Consumption Vs. Trophy Fishing Can They Coexist?
Musky Hunter|February/March 2017

Researchers try to answer if trophy musky fisheries can be developed where harvest occurs

Jordan Weeks
Consumption Vs. Trophy Fishing Can They Coexist?

Disclaimer — The intent of this article is to summarize the results of a published research study regarding the effects of angling and tribal harvest on trophy muskellunge in Wisconsin. The intent is to disseminate facts. The article does not necessarily reflect the opinions of the agency for which I work.

As I write this, I can’t help but think of the many conversations I have had, and will continue to have, regarding harvest of muskellunge. These conversations seem to rear their ugly heads during the winter when anglers long for open water and convene in large groups to “fix” everything that is wrong with the sport. Most of the “answers” revolve around size limits and spearing (tribal and darkhouse). While size limits have been trending up almost everywhere muskies live, spearing seems to anger anglers like nothing else.

Let me make this clear. The Chippewa tribes have the right to spear. That is Not up for debate. The question is: what impact does it have on trophy potential of muskellunge in Wisconsin? Furthermore, when you add angling and hooking mortality, is there any real chance to grow trophy muskies? Given the fact that nearly 100 percent of muskellunge anglers want to catch more and bigger fish, the ramifications of these findings are important.

My former graduate professor, Mike Hansen, and his student, Matthew Faust, used data generated in Wisconsin to determine whether a consumption-oriented fishery was compatible with a trophy-oriented fishery for muskies in Wisconsin. First some background data. Angler harvest of muskellunge is governed by minimum length Limits (MLL). These MLL vary across the country. For the purpose of this study, MLL of 40, 45, and 50 inches were used.

This story is from the February/March 2017 edition of Musky Hunter.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the February/March 2017 edition of Musky Hunter.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM MUSKY HUNTERView All
What can Current Do For You?
Musky Hunter

What can Current Do For You?

WATER FLOW IN LAKES IS SUBTLE AND OFTEN OVERLOOKED. BUT MUSKIES USE IT, SO WHY SHOULDN’T YOU?

time-read
3 mins  |
February/March 2021
Mountain State Muskies In Spring
Musky Hunter

Mountain State Muskies In Spring

CATCH MUSKIES DURING TIMES WHEN NOTHING IS PREDICTABLE

time-read
4 mins  |
February/March 2021
Winter Presentations For Southern Rivers
Musky Hunter

Winter Presentations For Southern Rivers

Winter has arrived, yet in the South it’s still mild enough to keep fishing with the exception of maybe a week or two of an Arctic front.

time-read
3 mins  |
February/March 2021
Tune Up For The Season Ahead
Musky Hunter

Tune Up For The Season Ahead

Have you started making your plans for the upcoming fishing year?

time-read
3 mins  |
February/March 2021
Rob Manthei
Musky Hunter

Rob Manthei

Guide Rob Manthei’s love for the Vilas/Oneida County region of northern Wisconsin is deeply rooted. His father and grandfather started taking him there on fishing trips when he was just two years old, and he began guiding full-time at the age of 25.

time-read
6 mins  |
February/March 2021
Find The Right Structure In Deep, Clear Water
Musky Hunter

Find The Right Structure In Deep, Clear Water

With breathtaking scenery, vast amounts of water, and complex and diverse structure, clear water Canadian Shield lakes offer some of the most sought-after musky fishing in the world. A bucket-list destination for the passionate and determined angler, there’s something truly special about being in the sanctuary of the great Canadian Shield lakes.

time-read
4 mins  |
February/March 2021
Multi-Species Or Bay Boat ... You Make The Choice
Musky Hunter

Multi-Species Or Bay Boat ... You Make The Choice

Is there really such a thing as a perfect musky boat? There are so many variables to choose from in the market today. Do I want a casting or trolling boat? Aluminum or fiberglass? Welded or riveted? Do I want a tiller, side console, dual console, or full windshield?

time-read
4 mins  |
February/March 2021
Region To Region
Musky Hunter

Region To Region

Region To Region

time-read
10+ mins  |
February/March 2021
Genetic Study Yields Answers
Musky Hunter

Genetic Study Yields Answers

STUDY SUGGESTS LEECH STRAIN IS NOT THE ‘SILVER BULLET’ FOR WISCONSIN MUSKY WATERS

time-read
6 mins  |
February/March 2021
Crawling Crankbaits To Catch Cold Water Muskies
Musky Hunter

Crawling Crankbaits To Catch Cold Water Muskies

Crankbaits catch plenty of muskies during spring, summer and fall, but the key to catching ’skies in the very early cold water season on these lures involves some special tricks.

time-read
3 mins  |
February/March 2021