BROTHERS FROM ANOTHER MOTHER
Motor Trend|August 2020
HYUNDAI MOTOR SIBLINGS SHOW YOUR CAR CAN BE SPORTY OR LUXURIOUS FOR THE SAME PRICE
SCOTT EVANS

They used to rule the road, these nimble, compact rear-drive sedans, ready to shred Angeles Crest upon request and zip across states with swift composure.

But with SUVs now the first choice of the majority of Americans, a shrinking number of these performance-minded sedans reside in showrooms in hopes that someone might be smitten with a design that is more sleek than chunky.

Case in point are two of the newest performance sedan players: the mainstream Kia Stinger GT and the premium Genesis G70.

Comparing similar mainstream and luxury cars can’t get much closer than this. Kia and Genesis are both part of the Hyundai Motor Group. The two cars are built on the same platform. They share the same engines and transmissions and countless other bits and bobs.

In the industry’s distant past, lazy, cynical product planning would mean they’d be literally the same car with different badges. Today, they demonstrate just how different the same hardware can be tuned and tweaked to accomplish different missions.

“They’re very different cars,” road test editor and co-judge Chris Walton said. “It is remarkable that they can start from the same template and come out the other side so different.”

The Stinger GT’s mission is right there in its name. Kia boldly launched its sport sedan at the Nürburgring, we then invited it to our annual Best Driver’s Car competition, and it has proven itself to be a worthy, sporty, powerful grand touring car.

This particular as-tested car has all the performance parts—but despite stiff springs to improve handling, the Stinger still has plenty of suspension travel and somewhat soft anti-roll bars. This provides a more relaxed demeanor, a distinct sporty edge rather than a full-time sport sedan.

The Kia is never going to feel as light and lithe as the G70, though. With its shorter wheelbase, the Genesis wears its sportiness on its sleeve, ready to attack a corner at any moment. It’s laser-focused on beating the best luxury sport sedans in the world at their own game—as it showed when it won our 2019 Car of the Year nod. There’s significantly less body roll in corners and vertical motion over bumps. It’s buttoned-down and buttoned-up.

Still, a luxury sport sedan isn’t a race car, so the G70 has a generous amount of compliance in the suspension to keep bad roads from rattling your brain around inside your skull. Because it doesn’t have to amp up the sport factor—even in Sport mode—the G70 rides more sweetly, absorbing bumps and broken pavement more gently than the Stinger. It’s a delicate balance some luxury sport sedans don’t quite get right, but the Genesis does.

“I wasn’t expecting the G70’s ride to be this plush,” Walton said. “What a truly well-rounded and fun car. I could live with the Stinger’s ride, but given the choice, I prefer the Genesis.”

Now would be a good time to stop and recognize the elephant in the room. Although these two have the same chassis, 3.3-liter twin-turbo V-6 engine, and eight-speed automatic transmission, they are not at all identical. The Stinger Kia was able to provide us is the limited edition GTS model, which means it’s all-wheel drive. Our G70 is rear-drive. The GTS is a one-year deal, a sport package for all-wheel-drive, six-cylinder Stingers designed to address criticism of the base all-wheel-drive system’s effect on steering.

Thankfully, this isn’t a track test. If it were, we might take note of the difference in steering feel, but that’s hardly critical to a decision between mainstream and luxury. We cannot avoid, however, taking note of the difference in curb weight.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM MOTOR TRENDView All

CARLOS GHOSN

SPEAKS ON HIS TIME IN A JAPANESE PRISON AND LIFE AS A WANTED FUGITIVE

5 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

2022 GMO Hummer EV

Our kind of monster.

3 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

2022 TOYOTA TUNDRA

THE ALL-NEW TRUCK AIMS AT THE HEART OF THE MARKET.

4 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

2022 Ford Maverick

Redefining the (small) truck.

2 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

2022 Toyota Corolla Cross

Earning the famous nameplate.

2 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

Powertrain Tech Deep Dive

CAR OF THE YEAR WINNER

3 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

LUCID AIR

THIS GAME-CHANGING ELECTRIC SEDAN POINTS THE WAY FORWARD

8 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

Lithium-sulfur battery promises 3x energy density, pricing that undercuts combustion.

Might lithium-sulfur batteries push solid-state aside as The Next Big Thing in battery technology? Silicon Valley battery tech company Lyten just came out of stealth mode at September's Motor Bella car show/mobility conference in metro Detroit after several years of federally funded research, and it made a very promising pitch: Triple the energy per weight!

3 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

The one new car I most want to drive.

The Big Picture

3 mins read
Motor Trend
January 2022

2021 Ford F-150

No, no—relax. There is no V-8 under the hood of the 2021 F-150 Raptor. At least, not yet—Ford says the eight-cylinder Raptor R super truck is rumbling its way toward the horizon break and should arrive sometime next year. For now, the standard Raptor is the top-of-the-line off-road baddie from the F-150 family.

3 mins read
Motor Trend
February 2022
RELATED STORIES

Home on the Greens

Golf-driven real estate is finally getting out of the rough.

6 mins read
Bloomberg Businessweek
September 20, 2021

Golf in the Lowcountry

Place South Carolina’s Kiawah Island Golf Resort high on your must-play list.

3 mins read
Global Traveler
April - May 2021

PARK OUTSIDE: KIA RECALLS NEARLY 380K VEHICLES FOR FIRE RISK

Kia is telling owners of nearly 380,000 vehicles in the U.S. to park them outdoors due to the risk of an engine compartment fire.

1 min read
AppleMagazine
March 12, 2021

B&B: CONFLICT WITH ZOE AND PARIS

Though she was initially glad to see Paris, Zoe feels it’s time for her sib to move on.

2 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
December 28, 2020

Scene & Heard

BEHIND the SCENES!

5 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
November 09, 2020

Kia - Stinger A Year With South Korea's Star Sedan

Perfectly balanced, as all things should be

6 mins read
Automobile
February 2020

Kia Nurse - Up To Something

She grew up idolizing Mike and now she’s officially part of the Jordan Brand family. New York Liberty guard Kia Nurse has already made history—and she’s only getting started.

4 mins read
Slam
September - October 2019

Telluride

Boxy Good Looks and a Full Suite of Features

4 mins read
Truck Trend
September - October 2019

Shane Warne ‘I CAN'T WAIT TO BE A GRANDAD!'

Could the Aussie cricketing legend soon have something to celebrate?

2 mins read
Woman's Day Australia
January 10, 2022

Kia's New People Mover - Carens

The three-row Carens has been unveiled and Dhruv Saxena got a chance to take a closer look at Kia’s next launch for the Indian market at its world premiere

3 mins read
Auto Today
January 2022