Harming Pets
Cat Talk|October 2017

Through the Expansion of Emotion-Based Damages

Kelly Crouch CFA Legislative Information Liaison
Harming Pets

People adore their pets, be they furry, fishy, or flying. We are devastated when our pets are hurt, or their lives are lost. When that harm is caused by another’s negligence, some pet owners seek damages for their emotional loss in addition to any economic loss, not understanding that emotion-based damages harms pets in general. In most states, non-economic damages are not allowed in negligence cases for pets or humans. Some groups, like the Animal Legal Defense Fund, seek to overturn existing law, arguing that the human-animal bond has increased so much over the last three decades that the liability for negligence by veterinarians, groomers, pet-sitters and the next-door neighbor should expand to include emotion-based damages. According to Phil Goldberg, this claim of a sudden change in the human-animal bond is a myth. (Goldberg, p. 65) Pets have held a special place in our hearts since they invaded our hearths. The more recent inclusion of the terms “fur kids” or “pet parents” in our vocabulary does not describe some new level of emotional relationships we have with our pets despite the marketing hype around such terminology. Some people may argue that we spend more on pets than ever before and that expenditure is a measurement of love. While American pet owners are expected to spend almost $70 billion dollars on their pets in 2017 (Pet Industry Market Size & Ownership Statistics), this sum is a measurement of cost which in cludes both necessities and indulgences. It is not a measurement of an exponential increase of love for our pets. Accepting the myth that pets are “functional children” as truth to justify expanding damages in negligence-based torts would overturn centuries of well-reasoned American jurisprudence. It would also have a far-reaching, foreseeable, harmful impact on our pets beyond the courtroom.

Understanding the Role of Damages in Torts

Esta historia es de la edición October 2017 de Cat Talk.

Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.

Esta historia es de la edición October 2017 de Cat Talk.

Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.

MÁS HISTORIAS DE CAT TALKVer todo
No Kitten! Cats Are Part of the Military!
Cat Talk

No Kitten! Cats Are Part of the Military!

Felines have graced the decks of boats and ships back nearly to the beginning of time, roaming freely on passenger ships, war vessels, and merchant schooners, keeping vermin at bay.

time-read
4 minutos  |
April 2024
Feline Summer Movie Fun!
Cat Talk

Feline Summer Movie Fun!

School is almost OUT! Huzzah! But raindrops are plunking against the window, the amusement and water parks haven’t opened yet, camping is out, and roasted hot dogs and S’mores are another month away.

time-read
5 minutos  |
April 2024
Kittens Are Special...
Cat Talk

Kittens Are Special...

...and so are some of the show rules for them:

time-read
7 minutos  |
April 2024
Genetic Pleiotropy and the Risks in Breeding Recessive Mutations
Cat Talk

Genetic Pleiotropy and the Risks in Breeding Recessive Mutations

Nearly everyone loves what’s rare and unique. A slight defect in the minting process of a coin can create a demand and a value well beyond the face value of the coin. The coin is functionally no different than its perfectly minted counterpart, but its scarcity and uniqueness alone make it more desirable than the rest.

time-read
5 minutos  |
April 2024
Good Things Come To Those Who Wait
Cat Talk

Good Things Come To Those Who Wait

Most new pet owners can hardly wait to get their new kitten home. How to explain why most breeders wait until the kitten is older? | Let's take a look at WHY breeders delay, and why new owners will be happier in the long run that they did.

time-read
10 minutos  |
April 2024
Who's That Kitten?
Cat Talk

Who's That Kitten?

Your queen has successfully delivered her litter!

time-read
4 minutos  |
April 2024
Kittens & Worms
Cat Talk

Kittens & Worms

You have settled in for the evening with your soft, sleepy kitten. As you rub her, you notice that her belly is large, round, and squishy.

time-read
4 minutos  |
April 2024
GESTATION What Is Normal & What Influences Gestation.?
Cat Talk

GESTATION What Is Normal & What Influences Gestation.?

About 46.5 million households in the United States report owning cats in 2024.

time-read
4 minutos  |
April 2024
Preparing Kittens For the Show Hall
Cat Talk

Preparing Kittens For the Show Hall

Socializing kittens and making sure they are confident for their new family is only a part of the job description for a show breeder.

time-read
3 minutos  |
April 2024
Library Cats felis cattus bibliotheca
Cat Talk

Library Cats felis cattus bibliotheca

Introduction - The Middle Ages, sometimes referred to as “The Dark Ages,” spanned approximately one thousand years, between 479 AD and 1450 AD. This time period is not generally considered to have been friendly to anyone, human nor animal, but it was especially hostile toward felines. Ignorance of knowledge and science was rampant among the majority of the population, with the ability to read limited to clerics and the wealthy. Myths, legends, and galliard songs spread widely throughout Europe as people migrated from place to place, searching for food and a safe habitat. Fear of the unknown and the unexplainable, particularly of witches and their cat familiars, was spread not only by the stories and songs, but by the Popes themselves. Without touching on the atrocities of medieval times, let us just say it was not the best time to be a cat.

time-read
5 minutos  |
February 2024