Just Give Me Some Space: Discussions And Beyond
Indian Architect & Builder|November 2019
Just Give Me Some Space (JGMSS) is Suha Riyaz Khopatkar’s debut book that paints a portrait of the dynamic life of an architecture student.
Suha Riyaz Khopatkar

It shares light-hearted anecdotes and playful illustrations from the five years of architectural college education; while navigating through life and growing emotionally and professionally as a young adult; from entering wide-eyed into a design studio to working through the highs and lows of the degree to finally surmounting the final thesis year and coming out as an architect. Building new relationships with friends, family, the society, self and most-importantly with architecture is a key theme within the book. A relationship that is brimming with passion, angst and awe. In the creative community of architecture and design, this book is the first of its kind that addresses mental wellness and self-care.

While a detailed account of life in architecture college, it stays relevant to professionals too as it appeals to the adolescent search for self. It urges students to soul-search, discover their purpose in life and ultimately find their space in the sea of opportunities that lie ahead.

The book released on 28th August 2019 at Kamla Raheja Vidyanidhi Institute for Architecture, Mumbai followed by a discussion around multi-dimensional facets of teaching and learning. Following is an excerpt from the panel discussion at the launch, with Vandana Ranjitsinh, Rohan Shivkumar, Nisha Nair-Gupta and Suha Riyaz Khopatkar; moderated by Anuj Daga.

ANUJ DAGA: It is a pleasure to share the stage with all of you because each of us represents a certain generation of teachers and students, so we can vouch for a generation that shaped us in a certain way. One of the key things is that I have been constantly thinking since I have read the book is the whole aspect of how ‘we’ relate to ‘students’ - the whole insider-outsider conundrum. And as teachers who are still learning, I would like to pose, how do we understand the student as a multidimensional persona? Our engagements with the student often happen in brief moments, whereas the student, in parallel, is living a life of their own, beyond the classroom. This “extra”[academic] life is inevitably feeding into the work of the student itself. How can we build those empathetic relationships within our discussions with the student?

ROHAN SHIVKUMAR: As teachers we expect architects and architecture students to imbibe certain skill-sets and often I would be irked at them for their sketching skills (the lack of it) and so on. But we forget that this young ‘skilled’ person, between the ages of 18-23, is also growing as a human-being. They are forming an identity, navigating architecture school and simultaneously becoming an adult. In school, as teachers, we focus primarily on developing the dexterities of the profession that they have undertaken. We perhaps overlook the personal trials and tribulations that the student undergoes in their personal life; hormones, finances, keeping up appearances, etc. For the first two years of architecture school, we should be conscious that the person is growing as a professional and a person, and both journeys are intermingled.

VANDANA RANJITSINH: The teacher who is assigned to students in the first year is the one who engages with them first-hand and initiates them into their journey of understanding this vocation. They get them excited, introduce them to materials, ideas and more; they should work with them sans judgement and let them operate in their space. The book mentions an analogy between the L-plate on a car to the first year of architecture school. A new driver with a learner’s licence puts up a sticker or an L-plate to indicate that they are novices. The L-plate endows a certain comfort but eventually the driver must traverse through roads sans it. And the road does get tough. A similar ‘L-plate’ exists in first year of architecture school that steers students but is ripped off in the subsequent years as the curriculum and life gets tougher. Some of us are tough on the students because we are preparing them for the demanding life that transpires after college. But these are very nascent years when their hormones are fizzing, they’re growing up and getting to know the world and we need to give them some space.

NISHA NAIR-GUPTA: Along with developing an idea of the self, our mental health is invariably tested in the high-strung scenarios from our architecture college. Eventually we develop lifestyle disorders/ arrangements in these five years of studying architecture which we normalise and carry forward into our professional lives. These issues must be addressed more proactively in our education system as well as practice. So during the course of our conversation over the book, I feel, this is a key aspect that can be one of the trajectories the book could take. Because I feel that we don’t talk about the lifestyle issues that we as architects undergo.

SUHA R. KHOPATKAR: The school to architecture college transition is tricky. In elementary school if I did not know the answer to a question, I would think of ways to trick the teacher into giving me better grades. I would either write in a better handwriting or write excessively by using multiple supplements. And this is why we are stumped on our first architectural jury because the entire mode of evaluation and the student-teacher relationship is different. We were now being judged not only by our work but also by our disposition, attitudes, stance, speech and so on. And as designing is a neverending process, the teacher’s requirements/expectations inculcate a mind-set that students have to eat, drink and breathe architecture! This vicious routine affects the student physically and mentally. So, it is very important for the teacher to be more receptive and help students acclimate.

ANUJ DAGA: This brings us to consider what strain of practice the student belongs to. Often we as teachers are trying to find that out to channel the student’s energies towards... We often sense that the way in which the student thinks of architecture may not be how we conceive of it traditionally. What are the strategies through which these modes can be strengthened beyond the normative, beyond what the profession asks for?

VANDANA RANJITSINH: As teachers we need to listen till we hear that non-conventional and non-traditional voice. Every student has a voice that sometimes gets stifled due to competition, as elementary schools have inculcated this business of scoring high marks. Then there are external pressures or pressures that are constructed primarily by the student themselves. How do you break that? Suha talks about the “Snowball Effect”; there’s a deadline and we are trying to help and hear the students, sometimes the voice takes time to be heard, but the deadline approaches, it’s snowballing and they’re sliding down this avalanche. Sometimes the system doesn’t allow them to get up. So you need to reassure the student that you are listening. Tell them you can sketch, throw that CAD out the window; you can’t sketch, pick up a model; you can’t speak, you need to put your thoughts in order; but you need to hear that voice. And at times the voice is so confused and troubled with pain; perhaps personal crisis, family problems, adolescent love, etc. And entwined amidst these circumstances, they put up work. And as I say in my foreword, that’s why we teach! You want them to put that offering, that thought in front of you and that’s when you know that now, they can do it.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM INDIAN ARCHITECT & BUILDERView All

Interlacing Perspectives

‘Meraki-2019’ A visionary Seminar series presented by Dr.Baliram Hiray College of Architecture, Bandra(East), Mumbai.

