Amateur Boatbuilding: What if I Make a Mistake?
Small Craft Advisor|November - December 2020
Everyone makes mistakes. If we try new things we will make mistakes, an essential part of the learning experience. It’s nice to learn from mistakes of others, but we learn more lessons and they stick better when they are our own. The more painful the mistake, the stronger the lesson learned.

That’s not to say you should go into a project blindly and learn only from mistakes. We should first research by reading or asking knowledgeable sources, to ensure we enter a new experience with the best chance of success. But even armed with knowledge and experience, there are myriad potential mistakes lying in wait.

I designed the Paper Jet with a building procedure in mind, but soon learned it couldn’t be done and had to backtrack and find another way. I had other backtracks too, but eventually had my boat complete. The backtracking probably added 25 hours to my building time, but I was doing something nobody had done before. I had lessons to learn that could only come from building the prototype, so that I could write building instructions to enable others to build without making those same mistakes.

If I were scared of making mistakes I wouldn’t try new things. I designed and built the first radius chine plywood boat, my own Black Cat, and made mistakes along the way, but was able to recover and move on.

I shrugged off criticisms from the skeptics about the wisdom of my project and its chances of success. The skeptics were of no consequence unless I allowed them to be. They were generally people who had never built anything significant themselves. Typically people who get pleasure from someone else making a mistake don’t achieve much themselves. Disregard those negative people.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM SMALL CRAFT ADVISORView All

POTTER WITH A LATEEN RIG?

Our editor-at-large Larry Brown is 75 now…an increasingly ancient mariner. He’s sailed various Potters since the early 1990s.

4 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

Vintage Lightning

Reborn as a Camp-Cruiser

6 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

The Joy of it All

Choosing a Boat Design

10 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

OPENING DAY

Sitting hove-to in 30 knots of wind was not how I anticipated spending my opening day.

3 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

RECONSIDERING ROSIE'S RIG

It was a typical hot Mississippi day when I walked into the Ocean Springs Yacht Club to cool off. I had just spent two hours bent in half while working inside the cabin of my West Wight Potter 15. I was stiff and drenched in sweat but feeling proud of myself. I had just turned Rosie into a lateen-rigged catboat.

4 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

SHALLOW DRAFT

When we were kids, we had a cocker spaniel aboard during summer cruises. The dog apparently had a massive bladder, but we kids were happy to row her ashore when nature called. We thought boating with a pet was terrific…but did our folks have a voice in the matter?

3 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

TECH BIGHTS

Some fiberglass boats, like Boston Whaler skiffs and MacGregor power-sailers, are built with integral flotation foam between the inner and outer laminations. Roger MacGregor was willing to flood his water-ballasted boats just to prove that they would not sink—and you can still find his old sales videos if you want to see for yourself. (youtube.com/ watch?v=hemNdJmzQBo)

8 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

MAKING THE SWITCH

Following are some methods for adding a Lateen rig to a Potter 15. Most of the photos are of my boat, but some clever ideas from others are included as well.

3 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

FIVE QUESTIONS: Richard Woods

Sailing experience with Richard Woods

2 mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021

Core Sound Cruising

Hmmm. I’m in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, with a nifty camp-cruiser sailboat on a trailer. I have a daughter on a sailing lake in Michigan, and another daughter on Long Island Sound in Connecticut.

10+ mins read
Small Craft Advisor
July - August 2021