Creta Vs Harrier - Can We Hail A New King?
BBC TopGear India|April 2019

Have you ever wondered if you really need a full-sized, four-wheel-drive SUV? Great, we have been asking ourselves the same question. And we’ve picked the two best ones to get an answer

Debabrata Sarkar
Creta Vs Harrier - Can We Hail A New King?

These two, they don’t quite fit together, do they? There’s a rather obvious difference in their sizes, the design theme that each manufacturer has chosen and possibly the set of capabilities that you would look at either of these cars for. But, when you have roughly nineteen lakh rupees in your pocket and you go out shopping, this is the pair you are most likely to narrow down your list to. For all their differences, here are two cars that attempt to deliver the SUV experience, in two very distinct flavours - while Hyundai addresses the small, urban, understated sort of need with the Creta, Tata has chosen do the diametrically opposite with an incredibly stylish design, and coupled it with massive dimensions to represent a proper, full-sized SUV. Now do you understand what I was saying about these two making for an odd sort of picture?

It is beyond a doubt that the Hyundai Creta is the story to try and better, but many have tried already and fallen by the wayside. But, unlike the others, Tata has decided to change the rules of the game with the Harrier and attempts to snatch a bit of pie that the Creta has cornered for itself.

In case you haven’t picked one, simply based on how they look, and are thinking about an Instagram face-off, well, let me stop you there. First of all, social media knows nothing. The cat meowing is likely to win. More importantly, the number of heads the Harrier turns is incredible. I have been stopped in my parking lot late at night, have had people pull up alongside and tap my window and have seen joggers stop mid-step during their morning run. This despite the dull white it is dressed in. In fact, while we stopped for breakfast, Devesh, Rajeev and I were the only people giving the Creta a once over. And that is when we realised that apart from the shiny chrome grille and the cool design on the alloys, there really isn’t much to look at in the Creta.

This story is from the April 2019 edition of BBC TopGear India.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the April 2019 edition of BBC TopGear India.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM BBC TOPGEAR INDIAView All
Porsche Ice Experience
BBC TopGear India

Porsche Ice Experience

It's a game best played on ice with the Porsche 911 Dakar

time-read
4 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
Mercedes-Benz EQS 580
BBC TopGear India

Mercedes-Benz EQS 580

WHY IT'S HERE To prove that Mercedes-Benz is the luxe king, irrespective of what's plonked under the hood or below the cabin.

time-read
2 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
F.A.T. CAMP
BBC TopGear India

F.A.T. CAMP

Take one Goodwood Festival of Speed, shrink it down, add skis and thermal underwear... you've got a recipe for an unforgettable day

time-read
4 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
ALL Stree DOWNHILL FROM HERE
BBC TopGear India

ALL Stree DOWNHILL FROM HERE

The Challenger is dead, for now. Will the muscle car survive? We couldn't leave California without a 1,300bhp grudge match

time-read
4 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
A HIGHER POWER
BBC TopGear India

A HIGHER POWER

They're the gnarliest, toughest Porsche 911s of modern times - and they're called Doris and Edith. Altitude does funny things to your brain...

time-read
6 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
VILLAGE OF THE DAMO
BBC TopGear India

VILLAGE OF THE DAMO

What do you get when you cross an R5 Turbo with a Suzuki Jimny? This is the company that decided to find out

time-read
5 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
CINQ OR SWIM?
BBC TopGear India

CINQ OR SWIM?

The reborn Renault 5 concept promised much - does the full production version live up to the hype? Say bonjour to the EV supermini with proper Gallic flair

time-read
6 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
THE TEAM BUILDING EXERCISE FT. CITROEN C3 AIRCROSS
BBC TopGear India

THE TEAM BUILDING EXERCISE FT. CITROEN C3 AIRCROSS

The Peppy 7-seater that Helped Me Break the Ice and Make New Friends

time-read
2 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
FUEL THRIFT
BBC TopGear India

FUEL THRIFT

Experiments On The Atal Setu

time-read
2 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024
BEYOND THE "BADGE
BBC TopGear India

BEYOND THE "BADGE

A Symphony of Engineering

time-read
2 mins  |
Annual Issue 2024