Try GOLD - Free

Writing a Great Retelling

Writer’s Digest

|

May - June 2024

When I say retelling, it's Sherlock Holmes who comes to mind. Just in recent film and TV, Robert Downey Jr. and Benedict Cumber-batch stand out for their interpretations of Arthur Conan Doyle's beloved character.

- Moriah Richard

Writing a Great Retelling

But then there's also Henry Cavill's role in Enola Holmes, where Sherlock was a bit character, and the star of the story was his little sister.

What about the retellings that don't have Sherlock translated so directly? Dr. Gregory House of the hit TV show "House," for example, is a known adaptation of Holmes, with homages to the original story sprinkled throughout the show (like the fact that his apartment is 221B).

And when it comes to unpaid creative work, a quick check on the fan fiction site Archive of Our Own shows that as of writing this article, there are 139,718 works with the tag "Sherlock Holmes." There are more retellings out there than I could ever hope to count, and there are more being written by the day. Whether it's Jane Austen, Mary Shelley, William Shakespeare, or well-loved myths, you might be called to retell a story through a brand new lens. Before you dive into it, here are some aspects to consider.

FIGURE OUT YOUR "WHY"

The story has already been told successfully-so why do you want to retell it? What is going to be different about the way you tell the story that will add something to the original tale? What will your voice add to the conversation that the original author started?

This is going to be the most important part of the retelling process. Because if you can't answer how your story will put a special spin on the original tale, then you'll probably have a hard time making your book stand out among the crowd later on.

MORE STORIES FROM Writer’s Digest

Writer’s Digest

100 Best Markets for Writers

A list of print and online publications looking for freelancers to contribute their knowledge on everything from pet care to finance and beyond.

time to read

65 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Writer’s Digest

Memoir Plus

Add a bonus to your personal narrative for a marketing boost.

time to read

8 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Surefire Ways to Sell Your Children's Book

In my 28 years editing children's books, I've learned that publishing exists at the intersection of art and commerce.

time to read

5 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

The ABCs of Freelance Success

Many freelance writers, especially those at the beginning of their careers, tend to place almost all of their professional focus on one specific component: craft.

time to read

5 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Writer’s Digest

How to Write in Different Genres

Emiko Jean and Yulin Kuang share tips and strategies for how they successfully write in different genres and mediums.

time to read

8 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Small But Mighty

Why small presses might be the perfect home for your book.

time to read

8 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Writer’s Digest

The Story Behind the Story

What's backstory, and what's it doing here anyway?

time to read

6 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Writer’s Digest

2025 Year in Review

Publishing expert Jane Friedman recaps the biggest news in the industry.

time to read

8 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Writer’s Digest

What Is Your Story Question?

When a story isn't working—when you know it's not quite coming together, when beta readers and critique partners confirm your fears but can't put a finger on why, or you're not getting offers from agents or publishers—savvy authors start trying to diagnose the issue by examining its component parts, like characterization, plot, and stakes.

time to read

6 mins

Yearbook 2026

Writer’s Digest

Writer's Digest 27th Annual 101 Best Websites for Writers

For the 27th year, Writer's Digest is shining a light on 101 websites with a goal of helping writers in a variety of ways.

time to read

26 mins

Yearbook 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size