The Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO), the government agency that investigates whitecollar crimes in India, made its first arrest on 8 August 2019, almost two years after it was given the powers to do so in 2017. And it was a big catch. SFIO arrested Neeraj Singal, the erstwhile promoter and Managing Director of Bhushan Steel. Singal was found to have used a web of shell companies, owned directly and indirectly by him and his family, to siphon off thousands of crores borrowed from public sector banks, causing wrongful losses to the banks.
Singal’s arrest could have been a shot in the arm for the agency, which has been in existence for over a decade and still faces a credibility crisis. Not everyone is convinced about its effectiveness in closing cases of fraud and other crimes committed under the Companies Act. Legal experts and law enforcement personnel say that while the agency has investigated several cases, very few of these investigations have led to conviction.
Shiju P.V., partner at legal firm IndiaLaw LLP, says, “There are no closures in SFIO investigations. You go, they give you a report, (but) you cannot see any conclusion. Investigation is one thing… you don’t see conviction.”
The criticism holds some truth. Numbers indicate that SFIO has not accomplished much when it comes to getting convictions and collecting fines.
Short of Target
Between 2003/04 and March 2017, SFIO filed over 1,200 prosecution cases and completed investigations in 312. In the four years to March 2018, the agency investigated 575 cases in all. However, only 12 cases saw a total of 93 convictions. Not a report card to be proud of.
This is the reason that when the agency was given the powers to arrest in 2017, there was hope that it would cease to be a toothless tiger, and the power to arrest would give it the required heft.
This story is from the January 12, 2020 edition of Business Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the January 12, 2020 edition of Business Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Picking Up The Paytm Pieces
Paytm Founder Vijay Shekhar Sharma Is Back In The Trenches After Rbi's Recent Action Left Him Without A Banking Platform. There Are Still Some Opportunities, But He Will Have To Move Swiftly To Grab Them
PMS Vs MF The Big Fight
How do mutual funds and portfolio management services match up? Know the score on structure, rules, entry fees, charges, and tax perks to pick the right path for your financial journey
Four Levers Of Enterprise AI Strategy
Wide-scale private sector AI deployment and new AI-based business opportunities and ecosystems can truly supercharge the Indian economy
"Don't let a unique chance slip by"
JEFF MAGGIONCALDA | CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER | COURSERA
THE INCOMING DISRUPTION
The disruption in the industrial sector is still unknown, but inevitable. Companies need to wake up
THE WHEEL WHISPERER
For Manan Shah, Managing Director of MICL Group, luxury cars are not about showcasing one's wealth or status. It is about personal well-being
TRIPPING WITH TECH
A road trip is an adventure like no other. While you take in the experience, get some peace of mind with these nifty gadgets
Transforming Spaces
WHETHER YOU WANT TO REDECORATE YOUR BEDROOM OR HALLWAY, A GORGEOUS WALLPAPER ADDS FLAIR TO YOUR HOME AND ALLOWS YOU TO STAMP YOUR STYLE IN YOUR NEW ABODE
ALPHATALE
MONEY MANAGERS TO THE AFFLUENT DELIVERED ROBUST RETURNS TO INVESTORS IN THE PAST YEAR, THANKS TO THE BUOYANCY IN THE MARKETS. BUSINESS TODAY DECODES THEIR STRATEGY
"THE ALTERNATIVES SPACE CAN GROW 3X IN FIVE YEARS"
Vikaas M. Sachdeva, MD of Sundaram Alternates, talks about where India's alternative investment industry is headed