How could they be so foolish?
Why did Pep Guardiola get this one so wrong?
As City head for another showdown with Cole Palmer and Chelsea this weekend, they will come face to face with the surprise success of the season. Palmer left City as a promising youngster without a Premier League goal to his name in September and now he has 20, level with Erling Haaland. He is the form player in the division and the signing of the season.
There's a very real chance he will stop City from defending their FA Cup trophy if he continues his scoring form today and questions will again be raised of just how the Blues allowed him to slip from their grasp.
But the truth - however inconvenient for the weekend narratives - is that the £42.5m transfer was a good deal for City, for Palmer and, as it turns out, for Chelsea.
Were the same people calling that fee a bargain 20 goals later saying the same back in the summer? Maybe not. At that point, he was just as much another expensive Chelsea winger as anything else. An expensive gamble.
However talented Palmer clearly was, there was no predicting that he would be as successful as he has been at Stamford Bridge.
City had given Palmer chances over the previous two seasons, but he always struggled to take his chance in the Premier League.
He seemed to be torn between doing what he thought Guardiola wanted him to do and doing what his brilliant instincts were urging him to do.
Is it a surprise that he name-checked Mauricio Pochettino for giving him the freedom' to express himself as a reason behind his sparkling season? When Guardiola introduced him in the Community Shield in August, he told Palmer to 'be himself' and a wonderful goal followed. And so did a clever header in the UEFA Super Cup.
That came off the back of a starring role in England's U21 Euro success - and Palmer returned a different, more confident player.
Esta historia es de la edición April 20, 2024 de Manchester Evening News.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor ? Conectar
Esta historia es de la edición April 20, 2024 de Manchester Evening News.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor? Conectar
House Prices Rise Above Inflation Rate
Some Parts Of Region Have Seen Increases
Trent steals show with crisp volley as England coast
TRENT Alexander-Arnold capped an impressive individual display with a tremendous volley as England beat Bosnia and Herzegovina 3-0 in last night's Euro 2024 warm-up friendly.
United yet to make call on whether winger is Garna have very busy summer
NO DECISION ON GARNACHO PLAYING IN PARIS OLYMPICS
Penalties of City facing expulsion or relegation are not sensationalised'
CITY can expect to learn their fate over the Premier League charges they are facing next summer, according to a football finance expert.
Ras has message for United target after bad injury
UNITED striker Rasmus Hojlund has sent a message to a former teammate who has been linked with following him to Old Trafford this summer.
Jack could be left out in the cold as Southgate ponders summer Euro squad
GARETH Southgate failed to assure Jack Grealish of his place in the England squad for the European Championship ahead of Friday's deadline.
'He'd be proud that we pulled together'
RUGBY LEAGUE STAR ROB BURROW'S FAMILY PAY TRIBUTE
Festival-goers urged to use public transport
TRANSPORT BOSSES TELL PARKLIFE PUNTERS TO PLAN FOR THEIR JOURNEY
'I've got a good job but can't afford a lot of basic things'
\"IT'S quite terrifying that I have a good job which is reasonably well paid, but I can't afford a lot of basic things,\" says supply teacher Mark Pillotti.
Starmer's case for the nation's defence
IT'S a venue which has seen the likes of Margaret Thatcher and Tony Blair in the past.