In June, the Karnataka Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) for Goods and Services Tax (GST) ruled that Malabar Parota is not the same as ready-to-eat chappati/roti as it has be processed further for consumption, and hence should be taxed at 18 per cent and not 5 per cent (tax rate for chappati). There was outrage and, soon, memes around the ruling started doing rounds of social media.
Blame it on flaws in the way AARs are constituted or complexity of India’s tax laws, the Karnataka AAR is not the only one that has been in news of late for wrong reasons.
Take the issue of tax on compensation paid to directors of an incorporated entity. Two state AARs — Karnataka and Rajasthan — came up with different interpretations and rulings on the issue earlier this year. The Rajasthan AAR said directors are not employees and so their fee should attract GST under the reverse charge mechanism (the company will pay the tax on behalf of directors). The Karnataka AAR, however, noted that an ‘executive’ director sells services as an employee, and therefore, his or her remuneration will not attract GST. However, it also said that remuneration to a non-executive director will attract GST. What is more perplexing is that the Karnataka AAR had, last year, given an opposite ruling on this issue. All this is adding to the confusion of taxpayers.
AARs have been set up to help taxpayers seek clarity, in advance, on tax to be paid on certain transactions, and in doing so avoid long-drawn tax litigation that is so common in India.
However, the fact that every state/Union territory has one AAR, manned by ‘junior’ tax officials, means that the rulings at times lack maturity, consistency and are often pro-revenue, say tax experts.
This story is from the September 06, 2020 edition of Business Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the September 06, 2020 edition of Business Today.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Picking Up The Paytm Pieces
Paytm Founder Vijay Shekhar Sharma Is Back In The Trenches After Rbi's Recent Action Left Him Without A Banking Platform. There Are Still Some Opportunities, But He Will Have To Move Swiftly To Grab Them
PMS Vs MF The Big Fight
How do mutual funds and portfolio management services match up? Know the score on structure, rules, entry fees, charges, and tax perks to pick the right path for your financial journey
Four Levers Of Enterprise AI Strategy
Wide-scale private sector AI deployment and new AI-based business opportunities and ecosystems can truly supercharge the Indian economy
"Don't let a unique chance slip by"
JEFF MAGGIONCALDA | CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER | COURSERA
THE INCOMING DISRUPTION
The disruption in the industrial sector is still unknown, but inevitable. Companies need to wake up
THE WHEEL WHISPERER
For Manan Shah, Managing Director of MICL Group, luxury cars are not about showcasing one's wealth or status. It is about personal well-being
TRIPPING WITH TECH
A road trip is an adventure like no other. While you take in the experience, get some peace of mind with these nifty gadgets
Transforming Spaces
WHETHER YOU WANT TO REDECORATE YOUR BEDROOM OR HALLWAY, A GORGEOUS WALLPAPER ADDS FLAIR TO YOUR HOME AND ALLOWS YOU TO STAMP YOUR STYLE IN YOUR NEW ABODE
ALPHATALE
MONEY MANAGERS TO THE AFFLUENT DELIVERED ROBUST RETURNS TO INVESTORS IN THE PAST YEAR, THANKS TO THE BUOYANCY IN THE MARKETS. BUSINESS TODAY DECODES THEIR STRATEGY
"THE ALTERNATIVES SPACE CAN GROW 3X IN FIVE YEARS"
Vikaas M. Sachdeva, MD of Sundaram Alternates, talks about where India's alternative investment industry is headed