For March, Goldin had a bigger number in mind: $40 million. Thousands of potential buyers had started placing bids that week on more than 2,000 items, including a bat used by Cal Ripken Jr., sneakers signed by Michael Jordan, and at least five trading cards Goldin thought could earn more than $1 million each, including rookie cards featuring LeBron James, Kobe Bryant, and Roberto Clemente.
On auction day, Goldin speaks with only a handful of buyers and sellers, serving for those VIPs as part financial adviser, part therapist. He sets expectations for sale prices, counsels on when to bid and hold, and calms nerves as prices escalate. One buyer, who agreed to be identified by only his first name, Spencer, wanted to discuss three cards: the Bryant, the Clemente, and a 1952 Mickey Mantle. Spencer started buying from Goldin two years ago, initially spending $40,000. Now he’s up to about $3.5 million. “You’re going to make sure I get something?” Spencer asked. Goldin assured him he would.
Spencer landed the Mantle, though he was outbid for the biggest prize of the night, Bryant’s 1996 Topps Chrome Refractor card, which shows the former Los Angeles Lakers star driving to the basket, surrounded by chrome edges that refract the colors of the rainbow. Bryant’s cards have long been among the sport’s most coveted, because of his Hall of Fame career, but their prices have soared since his untimely death last year. This one was especially valuable: It had been graded 10 out of 10 by professional authenticators, one of only two of that particular card to achieve that rating. Cards are graded on how pristine their corners, surfaces, and edges are, and how perfectly the photo is centered. Scratches, stains, or anything else affecting the overall “eye appeal” lower the rating.
Bidding on Goldin’s live auction site had started at $250,000 and passed $1 million before he took a bite of his pizza steak. Soon a bidding war erupted. Someone offered $1.26 million. Moments later, a rival bid $1.36 million. The first person countered with $1.5 million. The value of the card had jumped $500,000 in two minutes.
But 10 minutes before the auction was scheduled to close, customers started calling to say they couldn’t place bids. Goldin went live on Instagram to blame SimpleAuctionSite. com, his tech provider, vowing never to use it again. (Chief Executive Officer Bob Freedman says his company, which supplies more than 150 businesses with auction software, was hacked. “We’ve hired a security firm,” he says. Goldin still uses the platform.)
The site was back online about 30 minutes later, and by the time the extended bidding session closed just before midnight, Goldin had sold $41 million in cards and memorabilia. The Bryant card went for $1.75 million, the highest sum of the evening. “My little company running on 2002 software is one-quarter the size of EBay,” he said on Instagram at about 1 a.m., referring to the volume of his sports memorabilia sales. In a late May auction, Goldin surpassed $50 million in sales, putting the company at $200 million for the year and on pace for $500 million. It keeps 20%.
Goldin, who’s 55, has been buying and selling cards since 1978, when he traded some electric racetrack cars for his friend’s collection of about 5,000 baseball cards, including ones featuring Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, and Nolan Ryan. Over the next four-plus decades, Goldin became the hobby’s most vocal ambassador, appearing on HSN, QVC, CNBC, and any other station that would let him talk up the industry. He started his auction house in 2012, and today he streams live on Instagram at least once a week for up to an hour, opening packs from a full box of cards—a “break,” in industry terms— while taking questions with his son, Paul, who’s 7.
As they stream from their home, Paul identifies the rookie cards of promising young stars. Goldin interjects to grab certain players, show them to the camera, and place them in protective plastic sleeves. In the past year, his following on Instagram has increased from about 1,000 to more than 38,000. Pro athletes including Cleveland Indians reliever Bryan Shaw and Philadelphia 76ers guard Seth Curry have joined the streams to discuss the market; Curry even invited Goldin to a game. In February, Goldin opened a box of Pokémon cards with YouTube star Logan Paul. “We have something the hobby has never had before,” Goldin says. “All of a sudden, we’re cool.”
The sports memorabilia industry is on track to see almost $10 billion in sales this year, most of which will come from trading cards. Just as investors with too much time and cash on their hands during the pandemic have bought cryptocurrencies, nonfungible tokens (NFTs), music rights, and other alternative assets, they’re funneling cash into cards.
