver for all but the very rich. And the gop thinks this is the perfect time for more.

10+ mins read
Mother Jones
July/August 2020

An Alternative Way To Get Burned

YieldStreet pitches investments you can’t get elsewhere. That’s not always a good thing

6 mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
May 11, 2020

Lower Your Health Care Costs

Health savings accounts help defray the cost of high-deductible health plans. They’re also a powerful way to invest for retirement.

9 mins read
Kiplinger's Personal Finance
April 2020