3 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
November 2019

Facilitating A Community Through Architectural Practice

The humble, self-designed, self-built and organically planned home built by the majority of the world population rarely gets appreciated and critiqued as a viable lesson in architectural design.

5 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
November 2019

The Art Of Solving Problems Creatively

The practice of architecture is perhaps incomplete without the complement of a variety of other arts.

3 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
November 2019

Upcycling towards a playful tomorrow

Play is like the middle child, often forgotten, and always taking a back seat. For young kids, play can simply be running around, armwrestling with friends, building sandcastles on the beach, or singing popular music tracks in the shower.

3 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
November 2019

Balancing The Poetics And Pragmatism Of Everyday Design

Humanity is faced with an oxymoronic crisis. The crisis involves the earth, the environment, impending looms of climate change, deforestation, loss of species, dwindling resources etc.

3 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
November 2019

Just Give Me Some Space: Discussions And Beyond

Just Give Me Some Space (JGMSS) is Suha Riyaz Khopatkar’s debut book that paints a portrait of the dynamic life of an architecture student.

10+ mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
November 2019

The Next In Vernacular Architecture

Architecture has become a capitalist.

5 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
IAB October 2019

Rethinking The Future: Architecture And Its Education

“I want to be like animals, the bird makes a nest in one or two days, the rat digs a hole in a night, but intelligent humans like us spend 30 years to have a house, that’s wrong.” - Jon Jandai

10 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
IAB October 2019

Uniting The Human-Scale With The City-Scale

London-based architect Usman Haque is famed for his interactive architectural systems, and for his exploration of newer, more effective ways of creating human engagement and interaction through his designs. Indian Architect & Builder caught up with him, to quiz him on a variety of topics such as his journey as an architect, his inspirations and philosophies, architects using the digital revolution to their advantage, and more!

6 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
IAB October 2019

Framing spaces

Almost every architect also doubles as a photographer or at least an enthusiast.

5 mins read
Indian Architect & Builder
IAB October 2019
RELATED STORIES

Taliban seek Afghanistan's UN seat; world says no, not yet

Name New Envoy, Setting Up Showdown With Erstwhile Govt’s Ambassador

2 mins read
The Times of India Delhi
September 23, 2021

पैरालंपिक बैडमिंटन : कृष्णा नागर ने स्वर्ण जीता, सुहास ने रजत पदक

कृष्णा नागर ने यहां बैडमिंटन में दूसरा स्वर्ण पदक दिलाया जबकि उनसे पहले सुहास यथिराज ने रजत पदक हासिल किया जिससे भारतीय दल के लिये तोक्यो पैरालंपिक में दिन 'सुपर संडे' साबित हुआ।

1 min read
Samagya
September 06, 2021

SAYONARA, TOKYO

India’s Unprecedented Paralympics Campaign Ends With A Golden Hue

3 mins read
The Times of India Delhi
September 06, 2021

States preparing for next virus wave focus on children

Schools in at least 11 of India’s 28 states have opened ater more than a year of closures, raising worries these could become breeding grounds for transmission of the virus

3 mins read
Gulf Today
August 20, 2021

WRITING FROM THE MARGINS

Nagesh Kukunoor broke out with Hyderabad Blues in 1998. More than two decades later, the filmmaker is still dodging predictable tropes while enjoying his day in the OTT sun

1 min read
India Today
August 16, 2021

50% सभी धार्मिक स्थलों को कैपेसिटी के साथ खोलने की अनमति देने की मांग

पीर मखदूम साहेब चैरिटेबल ट्रस्ट और हाजी अली दरगाह के ट्रस्टी मोहम्मद सुहैल खंडवानी ने सभी धार्मिक स्थलों को 50% कैपेसिटी के साथ खोलने की उन्होने एक पत्र लिखकर मुंबई जिले के कलेक्टर राजीव निवत कर से मांग की है कि लॉकडाउन के दौरान सरकारी नियमों का पालन करते हुए सभी धार्मिक स्थलों को बंद कर दिया गया था परंतु सरकार द्वारा अन्य क्षेत्रों में थोड़ी राहत दी गई है।

1 min read
Rokthok Lekhani
June 09, 2021

HELPING OUT, NATURALLY

Yoga Bar’s initiatives on making breakfast healthy and helping out the Covid affected

2 mins read
The Morning Standard
May 24, 2021

TALES FROM THE OTHER SIDE

COVID SURVIVORS FROM WITHIN INDIA TODAY’S WORKFORCE ON FIGHTING THE VIRUS, WHAT GOT THEM THROUGH IT AND THE REALISATIONS THE DISEASE BROUGHT WITH IT

10+ mins read
India Today
April 26, 2021

SOCIETY: MUTTON HUNGER

When the Wazwaan country is deprived of its staple food, it is a crisis for the government and the society that still is stalemate, reports Khalid Bashir Gura

7 mins read
Kashmir Life
March 14, 2021

LAGRIPORA

Suhail Ahanger, one of the two cops who were killed in a hit-and-run attack by militants in Baghat, was orphaned when he was seven months old. His father, Mushtaq, was gone missing during the early days of militancy in October 1990 much before Suhail was born.

1 min read
Kashmir Life
February 28 - March 06,2021