Continue reading your story on the app
Continue reading your story in the magazine
Bitcoin of the Realm
What happened when a surfing town in El Salvador went full crypto
Nasdaq. NYSE. SushiSwap?
Decentralized finance uses crypto to build a new, unregulated kind of market
Whether or not he becomes New York’s next mayor, Yang has brought his signature idea—to just give people money—into the political mainstream
A One-Hit Wonder Looks for No. 2
Niantic teams up with Hasbro and Nintendo to find life beyond Pokémon Go
Working Abroad Is Easy. Taxes Aren't
More companies make remote work a job perk, but that can mean a paperwork nightmare
This Will Blow Your Mind
WITH KERNEL, BRYAN JOHNSON IS BETTING $110 MILLION THAT ACTIVELY MONITORING OUR BRAIN ACTIVITY WILL HELP US ALL LIVE BEYOND OUR YEARS. HE’S STUDYING EVERYTHING ELSE IN HIS BODY, TOO
Latin America Turns on The Establishment
Pedro Castillo’s victory in Peru signals a regionwide fury at incumbents, a boon for the left
AIRBNB HAS A NIGHTMARE PROBLEM
WHEN VIOLENT CRIMES HAPPEN DURING STAYS, THE COMPANY’S SECRETIVE SAFETY TEAM IS CALLED ON TO SOOTHE GUESTS, HELP FAMILIES—AND PREVENT PR DISASTERS
A Bittersweet Homecoming
Filipino migrant workers repatriated during the pandemic face a dearth of job opportunities
Young U.S. Jews Shift on Israel
Millennial and Gen Z progressives question American support of Israeli policies, a point of tension for the Democratic Party
AIRBUS-BOEING DEAL EASES US EU TENSIONS BUT CONFLICTS REMAIN
The deal the United States and the European Union reached this week to end their long-running rift over subsidies to Boeing and Airbus will suspend billions in punitive tariffs. It will ease trans-Atlantic tensions. And it will let the two sides focus on a common economic threat: China.
AMAZON ALLOTS $300 MILLION FOR HOUSING NEAR MASS TRANSIT
Amazon is providing $300 million in low-interest loans to support housing located near mass transit in the Washington, D.C., area and the Seattle and Nashville, Tennessee, regions.
CAN YOU MIX AND MATCH COVID-19 VACCINES?
Can you mix and match two-dose COVID-19 vaccines?
INTERNET OUTAGES BRIEFLY DISRUPT ACCESS TO WEBSITES, APPS
A wave of brief internet outages hit the websites and apps of dozens of financial institutions, airlines and other companies across the globe Thursday and Friday.
CASSILL TO BE PAID IN CRYPTOCURRENCY IN DEAL WITH VOYAGER
Landon Cassill will be the first NASCAR driver paid entirely in cryptocurrency in a sponsorship deal with Voyager that begins at Nashville Superspeedway this weekend.
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF CHINA'S NEW SPACE STATION
Adding a crew to China’s new orbiting space station is another major advance for the burgeoning space power.
HONG KONG WATCHING CHINESE NUCLEAR PLANT AFTER LEAK REPORTED
China’s government said Tuesday no abnormal radiation was detected outside a nuclear power plant near Hong Kong following a news report of a leak, while Hong Kong’s leader said her administration was closely watching the facility.
‘A SUMMER OF FREEDOM': VACCINE GIVES NEW MEANING TO JULY 4TH
President Joe Biden wants to imbue Independence Day with new meaning this year by encouraging nationwide celebrations to mark the country’s effective return to normalcy after 16 months of coronavirus pandemic disruption and more than 600,000 lives lost.
SELF-DRIVING CAR PIONEER WAYMO GETS $2.5B TO FUEL AMBITIONS
Waymo, the self-driving car pioneer spun off from Google, isn’t allowing a recent wave of executive departures to detour its plans to expand its robotic taxi service.
LOUISIANA CREATES RULES FOR SELF-DRIVING DELIVERY DEVICES
Louisiana has created a framework for self-driving delivery robots to drop off packages on the state’s streets, under a bill backed by lawmakers and Gov. John Bel Edwards.